Revised chapter 1 and synopsis.

c37

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2025
Messages
194
Points
43
As someone said, my chapter 1 sucked. It had a soulless MC. My synopsis was also misleading. So, I've revised it and rewritten my synopsis.
I would appreciate your feedback on it. Thank you.

Synopsis: Aegis has no interest in destiny. All he wants is coins. In the infernal city of Inanitas, a cambion slave survives by gambling on arena blood and clawing for scraps in a world built on dominance. Power belongs to those who take it, and Aegis intends to take enough to stop feeling owned. When a battle-scarred necromancer arrives in the arena — silent and feared— Aegis sees an opportunity to buy his freedom.






Chapter 1 - A Brat Lost in Blood.
Ninety-four silver, six more, and I won’t be dragged back by the collar tonight.

Aegis, a young cambion with four horns, walked down a stone road. Gray-black buildings passed as his lean figure moved forward. His burning red pupils, swallowed by black sclera, followed the pouch in his hand.

CLANK.

Coins clanked as Aegis tossed the pouch into the air. It was small —Too small to matter to anyone but him. A low whistle slipped past his lips as the pouch landed neatly in his palm.


A roar reached his pointed ears. The ground trembled as if thousands of fiends marched in unison. The arena — the only place where his pouch could get heavier. But before he could reach it.


SPLAT


His tattered leather boots stepped on something. He lifted his feet up to see what it was— filth.


Great! A Klucking hound decided to grace me with its filth. He threw his arms up in irritation, wiping his boot against the stone.


Soon, metal stairs rose before him, stretching upward toward the arena gate. A colossal skull guarded the entrance, its jaw forever screaming. Its hollow eyes pierced Aegis’s soul.

The arena pulsed with snarls at the city’s heart. The Infernus runes pulsed like embers breathing beneath the black surface. “GLORY TO THE STRONG.”

The sound of steel rang across the arena as two fiends were locked in a ferocious duel. A wave of excited growls surrounded them. A wide smile spread across Aegis’s face, exposing two fangs. Blood sprayed into the air as the steel met flesh. His tunic tightened as his chest rose with anticipation.

“Yes, kill him!” he muttered as he felt his pouch getting heavier with each blow. He could feel it getting closer as the fiend he wagered on rained slashes. Six more silver!

The arena erupted as the head with two horns struck the sand. Blood sprayed into the air as the body knelt.

What the kluck? Aegis froze as his pouch suddenly felt lighter.

His palm covered his face as he mumbled. “No, no, not today!”

His voice dissolved into the roar. The arena descended into multiple levels. The crowd clawed at railings, howling for more blood.

“NORKHON!”
“NORKHON!”
“NORKHON!”

Norkhon brandished his battle axe, covered in blood, and roared.

“YGREAHHHH!”

The metal railings around the arena shook as thousands of spectators screamed. The ground trembled beneath their cheers. The dais trembled under bored applause from jewelled fiends. His gaze lingered on them. He wondered what it felt like to sit above everyone.

“There he is!” As soon as the words reached his ears, realisation struck Aegis. The blood wager pit collectors. He forgot he lost the bet and now owes money. Without looking back, Aegis slipped through the crowd like prey escaping. All he hoped was to escape.

Aegis rammed into someone as the crowd surged forward. His hand shot forward and caught something heavy, but before he could leave, the stranger shoved him into the wall beside him.
He let out a sharp grunt and looked up.


He kicked Aegis in the face, bruising his cheek, then spat on him, claws tightening around Aegis’s throat. “You bastard! If you touch me again, I’ll behead you.”


The fiend kicked him again, this time in his ribs. Aegis held his ribs and watched him leave. One day…but for now
He took out a pouch full of coins and shook it. The coins inside clanked. Fool.


He swallowed iron and kept moving. As he made his way toward the Blood Wager Pit, he kept eavesdropping. It had earned him quite a few coins before.


“A necromancer!”


The braziers around the arena flickered. Necromancer? Aegis froze mid-step.


“What do you mean?”


“Don’t you know? A corrupted Eldari arrived in the Inanitas a few months ago.”


“He made quite a name in other Dominions.” The voice paused for a moment before continuing, “I will be the one to disembowel him!” A snarl followed.


“Hold your claws, some say they saw wraiths around him while he was fighting.” Another fiend joined in.


An Eldari necromancer, huh? That sounded expensive.

Aegis reached the Blood Wager Pit. Claws slammed counters as fiends snarled over payouts. Since Aegis was still a teenager, he crouched and made his way to the counter. Inside the counter stood a slender fiend with a single horn on his forehead. He looked at Aegis through his gold-framed glasses. Aegis reached into his pouch and placed some coins on the counter.
“I see you brought the coins. I was afraid I’d have to dissect you and display your body parts as a warning.”
The slender fiend took the coins and sent Aegis away. It took a while for Aegis to crawl out of the crowd. His face tightened with disgust as the metallic smell of sweat hit his nose. His spine popped as he rose from the crowd. Just when he was about to leave, a voice spoke loudly, “The champion of Mistress Vakharath.” Anticipation sharpened his gaze.

“A MILLENNIUM OLD CHAMPION, BUTCHER OF ELDARI,” Aegis ran back into the arena and climbed the railing.

“THE KHRANE IS HERE!”
The arena was filled with snarls and roars.
Aegis’s voice roared along with the crowd.

“KHRANE”
“KHRANE”
“KHRANE”

His eyes brightened as a crimson-skinned fiend stepped forward to speak.

The crimson coat over his black tunic fluttered as the wind blew. The burning red suns in the sky made his gold belt shine bright. His matted, swept-back hair fell below his shoulders, threaded with a few gold studs.

Khrane waved his hand, a faint smile on his face exposed sharp, jagged fangs. Khrane looked in his direction. Aegis forgot to blink.

Had his idol noticed him, or was he going crazy? Below the dais, in the sand, twenty fighters stood. Khrane looked down.

“Champions of the Dominions!”

“I was told you were strong.”

