Can someone review my story (don't hold back)

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,572
Points
158
I am new writer , I particularly don't know if the way I am writing is correct , I didn't learn it , just used chatgpt to know a normal LN format and tried to emitate it , I welcome all critcism , I don't have anyone I know who would read it so I would be really happy if someone could help me out
https://www.scribblehub.com/series/2095730/demonic-angel--the-hope-of-the-unwanted/
First, learn to spell "imitate."
Then learn that imitating an imposter (which is essentially what ChatGPT and all the other AI platforms is - it PRETENDS to be able to do things by polling a pool of language models, using your prompts, and tossing together what it thinks YOU want to see) is not the way to become good at anything.
Find real novels (on or off line), real authors, imitate them for a while until you find your own voice, then start over, and only use AI programs if you are stuck or need an immediate editor.
 

FoxyXop

New member
Joined
Jan 7, 2026
Messages
10
Points
3
First, learn to spell "imitate."
Then learn that imitating an imposter (which is essentially what ChatGPT and all the other AI platforms is - it PRETENDS to be able to do things by polling a pool of language models, using your prompts, and tossing together what it thinks YOU want to see) is not the way to become good at anything.
Find real novels (on or off line), real authors, imitate them for a while until you find your own voice, then start over, and only use AI programs if you are stuck or need an immediate editor.
Thanks for the advice, any novel you would suggest which have a simple story but with good writing?
If you have to play with fonts to grab people's interest, then you just admitted that your story isn't entertaining enough to be worth reading.
My idea is good and unique but people reading it for the first time doesn't know that, they just clicked on it because it sounded interesting to them.I just need grasp their attention in the start, and after 1 or 3 parts they would be intrigued to know what happens next
I'm reading
Thanks
You didn't use AI.
You are struggling to learn yourself.
And for that you deserve praise.
Keep improving.
Thanks
You didn't use AI.
You are struggling to learn yourself.
And for that you deserve praise.
Keep improving.
Thanks
Practice practice practice. Read a lot, so you can get a feel for sentence structure and pacing. Get a thesaurus, or look one up online, and replace any commonly repeated words. I am an old school writer, (or just plain old ?) and remember reading a paperback thesaurus for ideas. But the best thing you can do is keep writing. It can be easy to get disillusioned, but if it’s something you are truly passionate about, keep at it :)
I will, thanks
You didn't use AI.
You are struggling to learn yourself.
And for that you deserve praise.
Keep improving.
Thanks
Practice practice practice. Read a lot, so you can get a feel for sentence structure and pacing. Get a thesaurus, or look one up online, and replace any commonly repeated words. I am an old school writer, (or just plain old ?) and remember reading a paperback thesaurus for ideas. But the best thing you can do is keep writing. It can be easy to get disillusioned, but if it’s something you are truly passionate about, keep at it :)
I will, thanks
 
Last edited:

Nolff

An attractive male of unspecified gender.
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
2,126
Points
153
I installed Grammarly as you described, and am using 6 or 7 to end a sentence to show suspense or silence, and I am using italic for dialogue to make them easy to distinguish from the other parts, and I am working on the' she says, he thinks' problem, and I bold only words that would catch a persons a eye and continue to grasp their interest and i change paragraph to make space between dialogue and making it easier to read, could you also suggest some begginer friendly webnovel/light novel to start and I didn't refuse to read others work, I just don't know people who could tell me what to read, I even asked my english teacher to read my story but he didnt read it either and overall thanks for the in depth review, As an 15 year-old its really hard for me to know what am I doing wrong, I appreciate you helping out
Say, how much novels have you read in the past 3 years?

Just to see how deep you are in terms of this author stuff.

Also, I have only skim the beginning of the first chapter, and I already see things you gotta work on. Not just can, but SHOULD be work on. The synopsis isn't really nice to see at all. Informative, telling me what's the story is about? Yes. Is it intriguing? No. Redundancy is a b*tch. If you can't think of any other words to describe someone's expression or something, I suggest reading more novels, especially those within the same genre as your novel.

And then Tatami's father looks towards Tatami who was seven year old and looking at his dead mother's photos, feeling soulless and emotionless, then we see Tatami's father with a menacing smile, hinting that he was about to do something really sinnister, and the scene shifts and we see a car stopping at a stormy night and Tatami is kicked out and his father throws some cash and an key to an apartment and says

I have forged your death certificate, so now you are also legally dead to me. Survive if you can
I'll be genuine with giving an advice, sorry in advance if I somehow caused some anger in you.

