Need a feedback as new writer

ThirstyWater

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2026
Messages
24
Points
3
As a new writer and non-English speaker, I’d love to know how my story is going and how I can improve it
 

Bayleyrockstar

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 11, 2020
Messages
30
Points
58
As a new writer and non-English speaker, I’d love to know how my story is going and how I can improve it
Well, first, let's point out things you did do right. Your cover art is good, and you have a lot of tags, which means your story is findable, that's good.

The bad things? Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm guessing you're using machine translation and copy and pasting. Because it shows in how your story flows.
Your story sounds like it's good, like it's interesting. A Clown system in horror? Cliche, but a classic. Sign me up.

The issue comes with actually reading your story. You've written down one sentence per line. An issue in writing in english is that this easily causes disjointed thoughts. And this is probably what's bringing your viewership down.

There'll probably be someone soon who can bear with your writing style and talk about the plot. But right now, I have trouble even reading the story. The little I could get through without succumbing to my ADHD was interesting at the least, just some notes since Jack is supposed to be american.

One, apologizing like the doctor did isn't an American thing. So it'd be really weird to see in America. Instead, the doctor would hand the envelope over while talking around the issue, but to apologize would imply fault, and thus open the doctor, (or in this case the nephew) to be sued. An alternative is to have the doctor 'settle'. This basically means Jack would sign an agreement that he gets money, and he can't sue for damages because he's already gotten compensated. Basically, Jack would find the doctor's attitude weird for America.

The second is also related to the doctor. In America, hospitals aren't run by the doctors. Instead, doctors are just another worker there. It's incredibly difficult to get a patient in if they don't sign in first, unless you go to the ER. (emergency room) Where serious trauma is taken care of, and is open 24/7. In fact, no worker at a hospital would have enough clout to cancel their appointments to see the patient like in your story, unless it was a very rural clinic that was privately owned.

So waking up in a hospital, having a doctor handwave the fee would cause instant disbelief, because doctors make a lot, but not that much. American healthcare is expensive, and most of it is paid by, also expensive, insurance. And in this case, Jack would expect to be paid by the nephew's Insurance company.

Being hospitalized in America sucks, and generally means you'll be in debt.
 

ThirstyWater

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2026
Messages
24
Points
3
Well, first, let's point out things you did do right. Your cover art is good, and you have a lot of tags, which means your story is findable, that's good.

The bad things? Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm guessing you're using machine translation and copy and pasting. Because it shows in how your story flows.
Your story sounds like it's good, like it's interesting. A Clown system in horror? Cliche, but a classic. Sign me up.

The issue comes with actually reading your story. You've written down one sentence per line. An issue in writing in english is that this easily causes disjointed thoughts. And this is probably what's bringing your viewership down.

There'll probably be someone soon who can bear with your writing style and talk about the plot. But right now, I have trouble even reading the story. The little I could get through without succumbing to my ADHD was interesting at the least, just some notes since Jack is supposed to be american.

One, apologizing like the doctor did isn't an American thing. So it'd be really weird to see in America. Instead, the doctor would hand the envelope over while talking around the issue, but to apologize would imply fault, and thus open the doctor, (or in this case the nephew) to be sued. An alternative is to have the doctor 'settle'. This basically means Jack would sign an agreement that he gets money, and he can't sue for damages because he's already gotten compensated. Basically, Jack would find the doctor's attitude weird for America.

The second is also related to the doctor. In America, hospitals aren't run by the doctors. Instead, doctors are just another worker there. It's incredibly difficult to get a patient in if they don't sign in first, unless you go to the ER. (emergency room) Where serious trauma is taken care of, and is open 24/7. In fact, no worker at a hospital would have enough clout to cancel their appointments to see the patient like in your story, unless it was a very rural clinic that was privately owned.

So waking up in a hospital, having a doctor handwave the fee would cause instant disbelief, because doctors make a lot, but not that much. American healthcare is expensive, and most of it is paid by, also expensive, insurance. And in this case, Jack would expect to be paid by the nephew's Insurance company.

