When the Intentions are wholly impure from the very beginning.

Justhetip...

...of the iceberg.
Joined
Sep 9, 2024
Messages
249
Points
78
This is a rant. Nothing more, nothing less.

---

Don't know how many of you saw that thread, but today someone posted their story asking for feedback, and then when called out for it being AI-generated, they denied it and argued.

I came to the thread late, so I was quite curious about the story itself, but turns out he had already deleted.

To sate my curiosity a little, I checked their profile, and lo and behold, I saw the words "Join my Patreon for faster updates, early access, and exclusive content" and the reason why their story was AI-generated slop became a no-brainer.

Yeah. It was easy money.

Because, why in the world would you be advertising a Patreon so early?!

Without an established reader base, steady and trustworthy update schedule, or even at least, a minimum of 30-50 chapters already posted.

This was basically and unspoken confession that "Yeah, I wanted to make quick bucks, and I didn't want to work for it."

To be fair, even for the story I'm working on, I have this vague expectation within that at some point in time, I'd probably be earning a little from it, and there's nothing wrong with that.

But when you make profit the sole motivation for your work, how will you be able to resist the urge to cut-corners, take shortcuts, shove AI slop down the reader's throat and start waiting for the money to flow.

You can write to earn, but don't let it be the Alpha and Omega of your story.

Sheesh, have some dignity too. I'm sure you were thinking, "Oooh, the readers are soooo going to fall in love with this story that I totally wrote, and when they're done with the measly 3-5 available chapters that has barely even said anything about the story, they'll totally slap my face with some cool cash to access the paywall and gobble up the rest of the story like the good cash cows they are."

---

Phew. That's all.

Again. This is just a rant. Have a nice day.

---

Yeah, and I posted this in the Story feedback section just so they could see this, in case they came back to check their thread.

"You, yes you, I'm talking to you. Do better next time. Just write. And maybe the readers will even love your flawed writing."
 
Last edited:

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,556
Points
283
Damn, I missed it. I should ask the master of ScribbleHub events if the fight was good.

"@RepresentingWrath was the drama good in the thread being referenced?"

He was here before us and he'll be here long after, watching us.
Lately I've been busy so I don't know. My guess, drama probably wasn't that good.
Because, why in the world would you be advertising a Patreon so early?!
Even before AI became popular, a lot of people advertised Patreon from the get go. I don't get why they do it since it is detrimental, even if you actually want money it is detrimental, but they do it anyway. Humans. ?‍♂️
But when you make profit the sole motivation for your work, how will you be able to resist the urge to cut-corners, take shortcuts, shove AI slop down the reader's throat and start waiting for the money to flow.

You can write to earn, but don't let it be the Alpha and Omega of your story.
I disagree.

As for the story in question, missed the thread so can't say much.
 

Rezcore

Kell-Wnown Timber
Joined
Aug 18, 2022
Messages
1,093
Points
153
I agree. Like I don't mind the use of AI in certain cases. Oh spellcheck? Fine. What, grammar check? Fair. Fixing honorifics where needed? OK. Writing sentences and paragraphs, are you fucking bent? It's one thing if ai says "hey these are suggestions on how to make this passage better." Another to shit on our hobby with slop.
 

CarburetorThompson

Fuel Atomization Enjoyer
Joined
Jan 27, 2022
Messages
1,630
Points
153
I don’t use ai for writing but I’ll use ai art for generating lighting references for my art.

Some times I’ll use ai art for reference, but it’s not good to do so. Most ai art has bad proportions, the lighting and shading is often so good that it’s harder to notice.
 

StoneInky

Heart of Stone, Head of Ink
Joined
Jun 24, 2024
Messages
445
Points
108
This is a rant. Nothing more, nothing less.

---

Don't know how many of you saw that thread, but today someone posted their story asking for feedback, and then when called out for it being AI-generated, they denied it and argued.

I came to the thread late, so I was quite curious about the story itself, but turns out he had already deleted.

To sate my curiosity a little, I checked their profile, and lo and behold, I saw the words "Join my Patreon for faster updates, early access, and exclusive content" and the reason why their story was AI-generated slop became a no-brainer.