When telling stories, don't tell the stories like you're literally and textually telling the stories from a reviewer standpoint. Using "we" is like describing, instead of giving the audience a tale to listen or read. Like those narrators from documentary videos.

"In the wildlife of the Amazon forest, we see various floras and faunas."
"His father gave a death stare at his son, Parker, one akin to how a predator would stare at its prey. No one in the room saw that, but Joelle."


You see the difference between the two lines above? That's the difference between telling and showing.
Regarding the 'show don't tell' rule, it's something you should study and, more importantly, apply in the real world. It's not just good, but AMAZING to have, almost anything that requires communication between one person to another can be affected just by applying this rule. Be it the result of a presentation, a casual conversation, or even bigger, a high-tier international conference. You could really persuade people to believe your lies even.

In literacy, 'show don't tell' applies differently from the movies' and games' 'show don't tell'. When in movies and games, 'tell' means you're giving context of the story of said movies or games through a character or texts, outright telling you the context of what is happening in the story. For example: Cortana from the Halo game series. She is an example of how 'tell' is usually used. You can find her scenes in the game series on Youtube, and I advise you to do so because I want you to imagine this. Imagine you're playing the game, trying to understand the world around you and its events. But then, instead of learning it yourself through experience, someone just blurts out an essay-worth of paragraphs about basically the entire events and the reasons of said events even happening. Does that looks fun to you? In my opinion, it's not. This breaks immersion, and immediately you don't want to play the game anymore since even if you play the game to the end, what will you get anyways, money? Of course not, it's a game with story! And the story is supposed to be interesting to learn!

'Show' on the other side is a technique of story-telling that has been used by many successful works. Any great movies, games, novels, or comics have used this technique since the age of when literacy was born, and that's a lot of century ago. In movies and games, you learning about the world through its environments, the setting, minor interactions between characters that seems to be just banters but actually serves context of how the world operates, etc etc, is what 'show' is. For example: In the game Half-Life, instead of telling what your objective is as a researcher with a hazardous environment suit from the get go, the game lets you figure out what is happening through visual and audio. Like when you first encounter a Headcrab, a crab-like alien creature that will lunge at you when you enter their lunge radius. The game revolves around story and combat, yes you will have guns to use, and yet, the first time you met a hostile that can hurt you, the game didn't tell you that you can just ignore the enemies and move on to continue advancing through, no. Instead, it lets you meet the least dangerous enemy without a weapon inside a room/chamber with a door to the next room. What will you do in that situation when you don't have a weapon and is a little scared of what the creature can do? Avoid it and run? Correct! Because after doing so, you'll learn that you don't need to engage a fight with every enemies in the game to get through places. This will not just saves a lot of bullet and keep your health on good numbers, but also saves a lot of time and deaths that would otherwise frustrates you because of needing to retry over and over.

Alright, enough of my ramblings.

Your weakness overall is in the technical side of things. That is your grammar, your writing style, etc etc. Not gonna talk about plot or characters because you are definitely lacking in the technical side of writing. Like what the others have suggested, read more novels. And my suggestion personally, read and understand how people write their story. And maybe watch in-depth analysis of movies, games, or novels from each respective medias. Here's one that explains about Half-Life.

How do I add my book in like my profile?
Click on your profile and go to signature. That's where you can put texts and/or links and photos. The chain logo is where you can insert links of your stories. Just copy the link of the story (not the chapters of it) and it will appear below your messages like mine.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,572
Points
158
You need to study basic grammar, maybe download a tool like Grammarly. You comma's are consistently wrong, even in your messages here.
You do not leave a blank and write: *WORD , WORD* You need to put your comma directly after the first word.
Actually, that's a European standard, and using italics for dialogue is another international thing, blanking on which country uses it, but I've seen it a few times, usually also using a dash instead of a quotation mark so
- this is how we write , - he told me, is valid... but jarring for American readers (and not pleasant for many others).

Sometimes you use small letters for a name, sometimes you do it correctly.
Also a European, or at least a French thing.


To the OP:
Not sure the stories in my signature line would be to your taste but might be a decent start anyway.
Other, better ones might be
Henry Rider: Clown Hunter - Henry Rider: Clown Hunter | Scribble Hub
I Applied for a Delivery Job and Got Turned into a Flying Reindeer?! - Chapter One | Scribble Hub
I Blinked and now I’m Famous - Chapter 1 : It starts (1) | Scribble Hub
Or just skim the categories that you like for stuff with four- or five-star ratings or just a lot of reads, and that's just on this site.