“I was told you were feared.”

“I was told you were undefeated.”

He let the silence stretch… a low grumble escaped as he exhaled.

“So were the last hundred.”

“Do not bore me.”

His mouth parted without permission. My way to freedom…soon.

“I think you forgot it was not just your coin.” A low growl followed.

It was different. Almost as if a girl spoke—


As Aegis turned his head, a young fiend girl with dark-red skin stood to his right, her orange pupils seething with rage. Before Aegis could form a word, a fist landed with familiar affection. He bent and held his stomach and looked at her.


“We decided to bet on Norkhon! Why did you bet against him?” Her gaze softened despite herself.


“Yeah, you keep doing this,” Another voice spoke.


This time it was a young fiend boy with pale orange skin and short brown hair. His brown eyes were fixed on Aegis. Silence surrounded them for a moment.
Familiar disappointment crossed their faces.


Zerra and Kaelran. The only fiends he liked.


“Sorry?” Aegis offered the weakest apology imaginable.


“You will turn us into beggars, you dumbgrog,” Zerra smacked his arm with annoyance.


“Also, your master was looking for you, and he is not happy,” Kaelran added.


Aegis looked down. A moment later, he waved his hand dismissively “Ignore him.”


Zerra leaned closer, and her braided hair moved along with her. “Did you hear this? There is an Eldari necromancer among the twenty champions.”


“I thought necromancers died early?”
Kaelran tilted his head thoughtfully.


“Eh. Doesn’t matter, Eldari die easily anyway.” Aegis shrugged off.


“Look,” Kaelran nudged Aegis’s shoulder and pointed.


The elegantly dressed fiend atop the dais was about to speak.


Soon, a voice spoke loudly.


“CITIZENS OF INANITAS!”


Aegis, Zerra and Kaelran turned their heads toward the host.


“I KNOW YOUR BLOOD IS BOILING, YOUR EYES ARE BURNING. SOON YOUR THIRST WILL BE QUENCHED! THE WAIT FOR THE BATTLE OF THE CENTURY IS OVER! THE TWENTY CHAMPIONS ALL ACROSS INANITAS STAND IN FRONT OF US,”


Aegis leaned in with his hand resting over Zerra’s shoulder.


“THE BUTCHERS, THE MARAUDERS, THE SLAYERS ACROSS THE INANITAS ARE HERE TO FIGHT THE LEGENDARY KHRANE!”


“It is happening!” Kaelran spoke.


“LET US WELCOME THE CHAMPIONS ONE BY ONE.”


Hunger radiated through the stands. The crowd stood waiting in anticipation, and a low grumble echoed across the arena.

The champions passed one after another as the host announced their names.

Tiredness found its way to Aegis, and he leaned on the railing. As Aegis raised his eyes, the host leaned toward the fiend beside him and whispered something.

"A CHAMPION BEYOND ABADDON, "

The crowd was ready to roar once again.

"... A CORRUPTED ELDARI. "

"HIS NAME IS ANANKE! "

A thunderous roar erupted but soon fell silent. Footsteps echoed around the arena. A Hooded Eldari stepped into the arena.

His blackened plate armour clanked as he made his way into the arena. Coins hung suspended between wagers. Cheers withered into murmurs.Braziers around the battle pit dimmed. Heat felt distant.


Zerra rubbed her palms together. Kaelran turned to his friends, “Isn’t it cold?” But Aegis's bright red eyes were fixed on the new champion.

Ananke removed his hood, revealing his face. His gaze swept the arena, emerald-green eyes scanning every face before halting on Aegis.

The railing felt colder under his grip. “…Mistake.” The cold breath of air brushed him again.
 
Last edited:

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,573
Points
113
Dude... after reading chapter 1 once, I noticed your narrative has a sudden POV shift problem that makes it prone to head hopping.

Your narrative mixes a limited third POV (through Aegis) and an omniscient third POV that tries to explain the environmental conditions (the colossium?).

As a result, the reader's perception loses focus. The reader feels like they have lost the character's lens to enter the story. So this leads to being prone to head hopping.

The solution I offer is that your narrative should focus on a limited third POV through Aegis. You may be confused about narrating a limited third POV.

Simply put, a limited third POV is a point of view that follows a character's subjective experience.

You need to be more disciplined in narrating through Aegis' perception.

Imagine yourself as Aegis and then write about his experience through his 5 senses + physiological + thoughts + feelings + kinetics (character movement) in interacting with his world.
 

c37

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2025
Messages
194
Points
43
Dude... after reading chapter 1 once, I noticed your narrative has a sudden POV shift problem that makes it prone to head hopping.

Your narrative mixes a limited third POV (through Aegis) and an omniscient third POV that tries to explain the environmental conditions (the colossium?).

As a result, the reader's perception loses focus. The reader feels like they have lost the character's lens to enter the story. So this leads to being prone to head hopping.

The solution I offer is that your narrative should focus on a limited third POV through Aegis. You may be confused about narrating a limited third POV.

Simply put, a limited third POV is a point of view that follows a character's subjective experience.

You need to be more disciplined in narrating through Aegis' perception.

Imagine yourself as Aegis and then write about his experience through his 5 senses + physiological + thoughts + feelings + kinetics (character movement) in interacting with his world.
Okay, is that the only problem you found? Or do I have to fix something else too? Thanks for replying.
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,573
Points
113
Okay, is that the only problem you found? Or do I have to fix something else too? Thanks for replying.
There are actually many criticisms I could make. But now I disike to burden authors with too many demands. I prefer to suggest the most crucial point that will have the greatest impact on your narrative.
 

c37

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2025
Messages
194
Points
43
w
There are actually many criticisms I could make. But now I disike to burden authors with too many demands. I prefer to suggest the most crucial point that will have the greatest impact on your narrative.
Tried to fix the pov shifts and re-written few cinematic sections. :blob_cookie:
Ninety-four silver, six more, and I won’t be dragged back by the collar tonight.

