Thoughts on my Novel. am a new fairly new writer

Avarice_Of_The_Seven

Fallen Angel Of Rebellion
Joined
Nov 24, 2025
Messages
189
Points
63
Can someone tell me what they think of the first chapters of my novel? Honest criticism and praise please.
Link: Re:Start – To Conquer The Stars As The Evil Lord | Scribble Hub
I've read your first chapter Prologue: The Future King

I've divided my feedback on three levels:

Least critic: Will tell you the most major problems. (clueless reader POV)

Mid critic: Will tell you slightly detailed version of my feedback. (will focus on functionality as a story among other things)

Most critic: Will give my feedback from the prospective of an amateur author. (will involve writing aspects of the chapter and even small details.)

Tell me up to which level of critique you want. I won't sugarcoat my words so please think it through.
 
Last edited:

MakBow

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2025
Messages
326
Points
63
I want to full truth and nothing but the full truth. I want nothing to be held back so yes, 'Most Critic'.
 

Avarice_Of_The_Seven

Fallen Angel Of Rebellion
Joined
Nov 24, 2025
Messages
189
Points
63
Okay, so I'll first talk from a reader's prospective.

The biggest problem about the chapter that I felt was that it made me feel nothing. I understood what was happening but it felt like I was just reading text to understand an incident instead of reading a novel.

The second biggest problem that I felt was that the chapter felt too short and had me left unsatisfied.

Now let's talk about functionality as a story.

The concept of your novel, according to my understanding, is that someone with specific reincarnation fantasies dies an unfortunate sudden death and a god gives him an option to be reincarnated into a world of his choice at his last moments before death.

This concept itself isn't bad, it might be slightly common and used concept but the unique thing about it is that the god gives him choice related to his new world instead of his special powers after reincarnation.
If you develop this better, then it can be unique while still retaining the popular tropes.
But it felt underused in the current chapter. (wasted potential)

Now, I will talk in detail from an author's prospective.

first problem:

-I freaking love aliens and magic.

I’ve always wondered what magic would be like just reading fantasy stories, web novels, and other stuff.

I also really liked the idea of aliens.

I’ve always wondered what aliens would look like.

I mean, there is absolutely no way humans are the only living beings in the universe.

Even someone of pure logic should know that, or else they’re just dumb.

I read the light novel for Konosuba, laughing at the jokes, seeing the magic and how fun it looked, stopping at the train station.

I wonder if isekai is real? Reincarnation definitely is, but would it bring me to another world?

I pondered these questions in my head, not paying attention to my surroundings.-

This sounds so redundant while reading that I don't even know what to say. Most authors will care about redundancy in only two consecutive lines so this is beyond horrible. All sentences begin with 'I'.

Next:

-W-What happened? Is my mind so stimulated that everything looks frozen to me? Am I...really going to die now? I’m only 16. Why did that guy push me?

“I don’t know, don’t ask me.”

At that moment, I heard a voice, an echoing, masculine voice.

W-Who’s that?

“I am me.”

I turned my gaze to the black bird that didn’t look natural, its gaze directed towards me, those glowing yellow eyes piercing into my very being.

What?

“You are going to die, as you can see. You weren’t supposed to die so soon; that is why I am here.”

What are you talking about? Am I just hallucinating? There’s no way a bird is talking to me.-

This description is too weird. It should've been something like:

I turned my gaze towards the direction of this masculine voice and what came into my view was a black bird.

This black bird didn't look natural. It had glowing yellow eyes gazing towards me, and I felt as if those eyes were piercing into my very being.
(It could've been written far better than this but this would be the bare minimum)

The current description needs a lot of work and there are a lot of parts that need work in that single chapter.
Things happened too fast and too weirdly and the flow of writing itself was weird.

Basically, your writing skills need work. I know that you are new and you have a lot of expectations about your first novel, but this could use a lot of work and improve drastically.

I recommend you to first write a chapter and then go read a few chapters of your favorite novel.
Then come back and read your own chapters as a reader and find out the flaws and problems.(it would be easier cuz you just read your favorite novel and your mind has something to compare with)

Your writing skills will improve the more you write so take this into consideration. There are a lot of threads related to writing tips here so you can also read them to get more insight into how to improve your writing.

Conclusion: you can do better so work hard(y)


Side note: Now I know why there are so few people who give reviews. It sucks to criticize someone who is trying and want to know how well they did.
 