Offline, I'd suggest looking for writers like Lloyd Alexander for simple but not simplistic prose, J. R. R. Tolkien (especially The Hobbit and his short stories unless you have a lot of time to kill), C. S. Lewis, Mary Stewart, Joy Chant. E. B. White, E. Nesbitt, Peter A. David, or even Neil Gaiman.
 

Fairemont

No Bullying Allowed
Joined
Apr 15, 2025
Messages
593
Points
93
Yes I know, his words may sound bad, but he isn't lying. I have already installed Grammarly on my laptop and I am just looking for a beginner friendly webnovel/LN . I tried the lord of mysteries but a bit too complicated, I just need something with a simpler story but good writing, I would really appreciate if someone could suggest me one. No one I know is in novels I am like an exception.
Maybe go away from webnovels and grab actual novels.

When I was your age, I read hundreds of them. Id suggest things specifically written for a teenage audience.

I enjoyed the Merlin series by T.A. Baron when I was a youth.

Abarat by Clive Barker.

The Baetimaeus Sequence by Clive Barker was a good one.

Dark Materials (The Golden Compass) by Phillip Pullman.

These are all good books that should be comfortable reads.
 

FRWriter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2024
Messages
528
Points
108
Actually, that's a European standard, and using italics for dialogue is another international thing, blanking on which country uses it, but I've seen it a few times, usually also using a dash instead of a quotation mark so
- this is how we write , - he told me, is valid... but jarring for American readers (and not pleasant for many others).

Charles, I think your standard is the standard of normal (classical) fantasy authors. This is a place for webnovels. Nobody, and I stress, nobody writes like that. I've read hundreds of stories, and I haven't seen this type of writing even once. So it might be acceptable in a formal sense in Europe (I'm from Europe as well btw.), but it's not accepted within this community, so there is no need to beat around the bush: Don't use it! This is, after all, a place where we don't talk about formal writing but about webnovels.

Henry Rider: Clown Hunter - Henry Rider: Clown Hunter | Scribble Hub
I Applied for a Delivery Job and Got Turned into a Flying Reindeer?! - Chapter One | Scribble Hub
I Blinked and now I’m Famous - Chapter 1 : It starts (1) | Scribble Hub
Or just skim the categories that you like for stuff with four- or five-star ratings or just a lot of reads, and that's just on this site.

Offline, I'd suggest looking for writers like Lloyd Alexander for simple but not simplistic prose, J. R. R. Tolkien (especially The Hobbit and his short stories unless you have a lot of time to kill), C. S. Lewis, Mary Stewart, Joy Chant. E. B. White, E. Nesbitt, Peter A. David, or even Neil Gaiman.

These are all classical authors, and three stories on Scribble Hub might be great in your opinion, but they are also clearly not mainstream. Emulating these stories is not a good idea in my opinion. However, your advice about the ratings and the "reads" is spot-on. He should simply check out the most popular and best-rated stories.
 

Achillie

Active member
Joined
Mar 6, 2022
Messages
10
Points
43
Everyone else has given their own criticism here so I won't point out the obvious.

But, I'll give you a simple advice to add on. Read a lot, not just because you are obligated to, you have to read stories that you would personally enjoy. At some point your brain will just know how to form words and format things correctly after reading so much.

And broaden your sources too. Read webnovels, light novels, published books (physical or ebooks), short stories, anthology, etc. Lots of writers begin as readers after all.

Anyways, good luck with your journey! :blob_highfive:
 

FoxyXop

New member
Joined
Jan 7, 2026
Messages
10
Points
3
But, I'll give you a simple advice to add on. Read a lot, not just because you are obligated to, you have to read stories that you would personally enjoy. At some point your brain will just know how to form words and format things correctly after reading so much.

And broaden your sources too. Read webnovels, light novels, published books (physical or ebooks), short stories, anthology, etc. Lots of writers begin as readers after all.

Anyways, good luck with your journey! :blob_highfive:
I got my big sister's novel, which she bought some years ago; it's "It Ends with Us" by colon hoover. I didn't read it since I wasn't into romance, so is it a good novel to start with? I never really realised my passion for story writing till some time ago. I always find myself thinking about events for my story. I didn't think of writing because of reading a novel. I know I thought of writing a novel without reading one, I sound arrogant and stupid, but I never really get any clear answers offline or online. People my age only know novels are just stories, but it's way beyond that. And another thing that people may think is bad is that it was because of anime that I started writing, but I want to improve and share my creation.
Say, how much novels have you read in the past 3 years?

Just to see how deep you are in terms of this author stuff.

