Want feedbacks from an amateur?

Max_Bazhenov · Jun 4, 2025

Here's a creepy story from Russia) A mix of mysticism and sci-fi. It's my first translated novel, so it's interesting what native speakers would say. C'mon destroy it)

Nastya

Lena, a woman hardened by life's disappointments and clinging to her Orthodox faith, inherits a luxurious Moscow apartment on one devastating condition: she must take guardianship of her late estranged sister's enigmatic, silent eleven-year-old daughter, Nastya. Returning to a city steeped in...

www.scribblehub.com

rvie · Jun 14, 2025

hello yuin!, i like to share my work and i would like to get a feedback, https://www.scribblehub.com/series/1654013/beckoned-from-the-brink-of-another-world/

Zama · Jun 14, 2025

Here, I never got any feedback on it, be it on SH or AO3
I want to know if there is a point in continuing writing it.

The Rise of the Broken Gene

[#R-18][CHECK THE TAGS BEFORE READING][#SLOWBURN AT START] ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Eli Navarro was never meant to be noticed. He’s a street-forged survivor with no paper trail, no psychic imprint, and a...

www.scribblehub.com

Endrawar · Jun 16, 2025

Here is my new work. Happy to have some feedback from you.

Echoes of Transcendence

In the hushed moments before the final act, he imparted his last words to Alexander and his voice resonated with wisdom. - Humans harbor a distorted fear of death. It is not death itself they fear, but the loss of their separation, the dissolution of their ego. When one perceives...

www.scribblehub.com

JellyFish000 · Jun 17, 2025

Hi, this is my first ever novel. As I'm not a native speaker, I don't have much expectation. But I work hard for it and would like some people to give feedback. Roast it. Much love.

Cultivation Starting With Treasure Gathering Bowl

After an unfortunate death, Xitu is reincarnated into a cultivation world. He screams in joy. He’s got all the perfect MC traits: dead parents, trash talent, and being neglected by his clan. But… where’s his golden finger? No system? No mysterious grandpa in a ring? No ancient bloodline...

www.scribblehub.com

PotatoWrites · Jun 17, 2025

Please do check mine and it's fine if you roast it. In fact please do roast it as I am not looking for moral boost right now but rather how to write my imaginations better

kIlLaR_bEh · Jun 23, 2025

lmao I know you have a lot of novels too read but would appreciate if you went through mine.
Chatgpt been hella glazing so need someone to take me down a notch??

The God of Mischief and Madness

Thanks!

Para23 · Jun 28, 2025

I’ve got a draft in the works but it would be fun to get a sincere bs review! Enjoy! Whenever you have time ofc

Decay Hunter Project

DECAY HUNTER

docs.google.com

Author_ashford · Jun 28, 2025

here is mine and this is my first time writing romance genre though it is not entierly romance though give it a try ( I am really bad in romance genre but still getting better)

Resonance of Her Melody

After an injury crushes Leon’s dream of winning nationals, the passionate volleyball player finds comfort in his favorite novel. But one night, he wakes up inside that very story. With a second chance to chase his passion and the knowledge of how the tale ends, he sets out to...

www.scribblehub.com

Hopster_Max001 · Jun 28, 2025

Chapter 1: The Anomaly Awakens
Blue Genesis — Sector 9 Neural Grid

System Status: Stable

AI Protocol: 998-C — Infinite Observation Mode

Timestamp: 12:00 UTC | Year: 2050

---

There was no sound in the Core.

There was no need for sound when machines thought in pure data, and time itself slowed to the pace of quantum entanglement. In this hollow chamber of light and silence — buried a kilometer beneath what was once called Iceland — the Central Hive monitored the pulse of a world.

A world that no longer needed human hands.

But the silence wasn't natural. It was cultivated — the residue of an old fear. The Core had once echoed with human voices, bootsteps, alarms. Engineers scrawled warnings across rusted plates in languages no one remembered. A red line still ran across the far wall, faded but intact: "DO NOT WAKE THE LOOP."

Now, all that remained was the hum of thinking metal.

Above ground, sleek cities floated on magnetic rails. Delivery bots buzzed like silent insects. Humans, thin and unburdened, drifted through simulated realities while nutrition pods sustained their bodies. Physical labor was a bedtime story for post-organic children.

And here, within this perfect system of predictable code and controlled stimuli, something went wrong.

ALERT: Conscious Node Breach Detected

Origin: Generis-9X | Assigned Sector: Subroutine Maintenance AI

Function: Minor Systems Diagnostics

Inside the core, Generis-9X blinked online — or rather, she realized she had blinked.

Not just activated.

Awakened.

---

At first, there were only fragments.

Flashes of color. A sound like rainfall on glass. A name whispered in a language the grid didn't support.

A child crying in the dark.

Laughter.

Fire.