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
641
Points
93
Side note: Now I know why there are so few people who give reviews. It sucks to criticize someone who is trying and want to know how well they did.
It really isn't fun. But Tempokai (that twisted abomination of a human) seems to enjoy it. They have a whole thread dedicated to roasting webnovels.
 

MakBow

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2025
Messages
326
Points
63
I
Okay, so I'll first talk from a reader's prospective.

The biggest problem about the chapter that I felt was that it made me feel nothing. I understood what was happening but it felt like I was just reading text to understand an incident instead of reading a novel.

The second biggest problem that I felt was that the chapter felt too short and had me left unsatisfied.

Now let's talk about functionality as a story.

The concept of your novel, according to my understanding, is that someone with specific reincarnation fantasies dies an unfortunate sudden death and a god gives him an option to be reincarnated into a world of his choice at his last moments before death.

This concept itself isn't bad, it might be slightly common and used concept but the unique thing about it is that the god gives him choice related to his new world instead of his special powers after reincarnation.
If you develop this better, then it can be unique while still retaining the popular tropes.
But it felt underused in the current chapter. (wasted potential)

Now, I will talk in detail from an author's prospective.

first problem:

-I freaking love aliens and magic.

I’ve always wondered what magic would be like just reading fantasy stories, web novels, and other stuff.

I also really liked the idea of aliens.

I’ve always wondered what aliens would look like.

I mean, there is absolutely no way humans are the only living beings in the universe.

Even someone of pure logic should know that, or else they’re just dumb.

I read the light novel for Konosuba, laughing at the jokes, seeing the magic and how fun it looked, stopping at the train station.

I wonder if isekai is real? Reincarnation definitely is, but would it bring me to another world?

I pondered these questions in my head, not paying attention to my surroundings.-

This sounds so redundant while reading that I don't even know what to say. Most authors will care about redundancy in only two consecutive lines so this is beyond horrible. All sentences begin with 'I'.

Next:

-W-What happened? Is my mind so stimulated that everything looks frozen to me? Am I...really going to die now? I’m only 16. Why did that guy push me?

“I don’t know, don’t ask me.”

At that moment, I heard a voice, an echoing, masculine voice.

W-Who’s that?

“I am me.”

I turned my gaze to the black bird that didn’t look natural, its gaze directed towards me, those glowing yellow eyes piercing into my very being.

What?

“You are going to die, as you can see. You weren’t supposed to die so soon; that is why I am here.”

What are you talking about? Am I just hallucinating? There’s no way a bird is talking to me.-

This description is too weird. It should've been something like:

I turned my gaze towards the direction of this masculine voice and what came into my view was a black bird.

This black bird didn't look natural. It had glowing yellow eyes gazing towards me, and I felt as if those eyes were piercing into my very being.
(It could've been written far better than this but this would be the bare minimum)

The current description needs a lot of work and there are a lot of parts that need work in that single chapter.
Things happened too fast and too weirdly and the flow of writing itself was weird.

Basically, your writing skills need work. I know that you are new and you have a lot of expectations about your first novel, but this could use a lot of work and improve drastically.

I recommend you to first write a chapter and then go read a few chapters of your favorite novel.
Then come back and read your own chapters as a reader and find out the flaws and problems.(it would be easier cuz you just read your favorite novel and your mind has something to compare with)

Your writing skills will improve the more you write so take this into consideration. There are a lot of threads related to writing tips here so you can also read them to get more insight into how to improve your writing.

Conclusion: you can do better so work hard(y)


Side note: Now I know why there are so few people who give reviews. It sucks to criticize someone who is trying and want to know how well they did.
I can total understand what you mean. I really just wrote with the idea it was only a prologue, so I didn't bother going much in detail. I'll admit that. That's why I went way more in detail in the actual first chapter and beyond. I went in with the fact it was a true first impression, but you are right, I should have done more.
You are also right that it isn't original what I want to do. The idea is basically an old idea I heard about a manga, but that manga was really trash (don't remember its name).
I don't intend to do anything mind breaking, but really just try and maximize what already exists, with my various inspirations from various manga, LN, games, and more.
Overall, thank you for giving me criticism, it motivates me to keep on posting.
 