Aegis, a young cambion with four horns, walked down a stone road. Gray-black buildings passed as his lean figure moved forward. His burning red pupils, swallowed by black sclera, followed the pouch in his hand.

CLANK.

Coins clanked as Aegis tossed the pouch into the air. It was small —Too small to matter to anyone but him. A low whistle slipped past his lips as the pouch landed neatly in his palm.

A roar reached his pointed ears. The ground trembled as if thousands of fiends marched in unison. The arena — the only place where his pouch could get heavier. But before he could reach it.

SPLAT

His tattered leather boots stepped on something. He lifted his feet up to see what it was— filth.

"Great! A Klucking hound decided to grace me with its filth." He threw his arms up in irritation, wiping his boot against the stone.

Soon, metal stairs rose before him, stretching upward toward the arena gate. A colossal skull guarded the entrance, its jaw forever screaming. Its hollow eyes pierced Aegis’s soul.

The arena roared. Heat brushed his face as the runes in the stone flared red beneath his boots. “GLORY TO THE STRONG.”

The sound of steel rang across the arena as two fiends were locked in a ferocious duel. Growls rose behind him. Claws scraped railings. Someone shoved his shoulder. A wide smile spread across Aegis’s face, exposing two fangs. Blood sprayed into the air as the steel met flesh. His tunic tightened as his chest rose with anticipation.

“Yes, kill him!” he muttered as he felt his pouch getting heavier with each blow. He could feel it getting closer as the fiend he wagered on rained slashes. Six more silver!

The arena erupted as the head with two horns struck the sand. Blood sprayed into the air as the body knelt.

What the kluck? Aegis froze as his pouch suddenly felt lighter than it should have.

His palm covered his face as he mumbled. “No, no, not today!”

His voice dissolved into the roar. The arena descended into multiple levels beneath him. The crowd clawed at railings, howling for more blood.

“NORKHON!”
“NORKHON!”
“NORKHON!”

Norkhon brandished his battle axe, covered in blood, and roared.

“YGREAHHHH!”

The metal railings around the arena shook as thousands of spectators screamed. The ground trembled beneath their cheers. The dais trembled as the jewelled fiends clapped lazily from above. His gaze lingered on them. He wondered what it felt like to sit above everyone.

“There he is!” As soon as the words reached his ears, realisation struck Aegis. The blood wager pit collectors. He forgot he lost the bet and now owes money. Without looking back, Aegis slipped through the crowd like prey escaping. All he hoped was to escape.

Aegis rammed into someone as the crowd surged forward. His hand shot forward and caught something heavy, but before he could leave, the stranger shoved him into the wall beside him.
He let out a sharp grunt and looked up.

He kicked Aegis in the face, bruising his cheek, then spat on him, claws tightening around Aegis’s throat. “You bastard! If you touch me again, I’ll behead you.”

The fiend kicked him again, this time in his ribs. Aegis held his ribs and watched him leave. One day…but for now
He took out a pouch full of coins and shook it. The coins inside clanked. Fool.

He swallowed iron and kept moving. As he made his way toward the Blood Wager Pit, he kept eavesdropping. It had earned him quite a few coins before.

“A necromancer!”

The braziers around the arena flickered. Necromancer? Aegis froze mid-step.

“What do you mean?”

“Don’t you know? A corrupted Eldari arrived in the Inanitas a few months ago.”

“He made quite a name in other Dominions.” The voice paused for a moment before continuing, “I will be the one to disembowel him!” A snarl followed.


“Hold your claws, some say they saw wraiths around him while he was fighting.” Another fiend joined in.


An Eldari necromancer, huh? That sounded expensive.

Aegis reached the Blood Wager Pit. Claws slammed counters as fiends snarled over payouts. Since Aegis was still a teenager, he crouched and made his way to the counter. Inside the counter stood a slender fiend with a single horn on his forehead. He looked at Aegis through his gold-framed glasses. Aegis reached into his pouch and placed some coins on the counter.
“I see you brought the coins. I was afraid I’d have to dissect you and display your body parts as a warning.”
The slender fiend took the coins and sent Aegis away. It took a while for Aegis to crawl out of the crowd. His face tightened with disgust as the metallic smell of sweat hit his nose. His spine popped as he rose from the crowd. Just when he was about to leave, a voice spoke loudly, “The champion of Mistress Vakharath.” Anticipation sharpened his gaze.

“A MILLENNIUM OLD CHAMPION, BUTCHER OF ELDARI,” Aegis ran back into the arena and climbed the railing.

“THE KHRANE IS HERE!”
The arena was filled with snarls and roars.
Aegis’s voice roared along with the crowd.

“KHRANE”
“KHRANE”
“KHRANE”

His eyes brightened as a crimson-skinned fiend stepped forward to speak.

The crimson coat over his black tunic fluttered as the wind blew. The burning red suns in the sky made his gold belt shine bright. His matted, swept-back hair fell below his shoulders, threaded with a few gold studs.

Khrane waved his hand, a faint smile on his face exposed sharp, jagged fangs. Khrane looked in his direction. Aegis forgot to blink.

Had his idol noticed him, or was he going crazy? Below the dais, in the sand, twenty fighters stood. Khrane looked down.

“Champions of the Dominions!”

“I was told you were strong.”

“I was told you were feared.”

“I was told you were undefeated.”

He let the silence stretch… a low grumble escaped as he exhaled.

“So were the last hundred.”

“Do not bore me.”

His mouth parted without permission. My way to freedom…soon.

“I think you forgot it was not just your coin.” A low growl followed.

It was different. Almost as if a girl spoke—

As Aegis turned his head, a young fiend girl with dark-red skin stood to his right, her orange pupils seething with rage. Before Aegis could form a word, a fist landed with familiar affection. He bent and held his stomach and looked at her.

“We decided to bet on Norkhon! Why did you bet against him?” Her gaze softened despite herself.

“Yeah, you keep doing this,” Another voice spoke.

This time it was a young fiend boy with pale orange skin and short brown hair. His brown eyes were fixed on Aegis. Silence surrounded them for a moment.
Zerra’s mouth tightened. Kaelran didn’t meet his eyes.

