Most of the fairytales I read as a child have very sobering endings for at least one of the relevant characters. Just the nursery rhyme Humpty Dumpty has a morbid conclusion.
Some somewhat depressing stories have second chance mcs declaring "I will protect him/her this time around" only to fail anyway despite their careful effort and preparedness. Seems like evil tends to escalate its viciousness during extra round lives.
fridge horror: in a certain anime with the database database wow wow song, they eventually discover that resurrection actually has a price. Almost similar concept in Sword of Truth.
Is this aimed at me?
Edit after confirmation that it is:
Not sure if you're trying to recommend me reading material or say something about my writing, but those are different to what I'm describing~!
My broken narratives aren't just about being morbid and sad. Sometimes the characters recover and go on being happy, but the assumptions surrounding the story from that point on have to change.
I studied fairytales pretty extensively for a class at university and, while some of them have pretty miserable endings, those are still presented in a way that's consistent with their narrative frame.
Likewise, although it's typical for second novels to succeed at their mission, the reader is still aware of the possibility for failure, even if it's unlikely. In my example, that character's well-being wasn't the focus at all.
The fact that he was so OP that he could fix pretty much any situation with strength and seemed to laugh in the face of being affected by something done to him, even when people tried to give him a taste of his own medicine, made him a pretty comical badass character. Nobody, not even the living God who's supposed to be looking after the world, is keeping an eye on him because nobody seems to need to. Readers can also be assured that he'll always be fine.
But just because he's a "tough guy" doesn't mean that he can't be a victim. So the characters have a rude awakening to the fact that even a guy like that can be traumatised and that it was pretty messed up to depend on him so completely, and they have to reconsider their entire worldview. The readers also can't assume that he'll always be alright and fix all the problems after that.
Well, even that doesn't explain it completely... It's not just about what's done, but the context in which it happens and the way it's carried out.
Whenever I'm planning or writing this stuff, I always picture a nice, smooth symphony just stopping and switching to white noise in an instant, for some reason.
Of course, pulling it off properly is a separate challenge.