Your blatant ignorance reminds me of a quote. "Arguing with idiots is like playing chess with a pigeon. No matter how good you are, the bird is going to shit on the board and strut around like it won anyway."And in that sense I responded, pointing out the problem of your premise. See, everything according to logic.
The pot calling the kettle black, right?
Not in the slightest, I've quoted and screenshotted the premise and defined premise for you, and I've even explained to you what "moving the goalpost" is and how you're using it incorrectly, yet you're still acting like you somehow won something. Go ask your dear friend, Rellawing, to explain to you what a premise is. Hopefully, one day your original story will be as popular as your Naruto fanfic, with an editor that's more knowledgeable than the writer, its not likely but its possible
This part is absolutely correct. I don't think anyone here disagrees with this statement whatsoever.
and:
All these skills would be mightily useless if you are born a peasant. Chemistry ... Economics ...
What are even those economics? Accounting? An excel sheet?
As for networking ... Depending on your fantasy setting, you know how the feudal system works, right?
"It would still be possible, I guess. For example, if the Isekai'd person's background was that he was some kind of mechanic/engineer, who's hobby was tinkering with different things. But the MC would have to be specialized in some sort of field for it to be realistic."Well this is fun.
Do you mind If I join in and try and disect what's happening? If im wrong at some point, please correct me, but:
This part is absolutely correct. I don't think anyone here disagrees with this statement whatsoever.
The problem lies with these parts here:
and:
The implication here, whether intended or not, is that an Isekai could avoid problem (1) by using knowledge of their past life to gain some advantage, making the isekai trope useful over picking a "native residence" of the other world. This is the part that is being challenged here:
In other word, yes, Isekai aren't being used properly, but the concept of a protagonist using modern knowledge to his advantage in an Isekai would be far more difficult/unrealistic than you think.
It would still be possible, I guess. For example, if the Isekai'd person's background was that he was some kind of mechanic/engineer, who's hobby was tinkering with different things. But the MC would have to be specialised in some sort of field for it to be realistic.
Why do you hurt me this way? lol
Coz we authors often lose focus of what's more important: OUR STORIES.
But maybe the real important thing is actually the friends we made along the way
Yes.But maybe the real important thing is actually the friends we made along the way
Nah man, finish what you started.But maybe the real important thing is actually the friends we made along the way
The real important thing is the procrastination we did along the wayBut maybe the real important thing is actually the friends we made along the way
But maybe the real important thing is actually the friends we made along the way
Fwiends?
You can't force me.
Don't you want to sleep with a clean conscience. Think of your few fans. They are your friends and they need you.