Great. They knew.

“Sorry?” Aegis offered the weakest apology imaginable.

“You will turn us into beggars, you dumbgrog,” Zerra smacked his arm with annoyance.

“Also, your master was looking for you, and he is not happy,” Kaelran added.

Aegis looked down. A moment later, he waved his hand dismissively “Ignore him.”

Zerra leaned closer, and her braided hair moved along with her. “Did you hear this? There is an Eldari necromancer among the twenty champions.”

“I thought necromancers died early?”
Kaelran tilted his head thoughtfully.

“Eh. Doesn’t matter, Eldari die easily anyway.” Aegis shrugged off.

“Look,” Kaelran nudged Aegis’s shoulder and pointed.

The elegantly dressed fiend atop the dais was about to speak.

Soon, a voice spoke loudly.

“CITIZENS OF INANITAS!”

Aegis, Zerra and Kaelran turned their heads toward the host.

“I KNOW YOUR BLOOD IS BOILING, YOUR EYES ARE BURNING. SOON YOUR THIRST WILL BE QUENCHED! THE WAIT FOR THE BATTLE OF THE CENTURY IS OVER! THE TWENTY CHAMPIONS ALL ACROSS INANITAS STAND IN FRONT OF US,”

Aegis leaned in with his hand resting over Zerra’s shoulder.

“THE BUTCHERS, THE MARAUDERS, THE SLAYERS ACROSS THE INANITAS ARE HERE TO FIGHT THE LEGENDARY KHRANE!”

“It is happening!” Kaelran spoke.

“LET US WELCOME THE CHAMPIONS ONE BY ONE.”

Hunger radiated through the stands. The crowd stood waiting in anticipation, and a low grumble echoed across the arena.

The champions passed one after another as the host announced their names.

His elbows pressed harder into the railing. As Aegis raised his eyes, the host leaned toward the fiend beside him and whispered something.

"A CHAMPION BEYOND ABADDON, "

The crowd was ready to roar once again.

"... A CORRUPTED ELDARI. "

"HIS NAME IS ANANKE! "

A thunderous roar erupted but soon fell silent. Footsteps echoed around the arena. A Hooded Eldari stepped into the arena.

His blackened plate armour clanked as he made his way into the arena. Coins hung suspended between wagers. Cheers withered into murmurs. Braziers around the battle pit dimmed. Heat felt distant.

Zerra rubbed her palms together. Kaelran turned to his friends, “Isn’t it cold?” But Aegis's bright red eyes were fixed on the new champion.

Ananke removed his hood, revealing his face. His gaze swept the arena, emerald-green eyes scanning every face before halting on Aegis.

The railing felt colder under his grip. “…Mistake.” The cold breath of air brushed him again.
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,573
Points
113
Soon, metal stairs rose before him, stretching upward toward the arena gate. A colossal skull guarded the entrance, its jaw forever screaming. Its hollow eyes pierced Aegis’s soul.
(Need a transition here...)
The arena roared. Heat brushed his face as the runes in the stone flared red beneath his boots. “GLORY TO THE STRONG.”
Rough transition, the character feels like they teleported from the gate to the arena because there is no kinetic movement showing from the gate to the arena. It would take a paragraph of transition about the character's movement from the gate mouth to the arena. For example:

"Aegis climbed the stairs slowly. His pouch jingled with each step. 1, 2, 4, 10, 30 steps... Aegis arrived at the arena hall. The roar of the crowd echoed in his ears as if welcoming his arrival."
 

FRWriter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2024
Messages
527
Points
108
I don't really want to accuse you of anything, and I think you know that I already helped you, so I have good intentions, but either you are using some weird writing software or copy-paste out of AI (maybe for editing), or you do some other weird things. You have vastly different-sized paragraphs. This looks a little stupid, and I'd immediately drop a story like that. It really takes just a few minutes of effort to fix it.

Your first draft had even more cases of that, but even your latest version has some (look at the screenshot).

Also, your narration is extremely confusing.

Sometimes it's a neutral third-person narrator, and sometimes it's the MC's thought.

You don't differentiate between them at all.

This is one paragraph:

The braziers around the arena flickered. Necromancer? Aegis froze mid-step.

The first and the last tiny sentence is the voice of the narrator, and in the middle of those two narrated line you have the MC's thoughts.

I'd recommend using italics to differentiate between them at the VERY LEAST.

Also, your sentences feel a little clunky. The story doesn't flow well at all. You use short sentences, and despite being in the same paragraphs, some sentences are completely unrelated or describe two different events.

I think @Eldoria gave a good example already. You need to work on that. Also, I don't know who is speaking half of the time. If you do not use "XXX says, roars, replies," or whatever, your context needs to be perfectly clear so the reader knows whose dialogue he's currently reading. That isn't the case, imo.
1772563089303.png
 
Last edited:

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,573
Points
113
The scene visualization is still rough and blurry. Readers might be confused about where your character is, who they're with, and where their position is.

Try dividing the scene into blocks, such as a scene in the stands, a scene at the ticket counter, a scene in the break room, etc.

Provide spatial and temporal context and spatial clues about your character's position.

This way, readers can follow your character's movements without feeling like they've appeared suddenly.
 

