Honestly, I've been really stressed, haha... If it's not too much trouble, could you read my novel and give me a review? Nothing too deep or serious, just let me know if you liked it or found it interesting or boring. I've noticed I'm growing, but nobody comments, and I don't know if they understand the heart of my story. I just want to tell something similar, even if it's based on what I saw in anime from the early 2000s and 2010s.
Dani Zeyer hit rock bottom: broke, living in a cheap motel after running away from home. On a rainy night, a cosmic entity reincarnated him as Sienna von Rosengarde, the beautiful and spoiled heiress of a multimillionaire family. The big problem: his “Excalibur” survived intact. Now she’s...
www.scribblehub.com
I gave chapter 1 a read! ...
I’m a bit confused at the moment, so I want to read it again to make sure I didn't miss anything.
I'll edit this soon with more feedback!
Feedback:
I read your first chapter, and overall I think the concept is genuinely interesting and has a lot of potential. The transitions and the final reveal especially create a strong hook.
That said, I do have a few points that I think could really improve it.
First, the opening line — “the room smelled of bleach, damp carpet and broken dreams” — has a strong intention, but it feels a bit vague or cliché. The “broken dreams” part doesn’t connect to a physical sense, so it slightly breaks immersion. Grounding it in something more concrete might make the atmosphere even stronger.
One thing that confused me a bit is Dani’s original identity. It’s not very clear whether Dani was male or female before the transformation, and since this is a gender-bender story, that clarity is really important for the impact of the reveal.
The transition from the motel to the supernatural scene is fast, which actually works in your favor, but the problem is that the initial setting itself isn’t fully established yet. We don’t spend enough time understanding Dani’s situation, their struggles, or their relationship with Michael. Even a few more lines about their past or why they ran away would make the scene feel more grounded and emotionally meaningful.
On the other hand, the second transition (the mirror reveal) works quite well. It’s clear, direct, and easy to follow, which is a strong point.
I also feel like the emotional weight around Michael could be stronger. He seems important, especially at the end, but the story doesn’t give enough depth to that relationship beforehand to make it fully hit.
The entity scene is interesting, but it could benefit from a bit more buildup. Right now, the goal “conceive a child” comes very abruptly, which reduces its impact. A bit more tension or psychological pressure before that reveal could make the scene more memorable.
There are also some moments where the tone shifts quite sharply between serious, emotional writing and more crude or comedic phrasing. Individually they’re fine, but together they sometimes clash. Smoother tone control would make the story feel more consistent.
Finally, the mirror scene is good, but Dani’s reaction feels slightly rushed. Extending the reaction just a little "with more confusion or disbelief" could make the transformation feel more real.
Overall, I think this is a good start with a strong concept and some effective moments. However, as a Chapter 1, it feels a bit more like a prologue or Chapter 0, since it focuses heavily on setup and shock rather than fully establishing the story’s foundation.