Being hospitalized in America sucks, and generally means you'll be in debt.
Thank you for the detailed feedback, I really appreciate it.
And yes, I do use GPT to help translate and polish my English. My story basically AI assisted story, I’m also trying to learn how to write in a way that feels natural and readable for native English speakers. If you have any advice about tools, resources, or anything I could study to improve my writing, I would really appreciate it.
I understand your point about sentence structure and readability. I tend to use short lines to emphasize tension, but I agree that overusing them can disrupt the flow. I will try to balance it better in future chapters.
Regarding the cultural details, thank you for pointing that out. As a non-native writer, this is very helpful for improving realism.
I’m glad the concept itself still feels interesting.
Thanks again for taking the time to read and comment.
 

L_Foxfire

New member
Joined
Mar 26, 2026
Messages
11
Points
3
Review Swap Request

Hi there! I'd love to do a swap with you if you're open to reading a completed short story.

I have a completed short horror/thriller story (12 chapters / ~25k words). It's a blend of SCP-style clinical dread and cosmic body horror.

Here is the link: [https://www.scribblehub.com/series/2257911/containment-object-the-gallery-of-flesh/]

If you're interested in swapping for 12 chapters, let me know! I can start reading your work today and leave a detailed, honest review.

Let me know if we have a deal!

Best,
L. Foxfire
 

ThirstyWater

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2026
Messages
24
Points
3
Review Swap Request

Hi there! I'd love to do a swap with you if you're open to reading a completed short story.

I have a completed short horror/thriller story (12 chapters / ~25k words). It's a blend of SCP-style clinical dread and cosmic body horror.

Here is the link: [https://www.scribblehub.com/series/2257911/containment-object-the-gallery-of-flesh/]

If you're interested in swapping for 12 chapters, let me know! I can start reading your work today and leave a detailed, honest review.

Let me know if we have a deal!

Best,
L. Foxfire
Sure! I’m a bit busy on my side right now, so I’ll likely be able to start reading your story this Sunday, if that works for you.
 

L_Foxfire

New member
Joined
Mar 26, 2026
Messages
11
Points
3
Sure! I’m a bit busy on my side right now, so I’ll likely be able to start reading your story this Sunday, if that works for you.
Thank you so much for getting back to me and for your support. Please take your time—this isn’t urgent at all. Whenever it’s convenient for you, would you be able to share a link to your novel? I’ll be sure to read it and leave my honest feedback.

Wishing you a wonderful weekend!
 

ThirstyWater

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2026
Messages
24
Points
3
Terima kasih banyak telah membalas pesan saya dan atas dukungan Anda. Silakan luangkan waktu Anda—ini sama sekali tidak mendesak. Kapan pun Anda punya waktu luang, bisakah Anda membagikan tautan ke novel Anda? Saya pasti akan membacanya dan memberikan umpan balik yang jujur.

Semoga akhir pekanmu menyenangkan!
Here:


And if you're enjoying the story, feel free to check it out on RR. I've posted more chapters over there!
 

ThirstyWater

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2026
Messages
24
Points
3
Thank you so much for getting back to me and for your support. Please take your time—this isn’t urgent at all. Whenever it’s convenient for you, would you be able to share a link to your novel? I’ll be sure to read it and leave my honest feedback.

Wishing you a wonderful weekend!
Hi, since I finished my work earlier than expected, I’ve already read your story and left a review. The story is very interesting, and the body horror elements are especially well done. It even gave me some ideas for my own story, so thank you.
 

Makimaam

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 17, 2025
Messages
239
Points
93
Then he heard something.

A faint sound from the alley.

He froze.

“What was that?”

A long pause followed.

“Probably nothing…”

His voice trembled.

He continued walking.

The sound came again.

Closer.

Curiosity slowly overpowered fear.

The young man froze.

His brain screamed one word.

Ghost.

Run.


Instead—

he charged forward.

“GHOST!!”
If you think this is how English writers write their books, the first step is to pick up a book written by a human, not an overloaded machine spitting gibberish, and read it to understand how people actually write a novel.
 