BeezussWrites

New member
Joined
Apr 2, 2025
Messages
6
Points
3
I'm okay with fragments usually, but I feel like you overused them a bit here. Like when you say The arena — the only place where his pouch could get heavier. Why can't it just be The arena was the only place where his pouch could get heavier? And with "He lifted his feet up to see what it was— filth." I feel like describing what was under his shoe wouldn't be a bad idea, but again, that might just be the voice you're going for. Again, not saying this really is anything but a me problem as a reader, but I feel like relying on fragments made it feel way too choppy. And the "They call you undefeated" part was killing my brain. It's definitely possible it's one of those things that is just me, but I feel like "They told me you were undefeated..." the pause, then "Then again, they told me the same thing about the last hundred." because I really didn't fully understand what was being said until the third of fourth read of that line. And the biggest part that caught my eye on the first read was "Almost as if a girl spoke—" not only was it a girl, which made "as if it was a girl" a bit weird, but it was someone he knew. I feel like he should've at least recognized the voice a bit. Lastly... I'm not sure what was going on with all the Klucking. Is this something I missed, or are your characters part chicken? Overall, I do think you have a cool idea in mind. I liked the entrance of Ananke, and the "Mistake" ending. But the problems leading up to it dulled its impact.
 

c37

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2025
Messages
194
Points
43
I don't really want to accuse you of anything, and I think you know that I already helped you, so I have good intentions, but either you are using some weird writing software or copy-paste out of AI (maybe for editing), or you do some other weird things. You have vastly different-sized paragraphs. This looks a little stupid, and I'd immediately drop a story like that. It really takes just a few minutes of effort to fix it.

Your first draft had even more, but even your latest version has some:

View attachment 47092
I write in an app called Scrivener, in it I have to press enter twice to give space between paragraphs. Sometimes I press enter three times.
I'm okay with fragments usually, but I feel like you overused them a bit here. Like when you say The arena — the only place where his pouch could get heavier. Why can't it just be The arena was the only place where his pouch could get heavier? And with "He lifted his feet up to see what it was— filth." I feel like describing what was under his shoe wouldn't be a bad idea, but again, that might just be the voice you're going for. Again, not saying this really is anything but a me problem as a reader, but I feel like relying on fragments made it feel way too choppy. And the "They call you undefeated" part was killing my brain. It's definitely possible it's one of those things that is just me, but I feel like "They told me you were undefeated..." the pause, then "Then again, they told me the same thing about the last hundred." because I really didn't fully understand what was being said until the third of fourth read of that line. And the biggest part that caught my eye on the first read was "Almost as if a girl spoke—" not only was it a girl, which made "as if it was a girl" a bit weird, but it was someone he knew. I feel like he should've at least recognized the voice a bit. Lastly... I'm not sure what was going on with all the Klucking. Is this something I missed, or are your characters part chicken? Overall, I do think you have a cool idea in mind. I liked the entrance of Ananke, and the "Mistake" ending. But the problems leading up to it dulled its impact.
kluck is a slur in the world, which I listed in the glossary section of the book.
Rough transition, the character feels like they teleported from the gate to the arena because there is no kinetic movement showing from the gate to the arena. It would take a paragraph of transition about the character's movement from the gate mouth to the arena. For example:
I don't really want to accuse you of anything, and I think you know that I already helped you, so I have good intentions, but either you are using some weird writing software or copy-paste out of AI (maybe for editing), or you do some other weird things. You have vastly different-sized paragraphs. This looks a little stupid, and I'd immediately drop a story like that. It really takes just a few minutes of effort to fix it.

Your first draft had even more cases of that, but even your latest version has some (look at the screenshot).

Also, your narration is extremely confusing.

Sometimes it's a neutral third-person narrator, and sometimes it's the MC's thought.

You don't differentiate between them at all.

This is one paragraph:

The braziers around the arena flickered. Necromancer? Aegis froze mid-step.

The first and the last tiny sentence is the voice of the narrator, and in the middle of those two narrated line you have the MC's thoughts.

I'd recommend using italics to differentiate between them at the VERY LEAST.

Also, your sentences feel a little clunky. The story doesn't flow well at all. You use short sentences, and despite being in the same paragraphs, some sentences are completely unrelated or describe two different events.

I think @Eldoria gave a good example already. You need to work on that. Also, I don't know who is speaking half of the time. If you do not use "XXX says, roars, replies," or whatever, your context needs to be perfectly clear so the reader knows whose dialogue he's currently reading. That isn't the case, imo.
View attachment 47092
I'm okay with fragments usually, but I feel like you overused them a bit here. Like when you say The arena — the only place where his pouch could get heavier. Why can't it just be The arena was the only place where his pouch could get heavier? And with "He lifted his feet up to see what it was— filth." I feel like describing what was under his shoe wouldn't be a bad idea, but again, that might just be the voice you're going for. Again, not saying this really is anything but a me problem as a reader, but I feel like relying on fragments made it feel way too choppy. And the "They call you undefeated" part was killing my brain. It's definitely possible it's one of those things that is just me, but I feel like "They told me you were undefeated..." the pause, then "Then again, they told me the same thing about the last hundred." because I really didn't fully understand what was being said until the third of fourth read of that line. And the biggest part that caught my eye on the first read was "Almost as if a girl spoke—" not only was it a girl, which made "as if it was a girl" a bit weird, but it was someone he knew. I feel like he should've at least recognized the voice a bit. Lastly... I'm not sure what was going on with all the Klucking. Is this something I missed, or are your characters part chicken? Overall, I do think you have a cool idea in mind. I liked the entrance of Ananke, and the "Mistake" ending. But the problems leading up to it dulled its impact.
I've tried fixing what I could. If you guys still have the patience to take a look. Here it is.
Ninety-four silver, six more, and I won’t be dragged back by the collar tonight.

Aegis, a young cambion with four horns, walked down a stone road. Gray-black buildings passed as his lean figure moved forward. His burning red pupils, swallowed by black sclera, followed the pouch in his hand.

CLANK.

Coins clanked as Aegis tossed the pouch into the air. It was small —Too small to matter to anyone but him. A low whistle slipped past his lips as the pouch landed neatly in his palm.

A roar reached his pointed ears. The ground trembled as if thousands of fiends marched in unison. The arena — the only place where his pouch could get heavier. But before he could reach it.

SPLAT

His tattered leather boots stepped on something. He lifted his feet to see what it was—

"Great! A Klucking hound decided to grace me with its filth." He threw his arms up in irritation, wiping his boot against the stone.

Soon, metal stairs rose before him, stretching upward toward the arena gate. A colossal skull guarded the entrance, its jaw forever screaming. Its hollow eyes pierced Aegis’s soul.