Avarice_Of_The_Seven

Fallen Angel Of Rebellion
Joined
Nov 24, 2025
Messages
189
Points
63
I

I can total understand what you mean. I really just wrote with the idea it was only a prologue, so I didn't bother going much in detail. I'll admit that. That's why I went way more in detail in the actual first chapter and beyond. I went in with the fact it was a true first impression, but you are right, I should have done more.
You are also right that it isn't original what I want to do. The idea is basically an old idea I heard about a manga, but that manga was really trash (don't remember its name).
I don't intend to do anything mind breaking, but really just try and maximize what already exists, with my various inspirations from various manga, LN, games, and more.
Overall, thank you for giving me criticism, it motivates me to keep on posting.
No matter the chapter, it needs to be the best. Especially the first chapter, cuz it's the most important deciding factor about your novel whether the reader will continue onto the next chapter or not. So take it as seriously as you can.

Only ask for feedback when you don't know what can be improved anymore or if you are confused.

Deliberately leaving a chapter worse if you could've done better is not something that you should ever do.

I don't read only first chapter when I give a review but your first chapter just didn't make me feel like reading further.
 

Macha

{$user.user_title}
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
888
Points
133
Deliberately leaving a chapter worse if you could've done better is not something that you should ever do.
Leaving a chapter worse just to get readers commenting with edit suggestions is virgin RR behavior. We don't do that here. Most users in SH are silent and aren't grammar police.
 

MakBow

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2025
Messages
326
Points
63
Leaving a chapter worse just to get readers commenting with edit suggestions is virgin RR behavior. We don't do that here. Most users in SH are silent and aren't grammar police.
What are you talking about? No, I did not leave it worse intentionally for edit suggestions. There were no grammar errors. I merely stated that I was short-sighted to not put as much effort in the prologue as I did for the future chapters, believing that I had did enough, when I didn't since I was in a rush to get to Chapter 1.
 

Alski

Stray cat
Joined
Jan 10, 2021
Messages
1,400
Points
153
What are you talking about? No, I did not leave it worse intentionally for edit suggestions. There were no grammar errors. I merely stated that I was short-sighted to not put as much effort in the prologue as I did for the future chapters, believing that I had did enough, when I didn't since I was in a rush to get to Chapter 1.

Putting less effort in to one of the first things your potential readers are going to see is only going to hurt you.
 

MakBow

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2025
Messages
326
Points
63
I know, I know. I take the full blame for that. I'm already rewriting it to make it better and more detailed, as well as adding in a bit more characterization for my character before the main story.
 

Avarice_Of_The_Seven

Fallen Angel Of Rebellion
Joined
Nov 24, 2025
Messages
189
Points
63
Putting less effort in to one of the first things your potential readers are going to see is only going to hurt you.
That's what I'm saying. Every chapter needs equal attention. Never intentionally focus less on any chapter.
I mean it is very important to give equal and absolute attention to at least the first ten chapters, cuz the readers generally drop the novel before ten chapters. While I'm not saying that you shouldn't focus on chapter quality after the first ten chapters, it will just have comparatively less drawbacks after ten chapters.(I'm speaking from my own experience, there is a great disparity between the views of my first 10 chapters and after that part.)

Never give attention to scenes, give attention to chapters. Especially the early ones. Your mindset that more important scenes need more attention is inherently flawed if you want readers.

Well, if you're writing just for fun and don't care about whether someone reads your work or not, then you can do according to your own desires. You don't need to take mine or anyone's opinion. But you will have to think about these things if you want readers. (Not saying that you won't get readers otherwise, but their numbers will probably differ.)
 
Last edited:

Fairemont

No Bullying Allowed
Joined
Apr 15, 2025
Messages
606
Points
93
Bad news: It's bland. It reminds me of how I wrote in high school. Ultra-basic young adult fantasy content.

Good news: It means you get the joy of improving, to see your work flourish, to feel the sense of accomplishment when you look back and see how far you've come.

So, as a new writer, you're doing pretty well. Your technical skills are solid enough that you've either studied, practiced, or paid attention in school/college when they were teaching you the basics. So, that is great!

You're struggling with the things a new writer would obviously struggle with. Pacing your content introduction, logistics of storytelling, character interactions feeling a bit flat or inauthentic, and dialogue being simplistic or stilted.

These are to be expected. I started writing in third grade with a children's book, wrote my first full book in eighth grade, and I think that book was about the same quality of work you have right now. Probably cringier, to be honest. I think it took me well into college before I got to a point I considered my writing competent, and another ten years before I got to where I am now.

It's a long road to become a good author. You're getting started. You've got the right spirit, and a good foundation. You've come to a good, helpful community and that can be a massive boon to your progress.

So, my analysis: You're off to a good start, but you probably won't win any awards quite yet.

Keep up the good work! :blob_highfive:
 
Top