Offering feedback on your first chapter

Joined
Feb 19, 2026
Messages
49
Points
18
Hey folks.
I'm trying to find good stuff to read on here while also Engaging With The Community. I like horror, low fantasy, mystery, gothic, and historical stuff (my main era is Victorian England). Here for anything close to Stephen King, Shirley Jackson, or T. Kingfisher. Not here for isekai or overpowered protagonists or self insert fics. Drop your links below.

EDITED TO ADD: If you used AI to write your story, I'm not going to waste my time giving feedback on it. There's no excuse for using generative AI.

EDITED AGAIN TO ADD: no translations.
Want to clarify before I share my story:

Every chapter is 100% author written, but my work contains a couple optional/skippable worldbuilding addendums with additional context for neurodivergents like me, and one contains a fictional piece of legislation that is author created, and formatted to look like a real bill with AI assistance (I disclaim it in the addendum).

Disqualifying?

Not a part of the first chapter, but I respect your principles and if that is disqualifying I will quietly depart without being sourdough.
 

Peagreene

Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2026
Messages
48
Points
18
Want to clarify before I share my story:

Every chapter is 100% author written, but my work contains a couple optional/skippable worldbuilding addendums with additional context for neurodivergents like me, and one contains a fictional piece of legislation that is author created, and formatted to look like a real bill with AI assistance (I disclaim it in the addendum).

Disqualifying?

Not a part of the first chapter, but I respect your principles and if that is disqualifying I will quietly depart without being sourdough.
Ah, go on then, for a fellow neurodivergent.
 

Daeron

Kin-Slayer
Joined
Jan 22, 2026
Messages
95
Points
18
Hey folks.
I'm trying to find good stuff to read on here while also Engaging With The Community. I like horror, low fantasy, mystery, gothic, and historical stuff (my main era is Victorian England). Here for anything close to Stephen King, Shirley Jackson, or T. Kingfisher. Not here for isekai or overpowered protagonists or self insert fics. Drop your links below.

EDITED TO ADD: If you used AI to write your story, I'm not going to waste my time giving feedback on it. There's no excuse for using generative AI.

EDITED AGAIN TO ADD: no translations.
Oof, 'close to' Stephen King. That's very high standard dude :sweat_smile::sweat_smile::sweat_smile:
 

Dawnathon

Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2025
Messages
41
Points
18
I like horror, low fantasy, mystery, gothic, and historical stuff (my main era is Victorian England).
Sure, go ahead.

VoraCity

It's a writing experiment more than anything else. Content aside, the first chunk of the story goes on for a long time in this weirder subject matter before becoming a very different kind of story. It gatekeeps the people who would like the later character-driven focused story, while the people who do like the more abstract writing will feel disappointed when that changes. I think that alone makes it a more problematic prologue than any content does.

Still, while not quite the Victorian era, it is early industrial era fantasy not-London.
 

Peagreene

Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2026
Messages
48
Points
18
Indeed! You have great taste!
Also I guess I'm not looking for King in terms of quality (though obvs that would be fantastic) but more in terms of content. The way he blends supernatural with the mundane is 100% my jam.
 

LouuwBarnsThor

New member
Joined
Feb 7, 2026
Messages
1
Points
1
Oh guys, nice see an good and old forum here, I totally missed, can yo guys give me feedback on my "initial" work:

I have started another one before, but the plot was too complex for an starter, so I choose to put on hold and started to work on this simple story. An wife becaming an sex slave. I'm doing everthing in her point of view, thinking in future add some master point of view, for epilogues/interludios.

It has 2 chapters + prologue published up to now.
 

Peagreene

Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2026
Messages
48
Points
18
Oh guys, nice see an good and old forum here, I totally missed, can yo guys give me feedback on my "initial" work:

I have started another one before, but the plot was too complex for an starter, so I choose to put on hold and started to work on this simple story. An wife becaming an sex slave. I'm doing everthing in her point of view, thinking in future add some master point of view, for epilogues/interludios.

It has 2 chapters + prologue published up to now.
Not my vibe at all, sorry.
 

Toshiyuki

New member
Joined
Feb 10, 2026
Messages
7
Points
3
I know that my book is isekai but its as anti-isekai slop as I can make it lol. No op protag, no self inserts, no game systems, real world is super relevant and half the plot has supernatural/spiritual themes (soul abilities, dead spirits possessing objects, etc). The basic idea is that it follows a depressed former child actor that is pulled between a storybook fantasy world and the real world every time he sleeps, and must survive both worlds as they become more and more connected. Totally cool if this isn't your vibe, but I'll leave it here incase your interested

Book link: https://www.scribblehub.com/series/2178986/pharmakon-when-i-dream-i-wake-up-in-another-world/
 

Peagreene

Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2026
Messages
48
Points
18
Read whichever you like:




☮️
"The Gods Are So Unforgiving."
Who's saying this?

