New bl romance :3

soupsabaw

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 21, 2024
Messages
119
Points
58
Thank youuu for the replies on my question about chapters. I've split them up, and I feel a lot better!! It really did help.

If anyone is interested in a romance marriage of convivence bl... check out Be My Travel Husband, where the mc gets to experience doing travel work but in return, he has to pretend to be the ml's husband. Filled with lots of flirting and bickering moments between the two, and slowly, over time, the line between acting and not acting is unable to be deciphered.
 

Yuin

I’m out
Joined
Jul 24, 2024
Messages
118
Points
58
Thank youuu for the replies on my question about chapters. I've split them up, and I feel a lot better!! It really did help.

If anyone is interested in a romance marriage of convivence bl... check out Be My Travel Husband, where the mc gets to experience doing travel work but in return, he has to pretend to be the ml's husband. Filled with lots of flirting and bickering moments between the two, and slowly, over time, the line between acting and not acting is unable to be deciphered.
Hi I just read your story and here are my thoughts

- I could visualise the story and its setting. The dialogues between Sage and the nurse is very natural and I like that.
- It is very straightforward and easy to read and I also like the style of writing.
- However, there are some things I wanna address here:
- Although the premise of the plot is promising, the language disrupts my reading experience. It’s not bad but I know you can do so much better.:blob_reach:
- [elder woman's arm] change to elderly woman’s arm
- [few minutes more] change to few minutes late
- [His assistant nurse] Don’t capitalise the pronounce ‘his’
- [The look on his face was always just. It was hard to tell if he liked his job or hated it.] incomplete sentence. You can rephrase it as ‘The look on his face was unreadable.’
- [But they think you're a wife.] Change it to ‘So they would think you’re the wife?”
- [No questions, no comments, no nothing] No nothing is just contradictory. Just write it as ‘No questions, no comments, nothing.’
- Okay there are some repeated element like how Sage is a doctor who is handsome and a gentleman. It has been established from the start so there is no need to repeat it in the same writing format. You can imply these through his actions and not directly tell the readers what type of person he is.
- [Rowan had a wider one. His shoulders were wider, his hips were wider, his chestwas wider;] This… pls don’t repeat this again. You can write it as “His shoulders were broad and strong like his hips, his chest was large and muscular (Idk what’s your vision of him this is just an example) that one hug could consume a person’s body. Although he was gentle in nature, his facial features were like carved by the hands of God, and his deep voice alongside his casual movements exude charm in his appearance.’
- [ An uncomfortable silence between them. Uncomfortable wasn't the right word. They weren't comfortable but they weren't uncomfortable. It was more awkward than anything.] I saw the word ‘uncomfortable’ repeated three times. You can rephrase it as ’The silence was deafening. He could feel the stiffness in the air as every sound was echoed in the elevator. Sage looked down and fidgeted, he felt uncomfortable due to the awkwardness but a thought occupied his mind.’
- Okay yea so the storyline is solid, I would 100% continue to read it as a BL reader but the lack of variety in the language made the description of the scenes kinda monotonous and lacklustre. You can use metaphors to write the scene and character, or through the actions to convey the atmosphere instead of using the sentences such as “He was..” “They weren’t…”
- Don’t always start the sentences with the pronouns and explore other ways to express the words in the story.
- Otherwise this is a plot I will fw:blob_melt:


OH wait this isn’t the feedback forum. My bad, I appreciate any BL work so pls take my words lightly. :blob_cookie:
 
Last edited:

soupsabaw

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 21, 2024
Messages
119
Points
58
No, no, I accept feedback!

Hi I just read your story and here are my thoughts

- I could visualise the story and its setting. The dialogues between Sage and the nurse is very natural and I like that.
- It is very straightforward and easy to read and I also like the style of writing.
These compliments are great tysmm!!

- Although the premise of the plot is promising, the language disrupts my reading experience. It’s not bad but I know you can do so much better.:blob_reach:
- [elder woman's arm] change to elderly woman’s arm
- [few minutes more] change to few minutes late
- [His assistant nurse] Don’t capitalise the pronounce ‘his’
- [The look on his face was always just. It was hard to tell if he liked his job or hated it.] incomplete sentence. You can rephrase it as ‘The look on his face was unreadable.’
- [But they think you're a wife.] Change it to ‘So they would think you’re the wife?”
Taken these into note though thank you! I won't be doing exactly what you said because it doesn't feel right to steal it, but I will go back and look over to make changes!

