All fanfic writers are creatively bankrupt thieves.

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,733
Points
158
Another series of works that would be considered literature despite being a kind of fan fiction are The Flashman Papers. I can highly recommend them.

The main character was "stolen" from Thomas Hughes' Tom Brown's School Days. He even has his very own Wikipedia page. If not for Fraser's brilliant works, I doubt he would.
Yeah, amazing how a character who gets two scenes and two other mentions in one book becomes one of the greatest scoundrel/champions ever in his own series decades later... Believe I've read exactly half of the series (that's all I've been able to find used or below cover price on Kindle) - so far, favorite scene is when he interacts with Sherlock Holmes.
 

3guanoff

Well-known memoir
Joined
Jul 14, 2023
Messages
370
Points
133
Yeah, amazing how a character who gets two scenes and two other mentions in one book becomes one of the greatest scoundrel/champions ever in his own series decades later... Believe I've read exactly half of the series (that's all I've been able to find used or below cover price on Kindle) - so far, favorite scene is when he interacts with Sherlock Holmes.
Flashman and the Tiger was an interesting book, and the Sherlock story was certainly glorious!
I am currently re-reading all the works in order of their fictional chronology as opposed to order of publication. I've just started "Flashman at the Charge". It is perhaps my favorite of the papers, followed by "Flashman at the Great Game". We will see if my opinion changes.

Do you have access to Everand (former Scribd)? They have all the Flashman papers as ebooks.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,733
Points
158
Flashman and the Tiger was an interesting book, and the Sherlock story was certainly glorious!
I am currently re-reading all the works in order of their fictional chronology as opposed to order of publication. I've just started "Flashman at the Charge". It is perhaps my favorite of the papers, followed by "Flashman at the Great Game". We will see if my opinion changes.

Do you have access to Everand (former Scribd)? They have all the Flashman papers as ebooks.
I had Scribd on an old phone but never updated it or brought it to either of the last two. Last time I checked, Amazon had all but one - but they were all like $11-18 USD for paperback or print (same price, if you could get enough to not pay shipping) - if I had the cash, I would have bought the paperbacks.
 

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,556
Points
283
Flashman and the Tiger was an interesting book, and the Sherlock story was certainly glorious!
I am currently re-reading all the works in order of their fictional chronology as opposed to order of publication. I've just started "Flashman at the Charge". It is perhaps my favorite of the papers, followed by "Flashman at the Great Game". We will see if my opinion changes.

Do you have access to Everand (former Scribd)? They have all the Flashman papers as ebooks.
I had Scribd on an old phone but never updated it or brought it to either of the last two. Last time I checked, Amazon had all but one - but they were all like $11-18 USD for paperback or print (same price, if you could get enough to not pay shipping) - if I had the cash, I would have bought the paperbacks.
Bruh. You talk about the same thing in two threads. Get a room.
 

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,556
Points
283
Mate, you made two threads on the same thing.
One is about fanfics, the other is about those who write them.
 

3guanoff

Well-known memoir
Joined
Jul 14, 2023
Messages
370
Points
133
One is about fanfics, the other is about those who write them.
S'pose the sequel is a little milder. Yet they are close enough that many arguments are relevant to both topics.
I assumed this thread would die after you created the sequel. Oy.
 

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,556
Points
283
S'pose the sequel is a little milder. Yet they are close enough that many arguments are relevant to both topics.
I assumed this thread would die after you created the sequel. Oy.
If both my threads were serious, I would argue with you on difference. HOWEVER, these are not serious threads. Enjoy the ride. :meowsip:
 

Anonjohn20

Pen holding member
Joined
Mar 22, 2023
Messages
1,875
Points
153
If both my threads were serious, I would argue with you on difference. HOWEVER, these are not serious threads. Enjoy the ride. :meowsip:
The matter is life or death! Without the genre known as fanfiction (which we can exclude from our searches), bad authors would flood the other genres more easily. How else would they expose themselves as bad at worldbuilding? I will fight tooth, claw, and nail for that genre to exist (so I can exclude it from searches).
 

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,556
Points
283
The matter is life or death! Without the genre known as fanfiction (which we can exclude from our searches), bad authors would flood the other genres more easily. How else would they expose themselves as bad at worldbuilding? I will fight tooth, claw, and nail for that genre to exist (so I can exclude it from searches).
Based.
 

Tyranomaster

Guy who writes stuff
Joined
Oct 5, 2022
Messages
746
Points
133
The matter is life or death! Without the genre known as fanfiction (which we can exclude from our searches), bad authors would flood the other genres more easily. How else would they expose themselves as bad at worldbuilding? I will fight tooth, claw, and nail for that genre to exist (so I can exclude it from searches).
This is the singular best reason for it to exist.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,733
Points
158
Sailus woke up and chose violence.

I feel like they should be judged more on a case-to-case basis, though I'm inclined to agree if it's about most rather than all of them.
Well, many, perhaps even most, of us, I suspect, began writing either "fan fiction" or "alternate ending" stories - but then most also grow out of that phase.
 
Top