With each step, Aegis got closer to the entrance. The metallic smell of the sweat welcomed him as he entered the arena hall. On his right stood the blood wager pit. His feet instinctively carried him toward it. His eyes examined the board, “Norkhon challenges Zigor.”

After a moment of silence, he turned toward the counter. “I wager ninty-four silver on Zigor.”
A familiar slender fiend nodded and entered his name in the ledger.

He walked toward the spectators’ attic. Cambions and poor fiends surrounded him as he walked.

Am I forgetting something? Aegis froze mid-step. But he ignored it and walked. Soon, the champions’ names resounded, and the spectators beside him roared. Heat brushed his face as the runes in the stone flared red beneath his boots. “GLORY TO THE STRONG.”

The sound of steel rang across the arena as two fiends were locked in a ferocious duel. Growls rose behind him. Claws scraped railings. Someone shoved his shoulder. A wide smile spread across Aegis’s face, exposing two fangs. Blood sprayed into the air as the steel met flesh. His tunic tightened as his chest rose with anticipation.

“Yes, kill him!” he muttered as he felt his pouch getting heavier with each blow. He could feel it getting closer as the fiend he wagered on rained slashes. Six more silver!

The arena erupted as the two-horned head struck the sand. Blood sprayed into the air as the body knelt.

What the kluck? Aegis froze as his pouch suddenly felt lighter than it should have.

His palm covered his face as he mumbled. “No, no, not today!”

His voice dissolved into the roar. The arena descended into multiple levels beneath him. The crowd clawed at railings, howling for more blood.

“NORKHON!”
“NORKHON!”
“NORKHON!”

Norkhon brandished his battle axe, covered in blood, and roared.

“YGREAHHHH!”

The railing rattled under his grip. Screams battered his ears. The ground trembled beneath their cheers. The dais trembled as the jewelled fiends clapped lazily from above. His gaze lingered on them. He wondered what it felt like to sit above everyone.

“There he is!” As soon as the words reached his ears, realisation struck Aegis. The blood wager pit collectors. He forgot he lost the bet and now owes money. Without looking back, Aegis slipped through the crowd like prey escaping. All he hoped was to escape.

Aegis rammed into someone as the crowd surged forward. His hand shot forward and caught something heavy, but before he could leave, the stranger shoved him into the wall beside him.
He let out a sharp grunt and looked up.

He kicked Aegis in the face, bruising his cheek, then spat on him, claws tightening around Aegis’s throat. “You bastard! If you touch me again, I’ll behead you.”

The fiend kicked him again, this time in his ribs. Aegis held his ribs and watched him leave. One day…but for now
He took out a pouch full of coins and shook it. The coins inside clanked. Fool.

He swallowed iron and kept moving. As he made his way toward the Blood Wager Pit, he kept eavesdropping. It had earned him quite a few coins before.

“A necromancer!”

The brazier beside him flickered. Necromancer? Aegis froze mid-step.

“What do you mean?”

“Don’t you know? A corrupted Eldari arrived in the Inanitas a few months ago.”

“He made quite a name in other Dominions.” The voice paused for a moment before continuing, “I will be the one to disembowel him!” A snarl followed.

“Hold your claws, some say they saw wraiths around him while he was fighting.” Another fiend joined in.

An Eldari necromancer, huh? That sounded expensive.

Aegis reached the Blood Wager Pit. Claws slammed counters as fiends snarled over payouts. Aegis crouched and made his way to the counter. Inside the counter stood a slender fiend with a single horn on his forehead. He looked at Aegis through his gold-framed glasses. Aegis reached into his pouch and placed some coins on the counter.


“I see you brought the coins. I was afraid I’d have to dissect you and display your body parts as a warning.”


The slender fiend took the coins and sent Aegis away. It took a while for Aegis to crawl out of the crowd. His face tightened with disgust as the metallic smell of sweat hit his nose again. Finally, he crawled out. His spine popped as he rose from the crowd. Just when he was about to leave, a voice spoke loudly, “The champion of Mistress Vakharath.” Anticipation sharpened his gaze.

“A MILLENNIUM OLD CHAMPION, BUTCHER OF ELDARI,” Aegis ran back into the arena and climbed the railing.

“THE KHRANE IS HERE!”
The arena was filled with snarls and roars.
Aegis’s voice roared along with the crowd.

“KHRANE”
“KHRANE”
“KHRANE”

His eyes brightened as a crimson-skinned fiend stepped forward to speak.

The crimson coat over his black tunic fluttered as the wind blew. The burning red suns in the sky made his gold belt shine bright. His matted, swept-back hair fell below his shoulders, threaded with a few gold studs.

Khrane waved his hand, a faint smile on his face exposed sharp, jagged fangs. Khrane looked in his direction. Aegis forgot to blink.

Had his idol noticed him, or was he going crazy? Below the dais, in the sand, twenty fighters stood. Khrane looked down.

“Champions of the Dominions!”

“I was told you were strong. I was told you were feared. I was told you were undefeated.”

He let the silence stretch… a low grumble escaped as he exhaled.

“So were the last hundred. Do not bore me.”

His mouth parted without permission. My way to freedom…soon.

“I think you forgot it was not just your coin.” A low growl followed.

He knew that voice—

As Aegis turned his head, a young fiend girl with dark-red skin stood to his right, her orange pupils seething with rage. Before Aegis could form a word, a fist landed with familiar affection. He bent and held his stomach and looked at her.

“We decided to bet on Norkhon! Why did you bet against him?” Her gaze softened despite herself.

“Yeah, you keep doing this,” Another voice spoke.

This time it was a young fiend boy with pale orange skin and short brown hair. His brown eyes were fixed on Aegis. Silence surrounded them for a moment.
Zerra’s mouth tightened. Kaelran didn’t meet his eyes.


Great. They knew.

“Sorry?” Aegis offered the weakest apology imaginable.

“You will turn us into beggars, you dumbgrog,” Zerra smacked his arm with annoyance.

“Also, your master was looking for you, and he is not happy,” Kaelran added.

