Are You Plotter or Panther?

Maelstrom556

Soda Jerk
Joined
Dec 2, 2025
Messages
66
Points
33
I'd have to say I'm somewhere in the middle between plotter and panther(sic). I do end up with general ideas of where to go, but I'm not gonna meticulously plot out that journey. If we're going with some alliteration, I'd say I'm a punt gun. Point it in the right direction and watch it scatter when fired.
 

Zagaroth

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 18, 2023
Messages
378
Points
103
Panth/ster here, but not completely free form every chapter.

I started with just the starting scenario and built from there. I have done world building on the fly, and some of that world building has advanced out to creating specific story way points to reach, but I don't map the path there. If my characters actually have a reason to get there, they will. If not, then I need to discard the waypoint anyway.
 

MFontana

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 24, 2025
Messages
374
Points
93
Both.
I meticulously plot, build, and develop the world, story beats, intended consequences, and the characters. Then, I drop a few threads and hooks and let the characters breathe and play in the world.
Discovering the "How it happens" is all part of the fun, and almost as enjoyable writing, as watching it happen re-reading afterwards during my editing process.
 

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
637
Points
93
Well, I set up a general idea, but if I have it all planned out perfectly, then I get bored and don't want to write, so there's always room for details and adjustments.
 
Joined
Jun 30, 2025
Messages
23
Points
13
A small combination of both. I make general bullet point outlines of ideas and storybeats, and then try to fill in the gaps, which sometimes leads to new ideas popping up. Those new ideas usually happen because I realized that what I had planned either doesn't fit with the current characterization of a certain character, doesn't fit with the current events of the rest of the story, or (the most likely case) is something that is best saved for later but can easily be foreshadowed or alluded to. In those cases, I typically just rearrange those planned plot points a little and try to improvize my way into making them make sense within the story.

Also, I like Panthers, they're cool.
 

HouseOfUkiro

Active member
Joined
Jan 31, 2025
Messages
87
Points
33
I rawdog everything.
Achievement unlocked: Lord of Friction?
Both.
Chaos is a ladder.
Do you like the chaos or is that the way you’re built?
I'd have to say I'm somewhere in the middle between plotter and panther(sic). I do end up with general ideas of where to go, but I'm not gonna meticulously plot out that journey. If we're going with some alliteration, I'd say I'm a punt gun. Point it in the right direction and watch it scatter when fired.
Would you plot everything if you had additional brain power to spar?
I write like a DM, I know where each book will start and end, but I drop myself plot hooks along the way that I can grab for side quests to fill the space between.
Damn. That’s some spider web type planning.
Panth/ster here, but not completely free form every chapter.

I started with just the starting scenario and built from there. I have done world building on the fly, and some of that world building has advanced out to creating specific story way points to reach, but I don't map the path there. If my characters actually have a reason to get there, they will. If not, then I need to discard the waypoint anyway.
I like that. Makes sense. That way you won’t right about anything that has nothing to do with the story.
I have things I want to do so then I write how things happened to get there.
Step 1: current chapter
+
Step 2: x
+
Step 3: x
=
Step 4: plot point

Solve for x
Have you ever written yourself into a corner?
Both.
I meticulously plot, build, and develop the world, story beats, intended consequences, and the characters. Then, I drop a few threads and hooks and let the characters breathe and play in the world.
Discovering the "How it happens" is all part of the fun, and almost as enjoyable writing, as watching it happen re-reading afterwards during my editing process.
Damn. I can tell you’d have craze mana regeneration if you iselkaid ?
I'm a bit of a plotter, since I'm someone who overthinks things naturally.
Definitely not a panther. :blob_joy:
A diabolical plotter??
 
Last edited:

HouseOfUkiro

Active member
Joined
Jan 31, 2025
Messages
87
Points
33
Well, I set up a general idea, but if I have it all planned out perfectly, then I get bored and don't want to write, so there's always room for details and adjustments.
Ascended oh destined Panther. May chaos keep your readers addicted!!!!
Wakanda forever
Beats chest. FOREVER! ?️
A small combination of both. I make general bullet point outlines of ideas and storybeats, and then try to fill in the gaps, which sometimes leads to new ideas popping up. Those new ideas usually happen because I realized that what I had planned either doesn't fit with the current characterization of a certain character, doesn't fit with the current events of the rest of the story, or (the most likely case) is something that is best saved for later but can easily be foreshadowed or alluded to. In those cases, I typically just rearrange those planned plot points a little and try to improvize my way into making them make sense within the story.

