Search results

  1. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    I think I've read the novel before on RR. Is it Stormbringer? Why did you change the title? Well, doesn't matter. For now, the numbers you got is definitely above average mostly due to the 'Harem' tag and being in the front page after the initial release. It'll probably slow down unless you hit...
  2. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    Normally, a novel with plain title and premise wouldn't have gotten more than 100 readers after the initial release, even with girls love. But, considering your fame as a Scribblehub author, I guess it's possible. So far, the story's fine. There are some hiccups with grammar, but nothing's too...
  3. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    Your novel sucks. The title is so bland, even bottled water has much better taste. The synopsis is as fun as watching a paint dry. Try saying it out loud without getting bored midway. The premise is terrible and insipid -- the typical trending stories on this site are miles better. As for the...
  4. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    It has the same problems as the last one. The story was presumably written for females, but the ones who consume girls love fictions are mostly males (your last story was also the same, but I only noticed it now). They usually don't care how much make up the mc had put on. Just skip to the...
  5. Hathnuz

    Feedback + suggestions (Closed)

    Could you review mine please? I wonder what are the strengths and flaws in my story. Thanks in advance. https://www.scribblehub.com/series/2738/the-magic-lumberjack/
  6. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    The story is bland. Opening with dream sequence is a terrible choice to begin a chapter. Also, there are too many unnecessary descriptions that only clutter the chapter. Like, the action tags aren't supposed to be that long. I guess he tried to follow the "show, don't tell" advice, but he ended...
  7. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    At first glance, the story has no outstanding qualities but still fine... until I read the first chapter. Damn, that was quite sad. That chapter alone might carry your story all the way to trending and break 500 readers barrier. Even though the descriptions of stuff are lacking, I guess it's...
  8. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    Well, boys love is kind of unpopular nowadays, but doesn't mean it had no chance to be in spotlight. Yours, however, has a long way to go. The title and the premise aren't interesting. The synopsis and the first chapter also need some improvement. You do have popular tags among BL readers like...
  9. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    The Island: Everything about it is boring, from title, premise, synopsis, and first chapter. There seem to be lack of compelling elements that would attract readers or keep them interested. I accidentally summoned the hero! Now what? : Much better than the previous novel. At least this one has...
  10. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    It's okay, but everything about your story is very plain. You've gotta bring something fresh if you want people to check your story out. Or use popular tags, that works too. No significant issues that I could find, only some mixed tenses here and there. Overall, less than 100 readers by chapter 30.
  11. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    After some thinking, maybe I was mistaken and too generalizing. SH readers won't really care about that unlike RR readers. So, yeah, there shouldn't be any problem with your story. As long as it doesn't slow down the story too much, blue boxes are basically required in litrpg... I think. I...
  12. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    Plain premise, title could be better, and good synopsis. But, for a litrpg novel, it sure is lacking blue boxes, and that's actually a bad thing for litrpg readers. The mc might've gotten it in the future, but I don't think your readers would wait for too long. If I were you, I would make it...
  13. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    Although your story ultilizes slightly popular tropes like Isekai and is unique, unfortunately, only very specific readers will read it. Most males don't like boys love and females prefer heavy romance in that genre, so basically the premise is problematic. Everything else is fine, though...
  14. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    Japanese LN-style titles usually will do well since not only they stand out, they also convey information without having to click on the story, but yours is the opposite. You might as well use a single-word title, then. The synopsis is fine. As for the premise, well, it's nothing out of...
  15. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    Sorry for the late feedback (again). I kinda want to do it sooner, but I decided to wait for the right moment which is today because @virgilknightley for resurrecting the thread. Your guess is probably same as mine. Everything's about the story is niche, but rather good quality. It kinda...
  16. Hathnuz

    First-time user, advice?

    Quantity over quality most of the time. Have a consistent schedule. Don't be like me. Study grammar. Not saying you're bad at it, it's just almost mandatory for writers. Title and premise are very important. Make sure your story stands out from the rest.
  17. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    Definitely! More often than not, readers won't like the rewrite because they have to start all over again, or worse the old one was better. The safest option would be to ask their opinion first before proceeding. I, too, made this mistake, though I was kinda lucky that they still liked the rewrite.
  18. Hathnuz

    Does anyone wanna talk about magic and badass paladins from my book with me?

    Paladins in eastern stories, especially isekais are usually just a bunch of one-dimensional zealot hypocrites lol. I do have them in my story and I'm still researching about them. So, I've got some questions for you, oh paladin slut Can paladins use ranged weapons? Like bows or crossbows. What...
  19. Hathnuz

    I can predict whether your story will become popular or not

    Welp, sorry for the late reply. I've been busy lately. Yeah, you just struck gold and nailed everything what makes stories popular in scribblehub with that story. Other than it's tad bit cliched (but good cliche), I have nothing to criticize, so instead, I'll just give you an advice: don't go...
  20. Hathnuz

    Post your weapon and I'll tell you what I think of it from my weapon enthusiast perspective

    Weapon Name and type: Crimson Carnage - Poleaxe Physical description: Description: A two-handed, single-edge ax forged in a rundown workshop by the MC. The head is made of a special alloy that allows the user to cast enchantments without damaging the blade and with maximum efficiency. The...
Top