Also, I have only skim the beginning of the first chapter, and I already see things you gotta work on. Not just can, but SHOULD be work on. The synopsis isn't really nice to see at all. Informative, telling me what's the story is about? Yes. Is it intriguing? No. Redundancy is a b*tch. If you can't think of any other words to describe someone's expression or something, I suggest reading more novels, especially those within the same genre as your novel.


I'll be genuine with giving an advice, sorry in advance if I somehow caused some anger in you.

When telling stories, don't tell the stories like you're literally and textually telling the stories from a reviewer standpoint. Using "we" is like describing, instead of giving the audience a tale to listen or read. Like those narrators from documentary videos.

"In the wildlife of the Amazon forest, we see various floras and faunas."
"His father gave a death stare at his son, Parker, one akin to how a predator would stare at its prey. No one in the room saw that, but Joelle."


You see the difference between the two lines above? That's the difference between telling and showing.
Regarding the 'show don't tell' rule, it's something you should study and, more importantly, apply in the real world. It's not just good, but AMAZING to have, almost anything that requires communication between one person to another can be affected just by applying this rule. Be it the result of a presentation, a casual conversation, or even bigger, a high-tier international conference. You could really persuade people to believe your lies even.

In literacy, 'show don't tell' applies differently from the movies' and games' 'show don't tell'. When in movies and games, 'tell' means you're giving context of the story of said movies or games through a character or texts, outright telling you the context of what is happening in the story. For example: Cortana from the Halo game series. She is an example of how 'tell' is usually used. You can find her scenes in the game series on Youtube, and I advise you to do so because I want you to imagine this. Imagine you're playing the game, trying to understand the world around you and its events. But then, instead of learning it yourself through experience, someone just blurts out an essay-worth of paragraphs about basically the entire events and the reasons of said events even happening. Does that looks fun to you? In my opinion, it's not. This breaks immersion, and immediately you don't want to play the game anymore since even if you play the game to the end, what will you get anyways, money? Of course not, it's a game with story! And the story is supposed to be interesting to learn!

'Show' on the other side is a technique of story-telling that has been used by many successful works. Any great movies, games, novels, or comics have used this technique since the age of when literacy was born, and that's a lot of century ago. In movies and games, you learning about the world through its environments, the setting, minor interactions between characters that seems to be just banters but actually serves context of how the world operates, etc etc, is what 'show' is. For example: In the game Half-Life, instead of telling what your objective is as a researcher with a hazardous environment suit from the get go, the game lets you figure out what is happening through visual and audio. Like when you first encounter a Headcrab, a crab-like alien creature that will lunge at you when you enter their lunge radius. The game revolves around story and combat, yes you will have guns to use, and yet, the first time you met a hostile that can hurt you, the game didn't tell you that you can just ignore the enemies and move on to continue advancing through, no. Instead, it lets you meet the least dangerous enemy without a weapon inside a room/chamber with a door to the next room. What will you do in that situation when you don't have a weapon and is a little scared of what the creature can do? Avoid it and run? Correct! Because after doing so, you'll learn that you don't need to engage a fight with every enemies in the game to get through places. This will not just saves a lot of bullet and keep your health on good numbers, but also saves a lot of time and deaths that would otherwise frustrates you because of needing to retry over and over.

Alright, enough of my ramblings.

Your weakness overall is in the technical side of things. That is your grammar, your writing style, etc etc. Not gonna talk about plot or characters because you are definitely lacking in the technical side of writing. Like what the others have suggested, read more novels. And my suggestion personally, read and understand how people write their story. And maybe watch in-depth analysis of movies, games, or novels from each respective medias. Here's one that explains about Half-Life.


Click on your profile and go to signature. That's where you can put texts and/or links and photos. The chain logo is where you can insert links of your stories. Just copy the link of the story (not the chapters of it) and it will appear below your messages like mine.
Thank you, Nolff, for this in-depth explanation. You have my greatest gratitude.
t
Actually, that's a European standard, and using italics for dialogue is another international thing, blanking on which country uses it, but I've seen it a few times, usually also using a dash instead of a quotation mark so
- this is how we write , - he told me, is valid... but jarring for American readers (and not pleasant for many others).


Also a European, or at least a French thing.


To the OP:
Not sure the stories in my signature line would be to your taste but might be a decent start anyway.
Other, better ones might be
Henry Rider: Clown Hunter - Henry Rider: Clown Hunter | Scribble Hub
I Applied for a Delivery Job and Got Turned into a Flying Reindeer?! - Chapter One | Scribble Hub
I Blinked and now I’m Famous - Chapter 1 : It starts (1) | Scribble Hub
Or just skim the categories that you like for stuff with four- or five-star ratings or just a lot of reads, and that's just on this site.