- [No questions, no comments, no nothing] No nothing is just contradictory. Just write it as ‘No questions, no comments, nothing.’
- Okay there are some repeated element like how Sage is a doctor who is handsome and a gentleman. It has been established from the start so there is no need to repeat it in the same writing format. You can imply these through his actions and not directly tell the readers what type of person he is.
- [Rowan had a wider one. His shoulders were wider, his hips were wider, his chestwas wider;] This… pls don’t repeat this again. You can write it as “His shoulders were broad and strong like his hips, his chest was large and muscular (Idk what’s your vision of him this is just an example) that one hug could consume a person’s body. Although he was gentle in nature, his facial features were like carved by the hands of God, and his deep voice alongside his casual movements exude charm in his appearance.’
- [ An uncomfortable silence between them. Uncomfortable wasn't the right word. They weren't comfortable but they weren't uncomfortable. It was more awkward than anything.] I saw the word ‘uncomfortable’ repeated three times. You can rephrase it as ’The silence was deafening. He could feel the stiffness in the air as every sound was echoed in the elevator. Sage looked down and fidgeted, he felt uncomfortable due to the awkwardness but a thought occupied his mind.’
Sometimes I go for the style of being purposely repetitive for a type of emphasis or dramatics, but I can see how in some cases it might be overwhelming and not necessary ? I should save something like that for deeply intense situations rather than when my mc feels a bit nervous. I don’t even think I really do that anywhere else but this first chapter, but I’ll keep lookout thank you ?

- Okay yea so the storyline is solid, I would 100% continue to read it as a BL reader but the lack of variety in the language made the description of the scenes kinda monotonous and lacklustre. You can use metaphors to write the scene and character, or through the actions to convey the atmosphere instead of using the sentences such as “He was..” “They weren’t…”
- Don’t always start the sentences with the pronouns and explore other ways to express the words in the story.
I write in third person limited and not a third person omnipresent, so I use the “he” over “they" because the story focus is mainly on Sage (sometimes it switches to Rowan but only like twice?)

OH wait this isn’t the feedback forum. My bad, I appreciate any BL work so pls take my words lightly. :blob_cookie:
No omg don't even worry about it. This was great. I've never actually had like a beta reader before for my work. I kind of just send it to my friends who aren't writers, so they never see anything wrong with these simple mistakes. This was really helpful! Everyone needs a little help when it comes to writing. Even professionals have betas, so this was really amazing omg

I’m not arguing at all. Just explaining why I do what I do, I swear. I really do appreciate the help!!! This was genuinely so awesome to wake up to seeing someone interested enough to drop something ?❤️

Edited this because I did it on my phone... computer replies are so much cleaner
 
Last edited:

Yuin

I’m out
Joined
Jul 24, 2024
Messages
118
Points
58
but I can see how in some cases it might be overwhelming and not necessary ? I should save something like that for deeply intense situations rather than when my mc feels a bit nervous.
Aww that’s okay. It’s your writing style so just adjust whatever fits best! I have my own preferences too.
it doesn't feel right to steal it,
Nah it’s fine because it‘s just minor corrections.
third person limited and not a third person omnipresent, so I use the “he” over “they" because the story focus is mainly on Sage
Oh I never thot of that, okay thanks for clarifying!
No omg don't even worry about it. This was great. I've never actually had like a beta reader before for my work. I kind of just send it to my friends who aren't writers, so they never see anything wrong with these simple mistakes. This was really helpful! Everyone needs a little help when it comes to writing. Even professionals have betas, so this was really amazing omg
Omg same, I asked my friends and they just agreed to the overall plot? Your story is fine in terms of pacing and dialogues so it is generally decent!
I’m not arguing at all. Just explaining why I do what I do, I swear. I really do appreciate the help!!! This was genuinely so awesome to wake up to seeing someone interested enough to drop something ?❤️
Really? I hope it makes your day! Feel free to ask again if you have published enough chapters ?
 
Last edited:

soupsabaw

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 21, 2024
Messages
119
Points
58
Aww that’s okay. It’s your writing style so just adjust whatever fits best! I have my own preferences too.

Nah it’s fine because it just minor corrections.
Oh I never thot of that, okay thanks for clarifying!
Omg same, I asked my friends and they just agreed to the overall plot? Your story is fine in terms of pacing and dialogues so it is generally decent!

Really? I hope it makes your day! Feel free to ask again if you have published enough chapters ?
It really did make my day :blob_melt: I've got a deep love for these ocs so thank youuu ❤️
 
Top