Aegis looked down. A moment later, he waved his hand dismissively “Ignore him.”

Zerra leaned closer, and her braided hair moved along with her. “Did you hear this? There is an Eldari necromancer among the twenty champions.”

“I thought necromancers died early?”
Kaelran tilted his head.

“Eh. Doesn’t matter, Eldari die easily anyway.” Aegis shrugged off.

“Look,” Kaelran nudged Aegis’s shoulder and pointed.

The elegantly dressed fiend atop the dais was about to speak.

Soon, a voice spoke loudly.

“CITIZENS OF INANITAS!”

Aegis, Zerra and Kaelran turned their heads toward the host.

“I KNOW YOUR BLOOD IS BOILING, YOUR EYES ARE BURNING. SOON YOUR THIRST WILL BE QUENCHED! THE WAIT FOR THE BATTLE OF THE CENTURY IS OVER! THE TWENTY CHAMPIONS ALL ACROSS INANITAS STAND IN FRONT OF US,”

Aegis leaned in with his hand resting over Zerra’s shoulder.

“THE BUTCHERS, THE MARAUDERS, THE SLAYERS ACROSS THE INANITAS ARE HERE TO FIGHT THE LEGENDARY KHRANE!”

“It is happening!” Kaelran spoke.

“LET US WELCOME THE CHAMPIONS ONE BY ONE.”

The crowd leaned forward in anticipation, and a low grumble echoed across the arena.

Name after name blurred together. He stopped listening.

His elbows pressed harder into the railing. As Aegis raised his eyes, the host leaned toward the fiend beside him and whispered something.

"A CHAMPION BEYOND ABADDON, "

The crowd was ready to roar once again.

"... A CORRUPTED ELDARI. "

"HIS NAME IS ANANKE! "

A thunderous roar erupted but soon fell silent. Footsteps echoed around the arena. A Hooded Eldari stepped into the arena.

His blackened plate armour clanked as he made his way into the arena. Coins hung suspended between wagers. Cheers withered into murmurs. Braziers around the battle pit dimmed. The warmth against his skin faded.

Zerra rubbed her palms together. Kaelran turned to his friends, “Isn’t it cold?” But Aegis's bright red eyes were fixed on the new champion.

Ananke removed his hood, revealing his face. His gaze swept the arena, emerald-green eyes scanning every face before halting on Aegis.

The railing felt colder under his grip. “…Mistake.” The cold breath of air brushed him again.
 
Last edited:

FRWriter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2024
Messages
527
Points
108
I really don't want to confuse you, but now you've got even more holes (long blanks between paragraphs). Also, some of the MC's thoughts are now in italics, others aren't. It's a mix now.

Aside from that, I feel like it's definitely a little better, but not at a point where I'd call it finished. Still needs work.
 

c37

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2025
Messages
194
Points
43
I really don't want to confuse you, but now you've got even more holes (long blanks between paragraphs). Also, some of the MC's thoughts are now in italics, others aren't. It's a mix now.

Aside from that, I feel like it's definitely a little better, but not at a point where I'd call it finished. Still needs work.
By holes, do you mean just the blanks between paragraphs? fu*k this app i'll just switch to Word.
 

Makimaam

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 17, 2025
Messages
112
Points
63
I like your initial synopsis, don’t get me wrong, but you need to center it around Aegis instead of the paladin. Right now, you’ve dropped that part altogether and it reads as generic. I don’t quite remember the original, so here’s a suggested rough edit:


Must we atone for the sins of our fathers?

This question haunts Aegis long before he understands who, or what, he is. All he wants is to claw out of slavery in the only way a lowborn cambion knows how: gambling on blood-tainted coins won in the arena, betting on lives.

In this infernal city of Inanitas, morality takes a back seat to survival. Until one chance encounter with a Necromancer changes his life forever. And the whispers Aegis has been ignoring for so long surge back louder.

Is survival all there is to it?

Or was his debt never mere coins, but a penance for the sins of a past Paladin he cannot even remember?

———-
That’s a rough one but you still need to add a stronger hook about Aegis’s destiny to draw readers into the chapter.
 

c37

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2025
Messages
194
Points
43
I like your initial synopsis, don’t get me wrong, but you need to center it around Aegis instead of the paladin. Right now, you’ve dropped that part altogether and it reads as generic. I don’t quite remember the original, so here’s a suggested rough edit:


Must we atone for the sins of our fathers?

This question haunts Aegis long before he understands who, or what, he is. All he wants is to claw out of slavery in the only way a lowborn cambion knows how: gambling on blood-tainted coins won in the arena, betting on lives.

In this infernal city of Inanitas, morality takes a back seat to survival. Until one chance encounter with a Necromancer changes his life forever. And the whispers Aegis has been ignoring for so long surge back louder.

Is survival all there is to it?

Or was his debt never mere coins, but a penance for the sins of a past Paladin he cannot even remember?

———-
That’s a rough one but you still need to add a stronger hook about Aegis’s destiny to draw readers into the chapter.
Must a son pay for the sins of a father he never knew?

Aegis doesn’t care about sins. He cares about silver.

In the infernal city of Inanitas, a lowborn cambion survives by gambling on blood in the arena—betting on champions, scraping together coins, and dreaming of the day he can buy his freedom.

Morality is a luxury. Survival is not.

When Aegis crosses paths with a feared Eldari necromancer, he sees something he has never had before—an opportunity. If he plays this right, the necromancer could be his way out.

But whispers follow the man. And they follow Aegis, too.

Because the price of freedom may be more than coin…
and the debt hanging over Aegis may not belong to him at all.

Is this fine?
 

Makimaam

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 17, 2025
Messages
112
Points
63
It’s better, though a few things are missing:

1. Why drop the Paladin? The hint that a half demon boy has a saintly Paladin for a father is actually the hook.

2. The sentence borders on cliché again. Lines like these need more originality: “Morality is a luxury. Survival is not.”
When Aegis crosses paths with a feared Eldari necromancer, he sees something he has never had before—an opportunity.
Are you sure? For a thief, being opportunistic is part of his personality.



