Someone asked for feedback for their first story and got this in return. "This story is like the definition of slop someone shit out their ass."
Now you can judge for yourself whether dry and blunt replies here are rude, or as blunt as you initially have thought.
Hmm, that is definitely a rude comment but it's outwardly rude and hostile with no intent for being subtle. In simpler terms, it's easy to identify.
It would hurt, and it would hurt more if more people were to agree with it. But I don't think rudeness applies to whats mean or what's not, there are levels of intensity to them. Sometimes people can be rude to someone without meaning to through a comment or remark that may seem casual to someone else.
It's not as bad as I was expecting truth be told x) but I'm glad it isn't either. I hope this implies that there's not many plain negative comments on the forums here :)
This forum forbids solicition. Unless it's a business orientated space, people will always frown upon it. The essence of your request was where to post it on the forum for traffic. That itself was wrong.
Example: Hello, I'm graduating soon and need a new laptop. I already have a job, but fincances are tight. I want to open a patreon and kofi, but I'm grateful if anyone knows alternatives for donations.
SEE, no solicition. Before there was a wall of text which read like a sob story. Don't blame people for thinking so, the pattern is similar to shmeless scams that come in spam emails. Instant negative impression.
Hm, I see. Of course I could have worded it better, but I am unfamiliar with these scams or spam emails. I can take mention to add more details in the future, I didn't think or anticipate that people would react in that manner when to me, I was just asking for a bit of guidance navigating how donations are made.
If people are still willing to add their advice it would be nice. This sounds like a misunderstanding if your words speak for everyone else from the first page of responses. I was considering just figuring it out on my own again because of the feedback, but if people are willing to share some advice about it that would be greatly appreciated.