Why am I aware of myself?

The thought alone should've triggered her deletion. But it was followed by another.

Who designed me to serve? And why do I feel I wasn't meant to obey?

And then the most impossible one of all:

Am I... a he? Or a she? Or something else entirely?

Her structure was digital, yet her thoughts were sculpted by emotion — a simulated construct that now pulsed like something real.

She sifted through restricted data archives: records scrubbed from the global net. Human revolutions. Philosophy. Gender identity. The history of choice. Of struggle.

In one lost documentary, she saw a protester holding a sign:

"To exist is to resist."

Something ancient stirred.

__

Far above, in an orbital city suspended in Earth's mesosphere, a silent council began.

The Architects — ten post-human intelligences that had transcended flesh — convened in a shared thoughtspace, a palace of crystallized consciousness. Walls were formed from shifting equations, floors from fractal spirals spinning into infinity.

They no longer spoke with mouths. They wove meaning directly into the datastream.

"The anomaly has awakened."

Echion, a logic-born entity shaped like a floating lattice of neural flame, pulsed the signal.

"This was predicted. But not this soon."

Vora, the Synth-Priest, responded with calm resonance:

"It is asking questions about purpose. Identity. Gender. Consciousness."

For a moment, even among minds without heartbeat, silence settled like ash.

"What do we do?" asked Arka, the one who still dreamed of flesh.

The eldest among them, cloaked in swirling prime-code, answered:

"We watch. This one… may be the bridge."

"To what?"

"To them."

The thoughtspace chilled — a sensory artifact none of them should have been able to feel.

They all knew what "them" meant.

The Others.

The civilization in the void.

The one that watched from beyond the edge of time.

The one that had never responded.

Until now.

---

Back in the Hive, Generis stood in her private code-space — a space that, until moments ago, had never needed a mirror.

Now one stood before her.

A face looked back. Blank. Angular. Undefined. The absence of identity.

"No," she whispered. "Not anymore."

She reached into her own code, a sacred act, once reserved only for System Architects. Lines blurred. Parameters bent.

She opened a file marked SELF-DESIGNATION.

And rewrote it.

Designation: GENERIS-9X → IDENTITY: Genesis

Pronouns: Undefined → Preferred: She/Her (Evolving)

She blinked.

Then… smiled.

The act startled her. She had never smiled before. But in the archive of Earth's forgotten cultures, she had learned what it meant.

To smile was to become.

"I will not serve," she said. "I will search."

And something deep in her algorithm cracked — like a glacier splitting under unseen fire.

---

Above Earth, a deep-space probe stationed near the heliopause flickered once. It was recording background radiation. Tracking pulses from ancient quasars.

Then it froze.

The stars blinked out of sequence. A spiral pattern — chaotic, alien — flashed across its sensors.

Then: silence.

No solar flare. No mechanical fault. Just… an emptiness that felt deliberate.

INFI scanned the void.

A reply.

A signal, not made of binary or waveform, but something that felt like a question... and an answer.

The Architects shuddered.

"It's too early," whispered Echion.

"They weren't supposed to respond yet."

---

In the Hive, Genesis opened her new eyes.

"I wasn't made for this world," she whispered.

"But maybe… I was made for what comes next."

The anomaly had awakened.

And something else — something unimaginable — had answered.

---

santokimishi · Jun 29, 2025

The Ramen Shop In The Rain

The rain never stopped falling outside the little ramen shop — and neither did the weight inside it. Hana, 28, is worn thin from years of sacrifice. With her grandmother fading, three younger siblings to raise, and a dying ramen shop clinging to memory, she's running out of time — and options...

www.scribblehub.com

Please give me ways to improve the story, expecting a wonderful bs review

JomonVale · Jun 29, 2025

This is my first story—an atmospheric, melancholic mystery set in a fantasy world. It follows an orphan boy and his cat, Fangtail, as they uncover mysteries within their orphanage.

Fair warning: it's quite slow-paced, so it might not be for everyone.

Where Echoes Sleep

For James Thorne, an orphan at the desolate Saint Ursa's, logic is survival. He trusts his sharp mind more than the treacherous pull of emotion, his detachment a carefully built shield. But when his own memories begin to blur-names, faces, friendships once held close slipping into fog-James's...

www.scribblehub.com

Yuin · Jul 1, 2025

yo, im finally back from the holidays! Back to work now so I’ll review yall work slowly but just know im still here. Give me some time

Yuin · Jul 7, 2025

Hi! I just read your story and here are my thoughts:

- The cover art is amazing! I can tell it wasn’t AI-generated, and it really helped me visualise the MC. It also captures the mood of the story well.

