The Role Thingies (Author, Rising Author, etc) And The Mechanics Behind Them

Maple-Leaf

Maple-Leaf

•Deceased
Joined
Jun 4, 2020
Messages
681
Points
108
Honestly, I'm surprised they took the time to go and even click the one star button. good enough for me. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
Last edited:
BenJepheneT

BenJepheneT

Syro - Aphex Twin
Joined
Jul 14, 2019
Messages
5,347
Points
233
GDLiZy said:
Well yes, unreasonable 1* happens, but so do unreasonable 5*. I find it distasteful when people complain about 1* and discredit them for being a troll, despite the lack of any evidence.
Click to expand...
I can also agree with those unreasonable 5*s. Simply showering it with praise isn't gonna do it any good, but the same applies to criticism. If you wanna leave an ultra bad/good rating at least give some sort of reasoning behind it.

Unfortunately we're so conditioned with praise, whether it be undeserved or not, we just blindly accepted it. Not that it's any bad, but it isn't anything good either.

It does give that "peck the button and get the corn" dopamine rush so I guess that's that.

GDLiZy said:
Anyway, the rating is purely subjective. People will give a good rating to what they like, and give a bad rating to what they don't like. Ben just doesn't write what people like, and the story with little 1* rating just has what people tend to love.
Click to expand...
Hey, what's not to like about bipedal animals beating the absolute shit out of each other?
 
Assurbanipal_II

Assurbanipal_II

Nyampress of the Four Corners of the World
Joined
Jul 27, 2019
Messages
2,740
Points
153
BenJepheneT said:
I can also agree with those unreasonable 5*s. Simply showering it with praise isn't gonna do it any good, but the same applies to criticism. If you wanna leave an ultra bad/good rating at least give some sort of reasoning behind it.

Unfortunately we're so conditioned with praise, whether it be undeserved or not, we just blindly accepted it. Not that it's any bad, but it isn't anything good either.

It does give that "peck the button and get the corn" dopamine rush so I guess that's that.


Hey, what's not to like about bipedal animals beating the absolute shit out of each other?
Click to expand...

I would contest this claim. Praising is a cultural thing. There are cultures that praise everything, even average works. And there are cultures that only praise exceptional work. Everything else is not worthy of praise.
 
Yorda

Yorda

Villainess Yorda the Virtuous Flower of Evil
Joined
Aug 9, 2019
Messages
468
Points
133
BenJepheneT said:
Unfortunately we're so conditioned with praise, whether it be undeserved or not, we just blindly accepted it. Not that it's any bad, but it isn't anything good either.
Click to expand...
Assurbanipal_II said:
I would contest this claim. Praising is a cultural thing. There are cultures that praise everything, even average works. And there are cultures that only praise exceptional work. Everything else is not worthy of praise.
Click to expand...

Is praise good or bad? I need to see the data first before making a decision.

Specifically, what are the effects of praise (deserved or not) on human productivity and quality of the material produced. For example, perhaps praise has the effect of encouraging creators to produce more work and that in turn provides them with experience to produce higher quality works.

My Personal Opinion: Increased productivity and quality of creations is favourable to reduced productivity and quality, thus actions that promote increased productivity and quality of creations are preferable.

The data would tell me whether praising or not praising would be the optimal solution for my desired result.

The opposite of praise is criticism. I would also like to see the data on the effects of criticism.
 
Assurbanipal_II

Assurbanipal_II

Nyampress of the Four Corners of the World
Joined
Jul 27, 2019
Messages
2,740
Points
153
Yorda said:
Is praise good or bad? I need to see the data first before making a decision.

Specifically, what are the effects of praise (deserved or not) on human productivity and quality of the material produced. For example, perhaps praise has the effect of encouraging creators to produce more work and that in turn provides them with experience to produce higher quality works.

My Personal Opinion: Increased productivity and quality of creations is favourable to reduced productivity and quality, thus actions that promote increased productivity and quality of creations are preferable.

The data would tell me whether praising or not praising would be the optimal solution for my desired result.

The opposite of praise is criticism. I would also like to see the data on the effects of criticism.
Click to expand...

A Yordish answer. :blob_evil_two:
 
BenJepheneT

BenJepheneT

Syro - Aphex Twin
Joined
Jul 14, 2019
Messages
5,347
Points
233
Yorda said:
Is praise good or bad? I need to see the data first before making a decision.

Specifically, what are the effects of praise (deserved or not) on human productivity and quality of the material produced. For example, perhaps praise has the effect of encouraging creators to produce more work and that in turn provides them with experience to produce higher quality works.

My Personal Opinion: Increased productivity and quality of creations is favourable to reduced productivity and quality, thus actions that promote increased productivity and quality of creations are preferable.

The data would tell me whether praising or not praising would be the optimal solution for my desired result.

The opposite of praise is criticism. I would also like to see the data on the effects of criticism.
Click to expand...
Objectively speaking, there's no downside to simply praising for productivity. I mean, results speak for themselves.

Subjectively speaking, there's an inherent quality of manipulation behind the tiny dopamine rush from seeing another 5 star on your story, or simply being kissed in the ass. Intentionally or not, I don't like that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top