Could you write a book you didn't care about?

Sylver

Writer/Lover of Monster Girl Smut Content <3
Joined
Oct 11, 2023
Messages
584
Points
133
My work carries my passion and care into it. I can maybe pull something out of my butt to work with, or tweak the story or direction to make it more to my liking. But overall, if a story I am working on struggles to have my interest, the readers will be able to tell real soon.

But hey if I'm getting paid good money for it then I'll give it my best even if it's not a story I'm personally invested in :blob_evil_two: in contrast, if the payment is enough to live comfortably then you have my interest and you bet I will begin to invest some creativity and passion into this story.

As long as it's not something super boring. Heck I will gladly write LitRPG stories if I'm getting a check for it every week or two, and I will do my best to write a darn good LitRPG story for you :blob_paint:
Hell, there's been a couple times people have offered me upwards of $500 to write them a weird fetish story. I took one look at what they were into and
Point that sucker my way, buster! :p
 

AliceMoonvale

Honorary White Asian Girl
Joined
Nov 15, 2025
Messages
598
Points
93
Nope.

If I was somehow able to land a gig or something where I had to write LitRPG, I wouldn't do it. Unless it was an absurd amount of money that would be worth my mental anguish. Until that highly unlikely scenario happens, I only write things I give a shit about. lmao
 

Devilish

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 16, 2023
Messages
19
Points
53
I can’t even manage to write the ones I care about,Unless I’m very well paid, It’s already a miserable job to have to proofread and revise a text or a book I don’t like just for money, so if I’m expected to write something I don’t care about, I’ll need a lot of financial incentive.
 

CinnaSloth

Spicy Angry Latina 💢🌶️🤌
Joined
Nov 20, 2024
Messages
532
Points
108
Despite knowing that litrpgs are the easiest way to break into the webnovel market, it took me years to write one because I had no interest at all in the genre. I tried once or twice to write a litrpg simply for the attention it could get me, but I always gave up after one or two chapters because I wasn't emotionally invested in the project at all. If I don't feel anything for the story I'm writing, I can't write it. Simple as. It wasn't until I came up with a plot, world, and characters that I actually wanted to tell a story about that I was finally able to write XNPC.

What about you? Would you be able to write a book just because the genre is popular and you could potentially earn money off of it, even if you didn't have an emotional connection to the story or characters?

I didn't even know what a LitRPG was before I wrote one. it's the same as writing any story, just add a few stupid numbers.
and before anyone gets on my case for "stupid numbers" I can show you my maths, and my statistics. Goodluck actually reading it. :blob_evil:
There isn't an author alive who can write in every genre on earth. Even the most skilled and prolific writers specialize in a small handful of genres. For you to claim that genre doesn't matter is one of the most pretentious thing a writer could possibly say.

Guarantee, I have a backlog of books in my archive. Just because I personally don't like the genre or the story, doesn't mean I haven't written one. I needed to know what genres I could sell, and I was advised to write a variety of genres to know which I was good at. The ones I felt I was personally good at were fantasy, and romance. but I've written more than a couple dozen books that won't ever be published, not because they aren't written well, but because I choose not to try with them. I would dislike it if they sold well and were expected to write more when I'd rather write something else. But that rolls into the next part-
That depends. You'd definitely have have a connection to your paycheck, but does that extend to you having a connection to the story itself? Or would the promise of being paid be enough for you to hunker down and suffer through a story you wouldn't have wanted to write otherwise?

How much are we talking? because a good pay in advance would aid me in reconsidering what genres i like. I personally hate writing scifi, and mystery. It's too complicated to have great mystery and puzzles and describing futuristic technology when half the population is dumber than rocks. They complain everything, especially if the fictional death ray is powerful enough to be a death ray... "is it even possible?" unless you hand hold them through every step of the process its a pointless endeavor, and by then... UGH just shoot the main protagonist, I quit. Do some math yourselves... (gets handed large sack of money), WHAT I MEANT to say was people are geniuses, and im dumb, and I have a need to explain completely how case 1 was solved with the use of a single paperclip, fully describing every detail in order to get my own stupidity out of the way. Please, enjoy the story. Next book will be out in three months.
Hell, there's been a couple times people have offered me upwards of $500 to write them a weird fetish story. I took one look at what they were into and
View attachment 44600

?? Hold my chardonnay, child.
$500 for a simple smut fetish fanfic? Easy money.
I have a file named "For the love of your soul do not open" within "im telling you no" within "these are for paid commissions" within "whoever reads this stop" within "If you are reading this go no further" within "mature only" within "18+ don't open"
Not even joking. people on Ao3 are freaky af. but money is all green, baby (and sometimes funny colors with weird lookin people.)
==============
what can I say. Money is money
would I sell feet pics? who's to say i don't?
 