Offline, I'd suggest looking for writers like Lloyd Alexander for simple but not simplistic prose, J. R. R. Tolkien (especially The Hobbit and his short stories unless you have a lot of time to kill), C. S. Lewis, Mary Stewart, Joy Chant. E. B. White, E. Nesbitt, Peter A. David, or even Neil Gaiman.
Thanks for the suggestions
Maybe go away from webnovels and grab actual novels.

When I was your age, I read hundreds of them. Id suggest things specifically written for a teenage audience.

I enjoyed the Merlin series by T.A. Baron when I was a youth.

Abarat by Clive Barker.

The Baetimaeus Sequence by Clive Barker was a good one.

Dark Materials (The Golden Compass) by Phillip Pullman.

These are all good books that should be comfortable reads.
I am thinking of buying 3 books from the Dark Materials. Should I get the Kindle or the paperback version?
Charles, I think your standard is the standard of normal (classical) fantasy authors. This is a place for webnovels. Nobody, and I stress, nobody writes like that. I've read hundreds of stories, and I haven't seen this type of writing even once. So it might be acceptable in a formal sense in Europe (I'm from Europe as well btw.), but it's not accepted within this community, so there is no need to beat around the bush: Don't use it! This is, after all, a place where we don't talk about formal writing but about webnovels.



These are all classical authors, and three stories on Scribble Hub might be great in your opinion, but they are also clearly not mainstream. Emulating these stories is not a good idea in my opinion. However, your advice about the ratings and the "reads" is spot-on. He should simply check out the most popular and best-rate
So there is like no formatting guide, or anything for a newbie like me?
Everyone else has given their own criticism here so I won't point out the obvious.

But, I'll give you a simple advice to add on. Read a lot, not just because you are obligated to, you have to read stories that you would personally enjoy. At some point your brain will just know how to form words and format things correctly after reading so much.

And broaden your sources too. Read webnovels, light novels, published books (physical or ebooks), short stories, anthology, etc. Lots of writers begin as readers after all.

Anyways, good luck with your journey! :blob_highfive:
I am into anime and stuff. Any particular book you think I should get?
And thanks everyone for giving me advice, and I am very happy to be a part of a community like this.
 
Last edited:

Achillie

Active member
Joined
Mar 6, 2022
Messages
10
Points
43
I got my big sister's novel, which she bought some years ago; it's "It Ends with Us" by colon hoover. I didn't read it since I wasn't into romance, so is it a good novel to start with? I never really realised my passion for story writing till some time ago. I always find myself thinking about events for my story. I didn't think of writing because of reading a novel. I know I thought of writing a novel without reading one, I sound arrogant and stupid, but I never really get any clear answers offline or online. People my age only know novels are just stories, but it's way beyond that. And another thing that people may think is bad is that it was because of anime that I started writing, but I want to improve and share my creation.
I was in the same sort of situation years ago, I had a thing for writing and making stories but had to face the reality that I needed to read a good amount of books if I wanted to do this seriously.

Now, It Ends with Us is well... problematic, it romanticizes abuse, the author itself is pretty problematic (I wouldn't recommend it even as someone who loves the genre) The premise itself isn't bad, it's the execution. Also, it's a smut book.

Since you're not into romance, try reading books in genres that you like. Search for authors with really great, good and even mediocre writing so you can see what makes the great author a great writer in comparison with the others.

I read a lot in the past, ranging from classics to children's literature and tried to avoid the ones hyped by TikTok (don't follow what I did). My advice would be to start with pretty popular series, in terms of published books, such as Percy Jackson, Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings (never read any of these) and of course, if you want more, be active in bookish spaces online.
I am into anime and stuff. Any particular book you think I should get?
And thanks everyone for giving me advice, and I am very happy to be a part of a community like this.
For purely anime, reading light novels that was adapted to an anime that you've watched could be a good starting point, I'd say.

What kind of animes do you like though? I can recommend some published books if we can narrow down the kind of genres you're into.

But also, like @Racosharko said, go to your local libraries is the best option, you can also ask them for recommendations.
 

Xeoz

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 31, 2021
Messages
55
Points
58
Just read a lot. Start small, read light novels, Korean novels. Those novels are easy to read imo, then slowly transition to western novels. My shit isn't good either, but I learned along the way. Looking back, my first work and now, night and day. If the main issue was grammar? Use AI to study, not abuse. Learn. AI is a valuable tool for learning.
 
Top