Also, I like Panthers, they're cool.
Yup. Definitely a mage class if you get isekai’d??
Prolly not. I'm what you call one o' them simple folk. Just go with the flow from one point to the next. More of that there brainpower would just make the result go from garbage to top-tier garbage.
And then set it all on fire!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5306.jpeg
    IMG_5306.jpeg
    643.8 KB · Views: 9

kelmor

Active member
Joined
Dec 12, 2024
Messages
18
Points
28
Both. I'm not good enough yet to go entirely one way or the other. I let it flow a bit (maybe from the beginning, maybe not) to get started and decide whether I like the idea, then figure out what the emotional payoff and plot resolution should roughly be, potentially write a few random scenes I might want, and try to connect the dots. Sometimes what comes out doesn't go through the dots I'd thought of initially.
 

Elmir_Arch-Ham_of_Omega

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 10, 2024
Messages
115
Points
58
Do you like the chaos or is that the way you’re built?
I've read many things, I've watched many things, I've played many things. Ideas in my head battle in an arena of fire and only the best, or funniest, or weirdest survive.

At one point, I wanted to "make the experience of entering a portal different and not just looking at a screensaver with VR glasses", so I turned to Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas. Just because.

context:
  • It's Isekai taking place in a a fantasy DnD world
  • The (giant gun-toting) mice don't normally talk. Ralph, Arthur, and Sully are mice.
  • The fantasy elves have yet to be exposed to Earth's comics and TV shows.
  • Yes, the reincarnators brought guns from Earth.
  • Cecil is a slime living in a pocket dimension. He's stuck there but he can free-fly his portal.
  • Peanut is a pillow-sized mushroom-folk
As Ingrid stepped into the portal she began to realize a few seconds in that she didn’t seem to be moving any farther despite her walking and feeling solid ground beneath her.

“My brain’s starting to hurt…” Ingrid found her voice warbly and distorted inside this rift. She felt her pupils wobbling as she beheld a kaleidoscope of colors she didn’t even know existed, moving in a way she didn’t even know was possible.

Now she felt as if she was falling but couldn’t even tell in what direction the plummet was taking her.

The world between worlds was both blindingly bright and completely dark. Simultaneously a white void devoid of all color and a jumble of colors, colors she could not describe despite her eyes taking in its image. She was seeing illusions her brain was randomly conjuring; the same way she would when immersed in the pitch-black for extended periods.

Ingrid blinked slowly as she turned and looked around. Her neck kept turning and turning but the view remained unchanged, her neck seemingly having no end to its flexibility.

Nothing was making sense.

“SIRIA’S RIGHT! IT’S NOT SUPPOSED TO BE LIKE THIS!” Sammy whispered very quietly to everyone’s ears.

“Laggy connection again…” Cecil yelled calmly in panic. His portal was glitching as it turned to a blue screen displaying “No Signal”, which didn’t stop an ad for Farmer John’s Cheesy Jalapeno Chips from popping up at the lower-corner of his portal.

“QUICK! Change the channel!” Ralph wailed softly, adjusting his monocle.

Peanut was giggling as she danced over everyone’s heads, sprinking sugar everywhere.

“Have you tried the chicken, though?” Arthur squeaked. The mouse was T-posing as he hovered around, honey-fried chicken drumsticks rained from his paws while the ducks roosting on his shoulders were belting out a perfect rendition of ‘La Donna E Mobile” anyone on Earth would pay good money to hear, especially when one duck sounded exactly like Luciano Pavarotti and the other Mario Lanza.

Philia was furiously playing her accordion along to the tune, but it sounded like a trombone being waterboarded.

Ingrid caught one chicken drumstick that fell from Arthur’s paws, but all she saw in her hand was pineapple pizza.

“GET IT OFF ME! GET IT OFF ME!” The pizza pleaded “I DON’T KNOW ANYTHING! I’M JUST A MESSENGER!”