Rain poured down as lightning flashed across the ever-changing sky. Zara locked hands with her beloved as they ran through the palace. Screams of war sounded as they evaded the green flames. With a snap of her fingers she summoned a nimbus cloud and pulled Calliope into her arms as they zipped along the skies.
A lot going on here. Why are the names bolded? What's an ever-changing sky? What are the green flames? Where are they - first off they're running through the palace and then all of a sudden they're in the skies. This is a very surface-level way of setting the scene.

The lightning seemed to have a mind of its own as it curved towards them, Zara quickly dodged the sky god's assault as they dive-bombed.
Comma splice. Also this is contradictory - "seemed to have a mind of its own" implies this is just regular lightning that shouldn't be acting like this, but it being an assault from a god contradicts that. "Dive-bombed" implies there's a target they're aiming for.

It was a short distance as their cloud grazed the outside of the tornado before they fell.
I can't picture the logistics of what's happening here.

"Zara, this is a dangerous ordeal!" Calliope warned as she nuzzled her neck.
This absolutely does not seem like something someone running for their life would say/do. Also aren't they falling at this point? How can she be nuzzling someone's neck?

"What Zeus asked of me is extremely unjust," Zara explained. "Were doomed if we stay!"
They didn't sort this out before they fled? What's happening here? Did they start the war? Did they burn the palace? The opening makes it seem like they're fleeing war, but this dialogue implies otherwise. Should also be "we're" not "were".

Unfortunately, someone was waiting for them and that someone was Ares the God of war as he showed off one of his massive blades.
He was waiting for them where? Where are they going? Where's all this happening?

She pulled her arrow as Calliope wrapped her arms around her.
This pronoun use implies the she is Ares, not Zara. Also it's got to be difficult to draw an arrow with someone clinging to you.

Hiding in plain sight amongst the mortals seems like an easy task.
Does it?


Slow down and spend more time in the scene. I looked at the next chapter and was pleased to see aroace rep. (y)
 

Cookiez_N_Potionz

Rank: Moon Leo
Joined
Sep 27, 2024
Messages
402
Points
78
Who's saying this?


A lot going on here. Why are the names bolded? What's an ever-changing sky? What are the green flames? Where are they - first off they're running through the palace and then all of a sudden they're in the skies. This is a very surface-level way of setting the scene.


Comma splice. Also this is contradictory - "seemed to have a mind of its own" implies this is just regular lightning that shouldn't be acting like this, but it being an assault from a god contradicts that. "Dive-bombed" implies there's a target they're aiming for.


I can't picture the logistics of what's happening here.


This absolutely does not seem like something someone running for their life would say/do. Also aren't they falling at this point? How can she be nuzzling someone's neck?


They didn't sort this out before they fled? What's happening here? Did they start the war? Did they burn the palace? The opening makes it seem like they're fleeing war, but this dialogue implies otherwise. Should also be "we're" not "were".


He was waiting for them where? Where are they going? Where's all this happening?


This pronoun use implies the she is Ares, not Zara. Also it's got to be difficult to draw an arrow with someone clinging to you.


Does it?


Slow down and spend more time in the scene. I looked at the next chapter and was pleased to see aroace rep. (y)

Thank you for your time and advice! ❤️
 

Peagreene

Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2026
Messages
48
Points
18
I know you said no Isekais, but what about a dark one where the girl gets pulled into the real world? Urban setting, dark, mystery.

I constantly felt trapped in the body of a woman.
Hell yeah, trans icon.

but he was eventually taken captive and tied up. The four assassins began talking about their orders.
Dumbass assassins? Four of them and not one thinks to just run the prince through right there and then? If assassination is the goal, why bother tying him up? Just cut his throat there and then.

When I came back to consciousness
I'm pretty sure if you suffer head trauma so severe you lose consciousness, that's a potential concussion, and it doesn't matter how cool you are, you're not going to bounce back from that.

I couldn't believe my father was sending me far away.
Why not? This seems on brand, considering his earlier douchey behaviour.


There are quite a few instances here where it feels like a thing is written, not because it's realistic or what did happen/would have happened, but because it feels cool or like the kind of thing that happens in a story like this.

EDITED TO ADD: I read the rest of your chapters and they're a fun read! I would prefer a more immersive style of telling the story, showing the scenes and going at a slower, more evocative pace, rather than the distant narrative style you have at the moment, but honestly it's a fun story.
 
Last edited:
Top