All fanfic writers are creatively bankrupt thieves.

D

Deleted member 41774

Guest
The only good fanfics are R-18 doujinshis--

 

Rezcore

Kell-Wnown Timber
Joined
Aug 18, 2022
Messages
1,093
Points
153
This is a bad take. Especially when you consider that every single piece of Fiction is in itself a fanfic of a previous work/current reality. TWD, Night of the Living Dead. And so forth, war movies are fan fiction of wars.

Fanfics gives you a predefined structure to write in.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,710
Points
158
This is a bad take. Especially when you consider that every single piece of Fiction is in itself a fanfic of a previous work/current reality. TWD, Night of the Living Dead. And so forth, war movies are fan fiction of wars.
Night of the Living Dead was more of an adaptation - Romero wanted to make a movie of Matheson's "I Am Legend" but the rights had been sold to an Italian production company for more than his entire budget (that company produced the Vincent Price movie "The Last Man on Earth" from it), but rewrote so much of it that it wound up being more its own thing entirely. Now the sequels to it are all pretty much fan fiction...
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,710
Points
158
Now are shared universe stories considered "fan fiction" in this context? Say, are stories about the Cthulhu Mythos "fan fiction"? Or is "Fan Fiction" solely "taking either characters or events from established universes and either reimagining the outcome, merging them with other universes, or inserting the author into the story"?
A lot of author-insert stories really are utter trash (there are exceptions ... but these pretty much show the "90% of everything is garbage" axiom to be optimistic).
Universe merging is literally all over the place - from Silverlock in the 1940s to Craig Shaw Gardner's "Cineverse Cycle" near the top to ... some of the nearly unreadable stuff posted to fan sites near the bottom.
Same with "What If...?" scenarios ("What if Harry Potter boned Hermione instead of drooling after Cho Chang?" can be entertaining or just disgusting; and the old Marvel Comics "What If...?!?" series was as mixed a bag as any other fan fiction - and the animated series even moreso).
 

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,556
Points
283
Now are shared universe stories considered "fan fiction" in this context? Say, are stories about the Cthulhu Mythos "fan fiction"? Or is "Fan Fiction" solely "taking either characters or events from established universes and either reimagining the outcome, merging them with other universes, or inserting the author into the story"?
A lot of author-insert stories really are utter trash (there are exceptions ... but these pretty much show the "90% of everything is garbage" axiom to be optimistic).
Universe merging is literally all over the place - from Silverlock in the 1940s to Craig Shaw Gardner's "Cineverse Cycle" near the top to ... some of the nearly unreadable stuff posted to fan sites near the bottom.
Same with "What If...?" scenarios ("What if Harry Potter boned Hermione instead of drooling after Cho Chang?" can be entertaining or just disgusting; and the old Marvel Comics "What If...?!?" series was as mixed a bag as any other fan fiction - and the animated series even moreso).
Yes. :meowsip:
 
Top