For me this still misses on the Rank D exam theme.
I keep repeating this over an over (sorry!



) but I absolutely want to see failure/loss as part of the Rank D exam. It's frankly the only good point in the entire level progression that a serious roadblock in character development makes sense. At higher levels, characters start getting sufficiently strong enough that a roadblock can't be forced.
Maybe not everyone is happy to hear this, but I don't want to see any character smoothly surfing from level 1 to level 40 easily as if its a piece of cake to grind your way to level 40 in a straight upward trajectory. Rather, I have the view that characters
need to experience failure. Most players seem to want to see their characters smoothly succeeding at every step of the way (even if they end up very battered), but I think giving characters a sense of defeat is essential at some point in their journey. The Rank D exam is the most convenient place to force characters to
hit a low point (whether that is physically, emotionally, morally, or something else).
I'm highly reluctant to push an exam where the main conclusion is: "I need to make my character stronger / more OP!"
It's a very delicate balance, because if you push an exam that involves a laundry list of herculean feats, unless it's constructed in a sensitive way, people are somehow going to find a way to power their characters through without hitting that failure -- which misses the whole thematic point of the exam.
In either case, IMO this suggestion is a little to too specific, and it rehashes the Rank E exam too closely. I don't really see where the guild stands to benefit on sending Adventurer's on such a risky mission while intentionally handicapping their adventurers. It doesn't quite have the weight or significance that the Gelderholm Rank D exam has.
My personal view is that the Guild hands on Rank D promotions to adventurers who experience a
heavy trial and sacrifice in the line of duty (e.g. in war). If the character didn't make a heavy sacrifice, I personally don't think they earned the Rank D.
I prefer this much better -- as in making an impossible choice.
It fits the theme that I am looking for.