[Poll] Regression or Transmigration

Would you prefer to be regressed or transmigrated


  • Total voters
    44
  • Poll closed .

AnonUnlimited

????????? (???/???)
Joined
Apr 18, 2022
Messages
4,570
Points
183
Since these seem to be very popular right now in manwha, would you prefer to be reborn with all current memories and knowledge of the future, or be transmigrated as a baby into another world but be a sort of “chosen one”?
 

Rhaps

Evil to the very Core
Joined
May 5, 2022
Messages
1,553
Points
153
I don't want to repeat my whole life, it would be so boring. The unhinged goblin inside me demands chaos, so as the Choosen One I will bring the people to "salvation", my kind of salvation, one of anarchy.
 

Vnator

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 23, 2021
Messages
533
Points
133
What do each of these mean again? All I know are being portaled over (so you as you are right now) and reincarnation with memories intact (restart, new body, but a head start with modern day earth knowledge and keeping your attitude)
 

ElijahRyne

A Hermit that’s NOT that Lazy, currentlycomplainen
Joined
Aug 12, 2021
Messages
1,814
Points
153
Since these seem to be very popular right now in manwha, would you prefer to be reborn with all current memories and knowledge of the future, or be transmigrated as a baby into another world but be a sort of “chosen one”?
Regression, I would choose transmigration if I didn’t have to be a chosen one though.
 
Last edited:

Le_ther

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 21, 2022
Messages
302
Points
103
Regression would be boring due to the fact you already know anything but at the same time makes you invulnerable by using the future you achieve wisely

Transmigration is risky because of the udnerlying fact that the world you choose affects how you would turn out to be. Grim dark fantasy? Hah, good luck surviving. Sci-Fi dystopian nightmare? Even death is much simplier. A wholesome romance world? Fuck yeah!
 

Theirl

...---...
Joined
May 14, 2021
Messages
415
Points
133
Since these seem to be very popular right now in manwha, would you prefer to be reborn with all current memories and knowledge of the future, or be transmigrated as a baby into another world but be a sort of “chosen one”?
Do i need to be the chosen one? Cant i shill in a small village as i keep carving automatic longbows
 

AnonUnlimited

????????? (???/???)
Joined
Apr 18, 2022
Messages
4,570
Points
183
Clarification

Chosen one means you have the potential to be one of the strongest or the strongest with hard work. Not as in “you must save the world” type of thing.

Regression means you get photographic memory and knowledge of your past life.
 

RootBeerBert

Was definitely popular growing up
Joined
Jan 23, 2021
Messages
160
Points
83
Regression. While becoming the strongest and starting over is cool, I’m still mostly attached to my family and wouldn’t want to leave yet. Plus depending on the world I might never get to read web novels and manga again.
 

sanitylimited

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 23, 2023
Messages
255
Points
58
regression is like chess, but your only one piece thinking you control the whole board. hearing about how the plot should be, and then an explination on why you cant change it sucks.

transmigration protagonists dont have the obligation to care about the previous plot lines. they can flip the board and start playing checkers or tic tac toe
 

TheEldritchGod

A Cloud Of Pure Spite And Eyes
Joined
Dec 15, 2021
Messages
3,444
Points
183
It's reincarnation (born as a baby in another world), Transmigration (either recalling your past life in a new body, or your soul being stuck in a new, usually just died, body), or regression (Going back in time to relive you CURRENT life)

And BTW, Most TRUE transmigrations would be your soul getting stuck in a freshly killed body. Recalling your past life in a new body is technically Past Life Regression, since you are remembering your current life with your past life overwhelming the current personality. But since regression has be used to mean "rewound time", it doesn't really apply, and thus has become a subset of transmigration, since in effect, it is the same thing.

Your poll should be Reincarnation or Transmigration.
NOT Regression or Transmigration.

Your poll is wrong, or your Original Post is wrong.
Return to Monke would be the ultimate regression Manhua.
 

TheEldritchGod

A Cloud Of Pure Spite And Eyes
Joined
Dec 15, 2021
Messages
3,444
Points
183
Let me spell it out, BTW in more detail:

Reincarnation: Your soul upon your death goes to find a new body, usually a baby. You sometimes remember your past life. Sometimes everyone does this. Sometimes you are special. Sometimes you remember ALL your past lives, sometimes you just remember one. Whatever the case, usually, everyone does it, you're just the only one to remember, usually because someone, somewhere screwed up.