ThirstyWater

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2026
Messages
24
Points
3
If you think this is how English writers write their books, the first step is to pick up a book written by a human, not an overloaded machine spitting gibberish, and read it to understand how people actually write a novel.
Thank you for the feedback.
My writing style intentionally uses short, fragmented sentences as part of the atmosphere I’m trying to create. I was partly inspired by the rhythm found in Chuck Palahniuk’s Fight Club, where repetition and sentence fragmentation are used to build psychological tension.
That said, I understand that this style may not work for every reader, and I will continue refining the balance so that it remains readable while still preserving the intended mood.
Regarding AI, I only use tools to help polish grammar since English is not my native language. The ideas, structure, and wording choices are my own. I also forgot to include the AI-assisted in my description, and I will correct that.
I appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts.
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,977
Points
113
Thank you for the feedback.
My writing style intentionally uses short, fragmented sentences as part of the atmosphere I’m trying to create. I was partly inspired by the rhythm found in Chuck Palahniuk’s Fight Club, where repetition and sentence fragmentation are used to build psychological tension.
That said, I understand that this style may not work for every reader, and I will continue refining the balance so that it remains readable while still preserving the intended mood.
Regarding AI, I only use tools to help polish grammar since English is not my native language. The ideas, structure, and wording choices are my own. I also forgot to include the AI-assisted in my description, and I will correct that.
I appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts.
I'm not going to criticize you for using AI or writing with a pencil or anything. But consider the reading experience.

Saying 'this is my writing style' is the easiest way to shut yourself off from improvement and alienate a segment of potential readers (well, if you don't want criticism, this feedback thread shouldn't be relevant in the first place).

If you want to maintain your style, consider combining those short, fragmented sentences into larger, readable paragraphs (2-3 compound sentences per paragraph). You might not know... most readers are actually annoyed by 1 short sentence = 1 paragraph.
 

ThirstyWater

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2026
Messages
24
Points
3
Thank you for the feedback. I understand that this writing style may not appeal to every reader, and I truly appreciate you pointing out the readability aspect.

I created this thread specifically to receive criticism and improve the story, so feedback like this is very helpful. After receiving earlier feedback from Bayleyrockstar and Makimaam, I’ve already started revising some parts to better balance the fragmented sentences with more conventional paragraphs.

That said, the fragmented style is still an intentional part of the atmosphere I’m trying to create, so while I will continue refining the balance, I probably won’t remove it entirely. My goal is to keep the staccato feel while making the reading experience smoother.
Thank you again for taking the time to share your thoughts.
 

YukieSama

Member
Joined
Mar 26, 2026
Messages
37
Points
18
Thank you for the feedback. I understand that this writing style may not appeal to every reader, and I truly appreciate you pointing out the readability aspect.

I created this thread specifically to receive criticism and improve the story, so feedback like this is very helpful. After receiving earlier feedback from Bayleyrockstar and Makimaam, I’ve already started revising some parts to better balance the fragmented sentences with more conventional paragraphs.

That said, the fragmented style is still an intentional part of the atmosphere I’m trying to create, so while I will continue refining the balance, I probably won’t remove it entirely. My goal is to keep the staccato feel while making the reading experience smoother.
Thank you again for taking the time to share your thoughts.
By adding in longer and more varied sentences you improve the staccato feel when you do use it. It's the same for the overuse of any technique.
 

ThirstyWater

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2026
Messages
24
Points
3
By adding in longer and more varied sentences you improve the staccato feel when you do use it. It's the same for the overuse of any technique.
Thanks for the feedback. I’ve revised some of the earlier chapters to improve the reading flow. I’d appreciate it if you could let me know whether the fragmented style still feels overused.
 

L_Foxfire

New member
Joined
Mar 26, 2026
Messages
11
Points
3
Hi, since I finished my work earlier than expected, I’ve already read your story and left a review. The story is very interesting, and the body horror elements are especially well done. It even gave me some ideas for my own story, so thank you.
I have taken the time to read your novel, and I have to say, it is incredibly interesting! I went ahead and left a genuine review on your page.

Keep up the great work! I am really looking forward to reading more exciting content from your story in the future.
 

ThirstyWater

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2026
Messages
24
Points
3
I have taken the time to read your novel, and I have to say, it is incredibly interesting! I went ahead and left a genuine review on your page.

Keep up the great work! I am really looking forward to reading more exciting content from your story in the future.
Thank you, I’m really glad you enjoyed the story. I truly appreciate the review — it helps a lot.
I wish you the best with your writing as well, and I look forward to reading more of your future stories.
 

TheKillingAlice

Schinken
Joined
Aug 12, 2023
Messages
672
Points
133
If you think this is how English writers write their books, the first step is to pick up a book written by a human, not an overloaded machine spitting gibberish, and read it to understand how people actually write a novel.
That text looks like someone had a stroke while typing and kept falling onto the enter key with every third word. Amazing. :blob_cookie:
 
Top