Yeah. It was easy money.

Because, why in the world would you be advertising a Patreon so early?!

Without an established reader base, steady and trustworthy update schedule, or even at least, a minimum of 30-50 chapters already posted.

This was basically and unspoken confession that "Yeah, I wanted to make quick bucks, and I didn't want to work for it."

To be fair, even for the story I'm working on, I have this vague expectation within that at some point in time, I'd probably be earning a little from it, and there's nothing wrong with that.

But when you make profit the sole motivation for your work, how will you be able to resist the urge to cut-corners, take shortcuts, shove AI slop down the reader's throat and start waiting for the money to flow.

You can write to earn, but don't let it be the Alpha and Omega of your story.

Sheesh, have some dignity too. I'm sure you were thinking, "Oooh, the readers are soooo going to fall in love with this story that I totally wrote, and when they're done with the measly 3-5 available chapters that has barely even said anything about the story, they'll totally slap my face with some cool cash to access the paywall and gobble up the rest of the story like the good cash cows they are."

---

Phew. That's all.

Again. This is just a rant. Have a nice day.

---

Yeah, and I posted this in the Story feedback section just so they could see this, in case they came back to check their thread.

"You, yes you, I'm talking to you. Do better next time. Just write. And maybe the readers will even love your flawed writing."
Thank. You. Exactlyyyy.

I don't even care if they upload AI edited stuff, but they should at least tell their readers that! And the people they ask to review their novel!
 

WhiteFeather

Active member
Joined
Apr 12, 2025
Messages
63
Points
33
AI slop reads like utter shit.
What could be conveyed in a single sentence is dragged forever with so many metaphors and shit.
Here's an example,
"He was often tired after work and immediately hit the bed after reaching home." is what a human might write.
"He is often tired after work, walking on empty and dragging like a snail. He had no time to spare as he immediately got under the rug as soon as he arrived home." is what an AI might write.
Now I wrote both of those sentences, but I tried my best to imitate what AI text reads like.
It's so many words to say the same thing, and it annoys me.
If done moderately, such sentences can be great imagery. But if every sentence reads like the second sentence I wrote, then the reader just gets bored of all the extra words.
 

CountVampyre

Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2025
Messages
27
Points
13
The funniest shit is when I see a fanfic with 10 chapters, but the author already has their patreon in their bio. (its their 5th fanfic this months and they are only the translator)
 

StoneInky

Heart of Stone, Head of Ink
Joined
Jun 24, 2024
Messages
445
Points
108
AI slop reads like utter shit.
What could be conveyed in a single sentence is dragged forever with so many metaphors and shit.
Here's an example,
"He was often tired after work and immediately hit the bed after reaching home." is what a human might write.
"He is often tired after work, walking on empty and dragging like a snail. He had no time to spare as he immediately got under the rug as soon as he arrived home." is what an AI might write.
Now I wrote both of those sentences, but I tried my best to imitate what AI text reads like.
It's so many words to say the same thing, and it annoys me.
If done moderately, such sentences can be great imagery. But if every sentence reads like the second sentence I wrote, then the reader just gets bored of all the extra words.
I heard that a good way to describe AI is glorified autocorrect. Writing with it is just the more advanced version of clicking the random words that appear there. That's also why AI hallucinates and lies so frequently. It knows nothing. It just generates.

You are completely right. AI is slop. That is just how it works.
 

Justhetip...

...of the iceberg.
Joined
Sep 9, 2024
Messages
249
Points
78
The funniest shit is when I see a fanfic with 10 chapters, but the author already has their patreon in their bio. (its their 5th fanfic this months and they are only the translator)
These are the folks who piss me off the most. The fanfic translators.

Just get the raws off a pirated website, then run them through AI translator, and voila, post about 20 chapters, then put the rest behind a Patreon paywall.
 

Macha

{$user.user_title}
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
888
Points
133
The sad part is AI slop still read better than my slop XD

I have to ask a friend to turn my unreadable writing into something coherent, and now she is concerned about my mental health.


Also fuck you I'm not your friend. Get some help.
 
Top