CountVanBadger

Definitely not an overgrown skunk in a suit
Joined
Nov 5, 2025
Messages
377
Points
93
Just because I personally don't like the genre or the story, doesn't mean I haven't written one.
And just because you've written something doesn't mean you've written something well.
I needed to know what genres I could sell
The reason you're not able to sell them being because you can't write them well. By testing yourself, you find out what genres you're best at and which ones you're not, which tells you which genres you should specialize in. That's different than just saying "Genre doesn't matter, I can write literally anything I want."
 

CinnaSloth

Spicy Angry Latina 💢🌶️🤌
Joined
Nov 20, 2024
Messages
532
Points
108
And just because you've written something doesn't mean you've written something well.

The reason you're not able to sell them being because you can't write them well. By testing yourself, you find out what genres you're best at and which ones you're not, which tells you which genres you should specialize in. That's different than just saying "Genre doesn't matter, I can write literally anything I want."

True. Not everything is at the standard i would want for a published work, so i didn't publish it, but from what i've seen on the market, i don't think either of these points matter. People will buy slop, and garbage, and call it a bestseller. Genre still doesn't matter. If you write a genre long enough you'll get good at it. I wrote what came easy; didn't mean i was bad at anything else. it just took more time.
 

CountVanBadger

Definitely not an overgrown skunk in a suit
Joined
Nov 5, 2025
Messages
377
Points
93
If you write a genre long enough you'll get good at it.
Not necessarily. Like I keep saying, there hasn't been a single author in all of history who has been able to successfully write in every single genre. Even the most prolific authors specialize in a small handful of genres. Stephen King has the widest assortment of genres under his belt that I can think of off the top of my head, but he still doesn't write romance, historical biographies, sports fiction, or comedies. Everyone has limits, and claiming to be the exception to that rule is pretentious as hell.
 

CinnaSloth

Spicy Angry Latina 💢🌶️🤌
Joined
Nov 20, 2024
Messages
532
Points
108
so im pretentious. You claiming everyone has limits in their skill is naive just because you're incapable doesn't mean anyone else is. Writers write what they want not because they're incapable. They specialize because they can pump out a book every 3 months to make money. RL stine specialized in kids horror because he could swing it out every other week. Di you know he ALSO wrote fantasy, light and dark, scifi, joke books, and even adult novels? supernatural? mystery?
Yes, also stephen king
Isaac Asimov
Michael Crichton
neil gaiman
McCarthy
Hardy
It isn't a difficult thing. YOU are the one who cant do it. Call any of these authors and call them pretentious for accomplishing something you cant.
 

CountVanBadger

Definitely not an overgrown skunk in a suit
Joined
Nov 5, 2025
Messages
377
Points
93
so im pretentious. You claiming everyone has limits in their skill is naive just because you're incapable doesn't mean anyone else is. Writers write what they want not because they're incapable.
Claiming you have no limits is pretentious. You're a human being, not a god. All the typos and and grammatical errors you made in just those three(?) sentences I quoted prove that you have plenty of limitations, and the fact that you can't see them isn't a good sign.
 

CinnaSloth

Spicy Angry Latina 💢🌶️🤌
Joined
Nov 20, 2024
Messages
532
Points
108
Claiming you have no limits is pretentious. You're a human being, not a god. All the typos and and grammatical errors you made in just those three(?) sentences I quoted prove that you have plenty of limitations, and the fact that you can't see them isn't a good sign.

ah yes. a random online forum thread is a basis for my talent. sure. great argument cause i was going to publish debate. ah im ruined. lol
get over yourself. a god, me pff. no but thanks for assuming i thought of myself as such. ?
 

CountVanBadger

Definitely not an overgrown skunk in a suit
Joined
Nov 5, 2025
Messages
377
Points
93
ah yes. a random online forum thread is a basis for my talent. sure. great argument cause i was going to publish debate. ah im ruined. lol
get over yourself. a god, me pff. no but thanks for assuming i thought of myself as such. ?
...okay, sure, whatever. You have no limits and are capable of doing what literally nobody in history has ever been able to do. And instead of using your freakishly extraordinary talent to become a multi billionaire bestselling author, you're publishing your stories for free on a website that's famous for the sheer amount of smut it hosts.

1767636692789.gif
 

CinnaSloth

Spicy Angry Latina 💢🌶️🤌
Joined
Nov 20, 2024
Messages
532
Points
108
...okay, sure, whatever. You have no limits and are capable of doing what literally nobody in history has ever been able to do. And instead of using your freakishly extraordinary talent to become a multi billionaire bestselling author, you're publishing your stories for free on a website that's famous for the sheer amount of smut it hosts.

View attachment 44638

Yes, actually. I'm one of those smut writers. :blobthumbsup: Most of my money goes to my exwife.
Are there any other assumptions about me you'd love to throw out? Because you're just digging your own hole at how miserable you are by comparison. I can write what i put my mind to, so can most of the people on this thread. You asked, and plenty of people said sure, if you give them enough incentive. What's your problem? Laziness? Time? sounds more like skill issue to me. Pick up a book. Learn something.
 
Top