Would like someone to check out my work

legalolis

Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
5
Points
18
Project_Ise: Monsieur unedited

I’m extremely lazy when it comes to writing and have usually stopped on chapter 5. Mostly because editing punctuation and making sure that the work is grammatically correct is a lot. So I opted out of doing that for laterbut this is my first time trying a short story out. So I would just like to know a few things.

can you understand the story?
Is it paced properly?
Do you want to read more?
How can I improve in story telling?
 

Cipiteca396

Monarch of Despair 🐉🌺🪽🌊🪶🌑🐦‍🔥🌈
Joined
Jun 6, 2021
Messages
2,703
Points
153

No tags. Synopsis unclear (not exactly a sin).
Not a good first impression.
 

Mysticant

Resident Ant
Joined
Jun 17, 2021
Messages
274
Points
58
Well, there are a few different languages(mainly french I assume), making it kind of hard to read. The chapters are rather short, but I don't particularly care about that. It seems so hard to do paragraph indents, I haven't read such a format in a long time(lol, I guess I have been reading much crap).
 

legalolis

Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
5
Points
18

No tags. Synopsis unclear (not exactly a sin).
Not a good first impression.
I’m sorry I’m really bad at synopsis but the synopsis is important and I don’t really like long summaries but if that’s the best way then I’ll add some more and I’m also bad at tags I don’t know what to put can you recommend me anything
Well, there are a few different languages(mainly french I assume), making it kind of hard to read. The chapters are rather short, but I don't particularly care about that. It seems so hard to do paragraph indents, I haven't read such a format in a long time(lol, I guess I have been reading much crap).
The French isn’t all too important it adds to the story but it shouldn’t take away anything
Story link please. Help us lazy cats on SHF find it. Otherwise, we also too lazy to go search and take a look.
Sorry I was asleep
Story link please. Help us lazy cats on SHF find it. Otherwise, we also too lazy to go search and take a look.
 

KoyukiMegumi

Kitty
Joined
Jun 11, 2021
Messages
1,201
Points
153
I don’t really like taking other people’s artwork and slapping it on my cover. Just seems kinda rude to me no offense to others that do it.
Never said you should take another's the artwork. I make my own. Of course, I am not a professional artist, but I recreate an image and adjust it to what I need.

For that, all you need to do is trace an image, and do changes, and color it for your needs. Keep what I like while I do a lot of changes, like clothes and hair, expressions and such like that. Then I color them. Takes me hours to do, but I don't mind it.

But a book without a cover might get views, but surely will not get all the views it could get. :blob_melt:

You can also find images in the forums for artists. Some placed theirs so anyone could use it. *Read the post and such.*
 

legalolis

Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
5
Points
18
Never said you should take another's the artwork. I make my own. Of course, I am not a professional artist, but I recreate an image and adjust it to what I need.

For that, all you need to do is trace an image, and do changes, and color it for your needs. Keep what I like while I do a lot of changes, like clothes and hair, expressions and such like that. Then I color them. Takes me hours to do, but I don't mind it.

But a book without a cover might get views, but surely will not get all the views it could get. :blob_melt:

You can also find images in the forums for artists. Some placed theirs so anyone could use it. *Read the post and such.*
Okay thank you for mentioning this though I want to commission this to someone I know rather than other peoples. Only thing I feel with covers is that I don’t believe in my works so either I give up and such I want to complete this and then give it a cover for the edited version where I iron out the details and just make the story more refined. Thank you again for your suggestion.
 

LoliGent

The Lolicon Gentleman
Joined
May 21, 2021
Messages
248
Points
83
So I checked out the first chapter and... I'm kind of confused for many reasons. But before the story proper, the synopsis definitely needs to be worked on. The description is quite vague that I don't know what to make of it. The tags seem to correlate with what little there is of the synopsis, but the genre is the complete opposite. So this is a horror story? Because it sounds like some kind of drama. I'm not certain what to make of it.

So I go into the first chapter. I think one big issue here is grammar syntax. I think it reads well, I had no problem discerning what was happening, but I felt like it needed better wording.

Though I must make it clear that I don't actually read the stories, I just copy and paste the story to a text-to-speech program and have it read it for me. I found no problem listening as it sounds adequate enough to be discerned. Then I tried reading it myself, and that required some kind of concentration as the way it's written is quite odd. That might be the syntax problem I mentioned, but grammar issues are also strewn about.

I'm not the best person to consult about grammar, but I feel like you probably didn't proofread, or you didn't proofread with intent. I feel that sometimes we should proofread with some kind of intention behind it, such as one proofreading to look for errors and such and another reading to see how sentences can be improved. But this could also be a case where the errors are "invisible" to you, as in we get so used to our writing we see nothing wrong with it. All I can say is that I was having a tough time reading the first chapter and a few reads with some intention could go a long way. But as you said in the first post, you admit to being quite lazy with that.

I do admit, I also find it tedious to proofread, but I find proofreading tolerable when I write like 3 chapters. Then I proofread the first chapter, move on to the second chapter, and then the third, taking a break, or waiting much later, and then going back to the first chapter. I feel like we need a breather from a freshly proofread chapter, but not necessarily a break, just something else. That might help you when it comes to proofreading.

So what do I think of the story? It's kind of weird, and not the weird with intent kind, but more like random things are happening. I'm guessing this is suppose to be period drama during WWII with two... well... adults or kids, I can't tell the age of the protagonist. And apparently one of them melts? That was weird, but they seem to be fine later? Or was it a figure of speech? I'm not certain what to make of this story. It feels like it's throwing a lot at me without any context.

So with all that said, I guess I'll answer your questions.

can you understand the story?
Is it paced properly?
Do you want to read more?
How can I improve in story telling?

1.) No. I have no idea what is going.
2.) It appears so. It didn't felt like it jumped from one scene to another.
3.) I'm sorry but I do not.
4.) That's a tough one. You may want to read more stories to get inspired by them. Don't just read them, try to figure out how they are written. I feel like there's a lack of structure in terms of the writing itself. Much like how before drawing, you have to plan out with drafts and sketches, so too you must write drafts and take notes about what you want to write about. I feel this story is like a body without a skeleton. I know it's a story, but it's not looking like one.

I do hope you can continue writing if you are interested in it, but quality requires effort on the part of the author. Remember, how much effort you give reflects in the final product.
 

legalolis

Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
5
Points
18
Sorry I am planning to go back and do a final revision. First about chapter 1, it’s random as I haven’t set anything up yet, the first few paragraphs was a look into the main character and love interest, I also used it to set up the setting and time along with the fact that something weird is going on. Though reading back I do agree I should probably add the character’s age through the timeskip back into the past.
issue with your review is that I don’t think you read past the first chapter and it sounds like it didn’t bring you in to the story so I suppose stopping at the first is understandable.
The second and third chapter will show intent with the sort of story I’m trying to create.
now addressing the face melt I think I did goof with the French in there meaning Mister, it was to show that she turned into a mister and isn’t a misses anymore.
Lastly the synopsis, I know where I want to take the story but I feel if I add a lengthy synopsis it might just ruin the mystery I’m setting up.

thank you for reviewing my work though I will reread it to make sure it’s less confusing.
 
Top