Must a son pay for the sins of a father he never knew?

Aegis doesn’t care about sins. He cares about silver.

In the infernal city of Inanitas, a lowborn cambion survives by gambling on blood in the arena—betting on champions, scraping together coins, and dreaming of the day he can buy his freedom.

Morality is a luxury. Survival is not.

When Aegis crosses paths with a feared Eldari necromancer, he sees something he has never had before—an opportunity. If he plays this right, the necromancer could be his way out.

But whispers follow the man. And they follow Aegis, too.

Because the price of freedom may be more than coin…
and the debt hanging over Aegis may not belong to him at all.

Is this fine?
 

c37

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2025
Messages
194
Points
43
It’s better, though a few things are missing:

1. Why drop the Paladin? The hint that a half demon boy has a saintly Paladin for a father is actually the hook.

2. The sentence borders on cliché again. Lines like these need more originality: “Morality is a luxury. Survival is not.”

Are you sure? For a thief, being opportunistic is part of his personality.
The reason I removed paladin part was because of Aegis being my long-term MC. Right now, I have two MCs with dual pov for every 2-3 chapters for the short term( not that short ), so I thought removing it might send false information. But what you said is correct.
 

Makimaam

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 17, 2025
Messages
112
Points
63
The reason I removed paladin part was because of Aegis being my long-term MC. Right now, I have two MCs with dual pov for every 2-3 chapters for the short term( not that short ), so I thought removing it might send false information. But what you said is correct.
Since Aegis is your long term MC, you need to tease the readers more about the story arc. As of now, it already offers some teasing but is still borderline vague though better than the original synopsis, where he reads like a spectator in his own story.

How you tease it is entirely up to you.
 

c37

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2025
Messages
194
Points
43
Since Aegis is your long term MC, you need to tease the readers more about the story arc. As of now, it already offers some teasing but is still borderline vague though better than the original synopsis, where he reads like a spectator in his own story.

How you tease it is entirely up to you.
Must a son answer for the sins of a father he never knew?
Aegis was born a cambion in the infernal city of Inanitas — a place where fiends rule, cambions scrape by, and the only law worth respecting is coin. Freedom is expensive, and Aegis has only one way to earn it: gambling on blood in the arena.
Bet on the right champion.
Collect the silver.
Stay alive long enough to buy his freedom.
Then an Eldari necromancer enters the arena.
To Aegis, the man looks less like a monster and more like an opportunity — a champion worth following, manipulating, or selling information about.
But when the necromancer sees the boy, he sees something else.
Hope.
His son.
The closer Aegis drifts toward the mysterious Eldari, the louder the whispers around him become. Because the boy chasing silver may be tied to something far older than the arena.
After all, cambions are born from fiends. So how could Aegis possibly be the son of a Paladin?
And if that is true…
What sin is he meant to atone for? edited it. And thank you for reading.
 

c37

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2025
Messages
194
Points
43
I really don't want to confuse you, but now you've got even more holes (long blanks between paragraphs). Also, some of the MC's thoughts are now in italics, others aren't. It's a mix now.

Aside from that, I feel like it's definitely a little better, but not at a point where I'd call it finished. Still needs work.
Hey, sorry to bother you again, I decided to re-read my favourite novels and learn what they did and apply them.
Ninety-four,

Aegis counted the silver coins in his pouch.
He exhaled, but it was not enough.

Six more…and no one would drag him back by the collar tonight.

A young cambion with four horns walked down a stone road. Gray-black buildings passed as his lean figure moved forward.

CLANK.

Coins clanked as Aegis tossed the pouch into the air. It was small — too small to matter to anyone but him. The pouch landed neatly in his palm as he whistled.

He just hoped not to lose the wager today.

The ground trembled.
A roar rolled through the street like distant thunder.

Dragon’s Fall — one of the only places where his pouch could get heavier.
He quickened his pace; the duel would begin soon.

SPLAT

He could feel something soft under his tattered leather boots. He lifted his boot to see what it was—

"Great! A Klucking hound decided to grace me with its filth." He threw his arms up in irritation, wiping his boot against the stone and made his way to the arena.



Soon, before him, metal stairs rose, stretching upward toward the arena gate where a colossal skull guarded the entrance, its jaw forever screaming. Its hollow eyes pierced the crowd.

He always wondered what the skull had looked like alive.

Many fiends moved past him, climbing the stairs. Aegis joined them.

Step after step carried him higher, to the entrance. The metallic smell of the sweat hit him; Dragon’s fall welcomed him.

Inside the arena hall, on his right stood the blood wager pit. Claws slammed counters as a few fiends argued.

Aegis didn’t delay; his feet carried him toward it. The board on top of the counters read, “Norkhon challenges Zigor.”

He made his decision and turned toward an empty counter. “Ninety-four silver on Zigor.”
A familiar slender fiend nodded and entered his name.

Am I forgetting something? Suddenly, the whole arena vibrated, interrupting his thoughts.

He shrugged it off and walked toward the spectators’ attic. Cambions and poor fiends surrounded him as he looked for a spot.

This spot looks good.
He approached a spot beside an obsidian pillar.

Aegis grimaced as the stench of sweat invaded his nostrils. An old fiend beside him had waved his arms, shouting at the fighters.

An involuntary gag followed. The fiend’s eyes turned toward him. With haste, he covered his mouth and ignored the smell.

Soon, the champions’ names resounded, and the spectators beside him roared.

Two fiends stood on the sand. The sound of steel rang across the arena as they began the duel. Growls rose behind him. Claws scraped railings. Someone shoved his shoulder. Blood sprayed into the air as the steel met flesh.

A wide smile spread across Aegis’s face, exposing two fangs.
“Yes, kill him!” he muttered as he felt his pouch getting heavier with each blow. He could feel it getting closer as the fiend he wagered on rained slashes. Six more silver!
Does this have its own style? Or is it still reading like a draft version? I would really appreciate it if you could just take a look.
 
Top