Maybe you weren't supposed to die and god felt bad. Maybe you were supposed to die, but you were so nice you deserve a few perks and beanies in the next life. Who knows? The Author Knows. Expect it to be set up and never mentioned again in the first chapter, because it doesn't matter. We got a fish out of water story to tell!

Transmigration: Your soul is put into a new body. This CAN include a baby's body, but usually is a body much more mature. The implications are, you are not supposed to be there. The previous occupant was booted and you took over. Sometimes the invader gets "left over memories" from the previous occupant, but the personality and 'free will' of the original is absent. Usually you get nothing from the previous owner, but you have the perk of, "I REMEMBER THIS BOOK" and so the MC can at least GUESS what the previous occupant should know.

Past Life Intruding On Present Time: This is a strange one because it can be either of the previous, in its own way.

A) PLIOPT (Reincarnation): You are Usually you are "reincarnated" You live your life, then you "remember" stuff from your previous life. This usually has some sort of trigger event, like a bump on the head, or whatnot. In this version, usually, the past life is the passive personality and only serves to grant the new "life" information. Like "I read a book in a previous life so I know the plot of this world OMG I'm in an OTOME GAME."

B) PLIOPT (Transmigration): In this version, you are put into a new body and you MERGE with the current occupant to become a gestalt personality. Technically this is a transmigration, but more of an invasion. Usually in this method, the original personality becomes overwhelmed by the invading personality and takes over completely.

C) PLIOPT (Aggressive Reincarnation): Same as the reincarnation above, but the current personality is usually suicidal and wants to die, so they are trying to Nope out of existing, so the previous 'past life' takes over completely. This usually only happens in cases where the current personality wants to die, tried to kill themselves, or succeeded in killing themselves.

Regression: This means that you traveled back in time and remember everything that happened, usually when you die. There are many flavors

Second Chance Regression: Usually someone, a villainess or someone who really screwed up feels REALLY BAD and for some reason they get a second chance. Often not explained in the story, usually GOD or someone goes, 'Yeah, you were a DICK, but I know you are a good guy under it all. What the fuck, he's a second shot at it.' I have no idea WHY god would give a monster a second chance, but hey, we all love a redemption story, so what the fuck. Usually you only get one second chance.

History Erasure Button Regression: Usually the MC dies in a horrible way that was wrong and unjust. Someone else figures it out afterwards and feels horrible. Dad, Emperor, Husband, Crown Prince, some dude, usually. The MC is usual female and was just a saint or sucker, or just misunderstood and her death was tragic. So the History Erasure Button is hit, whatever it is, time ie rewound, but for some reason, only the MC knows that time was rewound. The person hitting the button (or magically maguffin) never seems to remember anything. or maybe they feel really guilty and don't know why.

Ground Hog Day Regression: The MC fucks up and dies. Time is reset. It keeps getting reset until the MC figures out how to get it right. This might be magic, this might be a transmigration, this might even be because he's in a video game and keeps going back to the save point. Usually it goes back YEARS, but months or even days is possible, but usually you get a couple of years to fix things.

Revenge Regression: A rare type. The MC figures out how to regress time out of REVENGE. Very popular among Chinese stories, especially involving Zombie outbreaks. The world goes to shit, but the MC figures out how to advance his chi by taking magic pills and sitting under a waterfall, thus reverting time back to before the zombie outbreak. They stock up on toilet paper, guns, and condoms because they gonna fuck all those bitches who pissed him off. Although if it's Japanese version, expect it to be some guy treated like shit by his adventuring party, and he's gonna make them die in the most graphic of torture porn you can imagine.

Time Power Regression: This version, the power is baked into the story. The MC's power is reset time. Maybe a day, an hour, a week, a save point. Unlike ground hog day regression, the MC is in control of the regression, so he's basically god and cannot lose because, if he loses, boop, reset the day.

ITS A SIMULATION: This is a new one popping up lately. The MC is a simulation of a Normal guy who happens to find himself stuck in an android body, or a Space Ship computer, or whatnot. Basically, any of the above, except that it's not magic, it's SCIENCE(tm) We MEAN IT. No No No. No magic here. Just Microchips and AI making a fake japanese 12 year old kid who was bullied in school just like the target demographic because REASONS. It's all very science-ish. We promise.
 
Last edited:
Top