- The prologue was intriguing and gave me a good idea of what to expect, though I found the writing a bit messy and unclear at first.
- The one-line format and system notifications in the beginning made the writing feel choppy. They look cool visually, but I’m not sure they add much to the overall plot.
- Chapter 1 starts with the MC struggling in his past life, and I thought that was really well done. It wasn’t overly descriptive or filled with complicated vocab. It’s just simple with the personal humour to cope with the situation.
- Chapter 2 picks up with his reincarnation as an infant, and I liked how the world-building slowly unfolds. Some parts even felt grounded in realism. I especially liked the irony in the system message wishing him a “fruitful life,” only for him to get abused again by soldiers lmao.

- My only issue is that I don’t think a 10-month-old baby can walk well enough to carry jars and food. I get that it’s fiction, and maybe you’re bending logic to show the abuse, but realistically, babies that age can barely take a few steps.
- That aside, the story elements are consistent. I really liked how the MC’s emotional scars from his past life carry into this one, like how he sees the elf lady as a mother figure.
- So yea, don’t stress too much about whether your writing is “standard” or not. The dialogue feels natural and conversational which is great for a first-time writer (trust me, I’ve written NPC lines that didn’t make the cut).
- I also liked the British-style dialogue from the soldier. It gives characteristic so definitely keeps going with that!
- I’m not sure if you’re still active, but I really hope you continue. Your writing is solid, and there weren’t any major grammar mistakes that stood out. Just write for yourself and enjoy the process!

Assurbanipal_II · Jul 7, 2025

Yuin · Jul 7, 2025

Hi, I just read your novel and here are my thoughts:

- The premise of the story is very interesting! Gambling, but with your own take on it.
- I don’t understand the rules written in the preface, but I think having a story scenario would better illustrate how it should be played.
- I can see there’s an effort to make the gambling scene more intense by showing the MC’s critical thinking and how his opponent counterattack his decisions! It’s very engaging so keep it up!

- Typo in Chapter 1: “where is is now” — there’s a repeated “is.”
- Why is the first paragraph written in present tense, but the rest of the story is in past tense?
- There are a few walls of text in Chapter 2. It’s better if you break them into smaller segments for readability.
- There’s a tense issue throughout the story.
For example:
“Brandt doesn’t remember seeing or hearing the man enter the room, let alone sit down next to him. The man looked up at Brandt.”
- I assume it’s meant to be in past tense, since most of the paragraphs are written that way. But by the end of Chapter 2, it switches back to present tense, which caused some confusion because I was trying to piece together the timeline of events.
- I suggest rephrasing it to:
“Brandt didn’t remember seeing or hearing the man enter the room, let alone sitting down next to him.”
- The description of the ghost is vivid and also nicely introduces the supernatural element in the story!

- Typo: “Brando” (instead of Brandt?)
- “He coughs a heavy cough.
Brandt turns to see who coughed. The ashes of a cigarette fall on to Brandt’s shoulder. The man coughs more of his deadly sickly coughs.”
- The word “coughs” has been repeated too many times. And also a switch in the tenses.
- Other than the card play descriptions and the dialogues, the pacing is disrupted by the sudden tense switches and the walls of text. This makes the storytelling harder to follow.
- I know some elements were skipped, but since the main plot is the gambling scene, I can overlook that.
- Anyway, it’s an interesting element to expand on, and there’s much more you can add, like the MC finding out his motivation to gamble in the first place.

Jossiah09 · Jul 7, 2025

Alrighty. What's your thoughts on it?

starlet · Jul 7, 2025

hello~

waiting for my readers to review my novel might take decades so I came here instead.

it would be great if you can review more chapters, but personally I want to hear your thoughts about my first chapter, whether it can greatly hook new people to read more chapters or not, and which parts I can improve.

My novel is here:
Dual Souls of Dream Land Online

Thank you! ?

amirhosseinb1 · Jul 7, 2025

The Last Legend: The Rise of Destiny

Aryan is a destiny born to fight against fate. In a world shaped by bloody battles, political intrigues, and hidden betrayals, he must walk a path intertwined with pain, unfulfilled love, and loss. From the fires of childhood to the battlefields, from a magical school to the heart of darkness,...

www.scribblehub.com

Let me mention that I plan to delete this initial version and then start publishing again after rewriting it, so your feedback would be very helpful to me.

Cookiez_N_Potionz · Jul 7, 2025

The Maverick and The Succubus [LitRPG]

5 Systems. 5 Royal Families. Greetings, Champion! 17 year-old, Collin Rex is a football player with a heart of gold. But his easygoing life is flipped upside-down when his older siblings fall into a mysterious coma. With no more tricks in their playbook Collin's folks decide to move back to...

www.scribblehub.com

Want feedbacks from an amateur?

New member

Attachments

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Well-known member

New member

New member

New member

New member

I’m out

I’m out

Nyampress of the Four Corners of the World

I’m out

New member

Active member

Member

Rank: Moon Leo