question on R-18 ratings, mature, ecchi tags, and minors...

naosu

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2020
Messages
336
Points
83
So... I had a thought. I'm trying to create an alternate life for the reader. I'm not creating a story. I'm creating THEIR Isekai experience as another person in another world! Its kind of fun to think this way. I'm giving them another life.

So because of that, I'm trying to capture their life and a chapter is their experiences...

Because of this, I can focus on some parts more than others. And other parts of the day can be summarized. Like I can say...

~6 AM Main character had sex with wife in the shower.
~6:40 AM got dressed.
~7:15 went to work.

Then have the real action in the chapter. The real chapter will be there. The other parts are just there to help the reader feel like they are experiencing a real life in the other world.

But here's where my question is; OK, by the above lines. The reader will read, OK he had sex with his wife in the shower before going to work. But its SUMMARIZED and not descriptive. (Some will be dismayed reading this LOL). OK< but my question is, because its summarized does that mean it has to have 18+ warnings now? Is it not readable by minors now? I don't have a steamy romance scene there. In fact its kind of like when you watch a movie and a couple runs into the bedroom and shuts the door, and then you hear them jump on the bed. But you only see a closed door and scene changes to the next morning.

But it remains a question, OK is this actually still going to require the 18+, the ecchi, the mature, the adult tags now? And are people going to be able to read it who are minors if all the adult scenes are written this way?

This could affect how a book is labeled and marketed. Also it might invite more family friendly options to people and good stories.

I hope to hear what you think? I'm also very interested in this. (But it doesn't mean every scene has to be summarized. You can still write it up how you like.) And I'm hoping to ask this to be able to reach more people, and be more family friendly. And part of this is... when you read a book you want that other Isekai life. That experience. It means...when you read a steamy romance scene, its not always the sex you want. Its the romance, that hope for the other person to want you and be with you. When people read steamy scenes, they think they want the Sex. But actually many of them just want the companionship and loyalty.
 

Empress_Omnii

Gay. Girl. Gay. Girl. Gay.
Joined
Oct 13, 2023
Messages
738
Points
133
he had sex with his wife in the shower before going to work. But its SUMMARIZED and not descriptive.
As far as I know, that should be r-15. But you could just... not have the sex scene. Readers can make assumptions from fade to blacks or you could show them being... happy after the shower with their significant other.
 

naosu

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2020
Messages
336
Points
83
As far as I know, that should be r-15. But you could just... not have the sex scene. Readers can make assumptions from fade to blacks or you could show them being... happy after the shower with their significant other.
That's an idea too. Thanks.
Not sure about most of your questions. But shower sex is way over rated
Well that was an example. I'm trying to look at more than 1 way of doing things, and how it affects what you have the RATING/warnings for.
As far as I know, that should be r-15. But you could just... not have the sex scene. Readers can make assumptions from fade to blacks or you could show them being... happy after the shower with their significant other.
I'm trying to create a full look of what their new life is like. So yes, I am looking at moving away from steamy scenes. But it is harder to catch readers without them. That's why I'm kind of stuck with have them or don't... plus I do want to transition also a way from harem story to be now family story (with harem elements).
 

Empress_Omnii

Gay. Girl. Gay. Girl. Gay.
Joined
Oct 13, 2023
Messages
738
Points
133
That's an idea too. Thanks.

Well that was an example. I'm trying to look at more than 1 way of doing things, and how it affects what you have the RATING/warnings for.

I'm trying to create a full look of what their new life is like. So yes, I am looking at moving away from steamy scenes. But it is harder to catch readers without them. That's why I'm kind of stuck with have them or don't... plus I do want to transition also a way from harem story to be now family story (with harem elements).
oh. I take back what I said. If it's harem you'll be expected to have a lot of smut. I say just make it r-18... readers will likely want smut everywhere
 

naosu

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2020
Messages
336
Points
83
oh. I take back what I said. If it's harem you'll be expected to have a lot of smut. I say just make it r-18... readers will likely want smut everywhere
So you think people might pick it up just looking for the R-18 tag? LOL.
 

Empress_Omnii

Gay. Girl. Gay. Girl. Gay.
Joined
Oct 13, 2023
Messages
738
Points
133
So you think people might pick it up just looking for the R-18 tag? LOL.
No. I know most people will pick it up for that. The site is called smuthub for a reason. A large number of the readers here just adore smut... or something? I don't interact with the smutty stuff here.
 

Anonjohn20

Pen holding member
Joined
Mar 22, 2023
Messages
1,892
Points
153
Not sure about most of your questions. But shower sex is way over rated
Your shower (and mine, honestly) is too small. Banging someone in warm water and then not having to worry about getting dirty as you can clean up immediately is great assuming you can do so comfortably.
shower 1.png
shower 2.png
shower 3.png
shower 4.png
 

Rezcore

Well Hewn Timber
Joined
Aug 18, 2022
Messages
1,095
Points
153
Top