“Messenger my ass!” Ingrid said, shaking the pizza. The pineapples growled and barked like tiny chihuahua’s, tearing off bits of dough. Rivulets of molten marinara and mozzarella ran down the crust as the vicious pineapples continued to devour it alive.

“You’re one of them!” she accused.

“N-no!” The pizza protested, but the pineapples weren’t buying it, tearing off the pepperoni and making the pizza howl in torment.

On cue, giant shrimp a million feet long crested out of the periphery, creating a constantly moving arc of orange and white. On its colossal back rested every kind of sushi imaginable.

“We’re too late.” Siria sighed, “Naruto has summoned the dragon balls.”

Iohann looked up at the giant cresting shrimp and shrugged, returning to her desk to continue drawing her manga.

“That’s it, just keep it up.” The felmoon priest said. “Act natural.”

Kinu and Kvaris were making out on a bed.

“I’m the bottom again?” Kinu whined, but it was clear she was enjoying it.

“The fans prefer me.” Kvaris said, lowering herself for a french kiss.

“Mhmm… perfect.” Iohann said, drawing the scene. Her hand was frantically drawing page and after page of the two sisters enjoying a gangbang. Selphie’s eyebrows were furrowed in concentration as she tried to ink the lines, jumping as the phone loudly rang.

“Hello, Sheep Comics.” Selphie replied as she picked up the phone, her hands not stopping as she inked the orgy. “Miss President, it's for you.”

Iohann listened to the phone for a few seconds in annoyance.

“What!?” The felmoon priest bleated, and then her ears suddenly drooped in horror “...what do you mean the deadline is tomorrow!? Kinu and Kvaris don’t have their cosplay yet! We’re not gonna make it into Comiket on time!”

She banged her fist on the table, sending pens and ink flying everywhere. The pens screamed but some managed to deploy parachutes before the fall killed them.
The two sisters continued to make out in the background, unconcerned.

“Come on please!” The pizza pleaded, wriggling in Ingrid’s grasp. “I’m innocent!”

Peanut sprinkled some sugar on the pizza causing it to cough and retch.

“Tell the truth already!” The little mushroom giggled as she continued to tap dance over Ingrid’s head.

“Don’t lie to me!” Ingrid snapped. “That pineapple wasn’t on you by accident!”

“Boss, he might be telling the truth.” said a taco hovering beside her. As the taco flapped open and closed, salsa and guacamole drooled out of it.
Ingrid recoiled in disgust

“Dammit Sgt Taconi, have you been snorting guac again!?”

“Hey, you can’t kick a habit down for good.” The taco frowned, causing strips of asado to fall to the floor.

“We’re cops for God’s sake! And that guac was evidence!”

“Order in the court!” Sully said, shooting his gun in the air, a shower of cheese rained from his barrel which quieted the other mice having a heated debate regarding the merits of macadamia nuts versus almonds. The golden mice however were passed out, twitching on the ground. A hookah sent plumes of strawberry aroma into the air, laughing nefariously as it wiggled its stems in triumph. From the smoking bowl, buds of opium wearing shades were making their escape as they jumped out, crying in relief as they finally tasted the outside air.

“Hey…” Viel called, she was a crudely-animated 12fps paper cutout and all her colors had been inverted. “Wanna see my head come off?”

“Seriously, has anyone here tried the chicken though?” Arthur pressed, pelting the party with more honey-fried drumsticks as he T-posed over everyone.


Meanwhile, Autumnhollow, Terragalia:
“AUGH!!!”

Zefir and Gwen recoiled as a sharp blast of static pierced their headsets, quickly taking them off of their heads. The camera feed showed only dark, distorted pixels. A few seconds later they saw everyone was jettisoned out of the Rogue Rift and into an unfamiliar grassland, skidding a good thirty feet despite the damp grassy soil with a generous amount of rocks underfoot. Nobody stumbled however, the only inertia everyone felt was the few steps they took, as if they had just walked through a five-foot long corridor that separated the two dimensions.

“Wow, I literally just watched a real-life glitch.” Zefir said cryptically.

EDIT: for some reason putting a spoiler tag cut off the text, so I removed it
 
Top