My probably stupid Magic system

PeacefulMyst

In your heart~
Joined
Dec 23, 2021
Messages
672
Points
133
A rookie author here. Basically just starting off my writing journey so I decided to create a magic system I've constructed with my terrible imagination for my first ln. Soooo... Can someone please tell me if it is good or just stupid? (or just too generic)



Aight so for the basics, Mana is everywhere around the air. The people are born with the ability to manipulate the mana around them using the help of these invisible spirits. The spirit of each person is decided as soon as they're born. And the way they use this is they must have enough 'concentration' Ie: To focus their mind on the spell casting and forget about the rest. Oh, the spirits rarely make an appearance as they need to stay hidden. And they don't have that much intelligence in the first place.



And now, the elemental shit.



So, each person is born with their own spirit. And these spirits each are made up of certain basic elements. Air. Water. Fire. nature. And sky (the divine power in my ln) And, the more you use your abilities, the better you get at them. After they've reached a certain level, their elements mutate to better suit the user. (however, these diff forms will still be similar to the main one.) Oh and you cannot use more than one element at a time. No exceptions. (Other than the gods themselves) As for the ‘sky’ element. It basically is borrowing power from the sky. Like causing rain, thunderstrikes, And stuff like that. (No. No healing magic. That's part of the element less and requires the caster to know medical science of the world.) Oh, and just like the sky.

As per as how magic is cast, for a certain amount of time, it's with the help of runes. Runes are basically mana manipulation made more simple after years of research. So it doesn't take as much brainpower to do simple tasks by making it not as free. However, the con to that is the spells are not freely manipulatable.

And as for brain power, it’s related to how much you can handle mana manipulation without completely breaking down. The way the ‘brain power’ gets stronger is with repeated casting.

Now, as for applying the runes to weapons. Well, it is easy to do it, but hard to maintain them during a battle. And runes that don't require the caster to constantly keep moving the mana around them into it are quite advanced and hard-to-do spells. So mostly stuff like using swords, spears etc isn't particularly a fav of newcomers.

Now, even after all this, I haven't explained how moving mana works.

Basically, it's just felling the mana around you and ‘commanding’ it to move into your spells. That alone requires a lot of imagination by the caster and puts a strain on the mind.

Why do I have a feeling this is somehow similar to Benders. Like airbenders etc. I haven't even watched that show

please excuse the grammar mistakes thank you.
 

RavenRunes

Filth Wizard
Joined
Mar 23, 2022
Messages
790
Points
133
Using something similar myself, except the runes are finite and require life force. They're mostly just a 'focus', there's no actual power in them. I think as long as a system has some limitations or flaws, and makes sense, it's fine. You'll probably find that most things you can come up with are similar to what's already been done, but who cares, put your own little spin on it and crack on!
 

Kilolo

I'm so kewl
Joined
Jul 1, 2019
Messages
419
Points
103
i think this is nice. and i don't see it as similar to the avatar as well.

i mean, you said "each person is born with their own spirit", and what happened to the spirit once the person died? Does the spirit dies as well? Most likely not. which could diverged into many possible interesting plot.


it just 2 point that i think you need to figure out next.
1. what about the existence about magical tools or such? doing it your way eliminate the possibility about the existence about magic stone.
2. the story needs villains, does those villain using the exact same system as well? are they human? what are those villain do with these magic system and making them the villains. (i mean you can't say your character is able to shot a fireball without anything that could justify them to shot it at something. you at least need an enraged beast for that)
 

BearlyAlive

I'm not savage, you're just average
Joined
Oct 13, 2021
Messages
1,969
Points
153
That reminds me a lot of this series, but you have your own twist on it with the runes, so go for it!
This.

This system is good enough on its own. Opens up a few nice twists and turns you could build on.

Can spirits be cut from their masters/users? Can they be weaponized outside of being used for magic?
Does personalized magic just grow more powerful or does the specialization come with downsides?
Do spirits mature or are they just a magic wand/battery?
Is it possible to turn spirits into artifacts (maybe powerful ones, but at the loss of magic)?
Are runes preset or can they be customized?
 

PeacefulMyst

In your heart~
Joined
Dec 23, 2021
Messages
672
Points
133
This.

This system is good enough on its own. Opens up a few nice twists and turns you could build on.

Can spirits be cut from their masters/users? Can they be weaponized outside of being used for magic?
Does personalized magic just grow more powerful or does the specialization come with downsides?
Do spirits mature or are they just a magic wand/battery?
Is it possible to turn spirits into artifacts (maybe powerful ones, but at the loss of magic)?
Are runes preset or can they be customized?
Aight I'm just gonna spend my time trying to think up of twists that will mach the plot im going for now.

I have thought of some of these too. Like a slave camp which is basically a farm for stones made of spirits.
although
Can spirits be cut from their masters/users? Can they be weaponized outside of being used for magic?
this. Hadn't thought of it but it sounds like something i could incorporate.

Currently, one of my problems is trying to make a source for proper magic tools. As stated by Kilola


Thanks for all the help everyone. Now I'm gonna go work more on developing the magic system. its flaws etc. :)
 

TheTrinary

Hi, I'm Stephen
Joined
Nov 23, 2020
Messages
1,011
Points
153
All the spirit bits make me think of stormlight but it's also the part I don't get. What is the interaction between the magic user and the spirit?
 
Top