I know it's a bit hasty, but I'd like to know if I'm starting any good

Failnot

Active member
Joined
Dec 6, 2025
Messages
76
Points
33
This is the first story I've ever written, so it's a bit rough. I'd really appreciate any and all feedback. What am I doing okay? What am I doing poorly? What should I focus on? Is the synopsis eye-catching enough? Are the opening two chapters interesting? I know the cover image kinda sucks (though I also kinda like it) so should I make sure to change it quick?

https://www.scribblehub.com/series/2035043/calling-all-unwanted-hunters-please/

Here it is. There's only two chapters, but I'd like it if you took a look and told me your thoughts. Thanks in advance
 

CinnaSloth

Sinful Sloth
Joined
Nov 20, 2024
Messages
522
Points
108
I took a quick look.
Mind you, I'm not trying to be mean, or rude, but I am dyslexic, so punctuation, and grammar are some things I, personally, generally, look for, and you're missing... a lot of it; Not saying you need to be perfect at it, or need to go edit everything if you don't want to, but with the way you naturally write, commas will be your friend.

That said, (putting punctuation, and grammar aside.)
This is your synopsis:

You don't really have to be a magus anymore. Sure, if you're born into a magical lineage you'll have to learn the secrets and then pass them onto your own offspring or maybe inscribe them into the neurons of a bullfrog somewhere, but you don't actually have to practice. There is just no reason to get yourself involved in that nonsense. You wanna protect Humanity? Pursue knowledge? The ladies and gentlemen of the Associations have that covered. Just relax.

But, despite this fact, these "prodigal sons" eventually find their way back to magic after coming face-to-face with the reality of everyday life for years and years on end. The keyword is eventually.

Filia Tertias, at the age of 18 years, 3 months, 4 days, and about half an hour, felt he'd had more than enough of the world of Humanity and seen all its fathoms, and so, leapt headfirst into the second (possibly third) most terrible of the terrible businesses of magic, hunting. Quickly outcast, he finds himself at the center of an agency of other rejected hunters, and suffers the cost of trying to make a living, and his own hubris...

Question:
Is it called "The Association", or are you leaving the name of the association vague?

I noticed the first paragraph reads more like an announcement; A paperboy, or someone on the street shouting at people, 'hear ye, hear ye'.
I would say, remove the "Just relax." at the end. Everything else is great. The "just relax" is more of an eyeroll, as it should be, but you're trying to bring people in to read your book, not deter them.

The second paragraph jumps into... 'Author mode''(??) describing the, seemingly, fact(?) that these people who delved themselves into magic, left magic behind for a regular life, but ultimately ran back(???).

Why did they leave in the first place? Also.. If they don't need to practice, what are they running back to? This line doesn't really make much sense to me.

The third is very... sloggish -compared to the first. I know it's supposed to be comedic in some way, but doesn't read as such (at least, not for me). I also recognize it's where your story description begins... so you can't delete it entirely.

I would (which you don't have to if you don't want to) write it as such:
Filia Tertias had more than enough! The world society had created had become dull, predictable, and boring. He'd seen everything it could possibly fathom from the perch of his all mighty ego, and at the cost of his own hubris, he'd decided to leap, headlong, into the business of Hunting; A business so dreadful, it was deemed as: 'The most disgraceful use of magic that could have ever been imagined'.

Keep the 1st. and explain the awkwardness of the 2nd, or delete it. The first paragraph was eye catching on it own.

...and the cover is.. -memorable.. though, I don't think for good reason. lol
Either way, good job so far.
 

LeilaniOtter

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 29, 2025
Messages
1,185
Points
113
I honestly think you should start by re-writing your synopsis first and get people interested. Right now, it's vague, confusing and all over the place. ?
 

Failnot

Active member
Joined
Dec 6, 2025
Messages
76
Points
33
Ty for the responses, I’ll try and work on that synopsis today.

As for the cover, that’ll take some more time because my artistic department doesn’t exist. I could always hop into paint with a bunch more PNGs

Edit: As for grammar and mechanics, I do kind of suck at that. I’ll also try to improve this tho

Edit 2: Name of the association is left vague intentionally here yes
 

CinnaSloth

Sinful Sloth
Joined
Nov 20, 2024
Messages
522
Points
108
Ty for the responses, I’ll try and work on that synopsis today.

As for the cover, that’ll take some more time because my artistic department doesn’t exist. I could always hop into paint with a bunch more PNGs

Edit: As for grammar and mechanics, I do kind of suck at that. I’ll also try to improve this tho

Edit 2: Name of the association is left vague intentionally here yes

If you don't have the art skill, download gimp, use the extra layers within the program tab to add a bunch of pictures, copy paste from the net, make a collage, cut what you don't need, or don't like. use another tab to trace everything as a whole. then just color. make yourself a concept of what you're trying to create for a cover piece. I'm sure, if you add the concept to the art tab here on SH, you'll get someone who's willing to help you turn it into a rendered piece.
 

Failnot

Active member
Joined
Dec 6, 2025
Messages
76
Points
33
Did a thing with the synopsis, trying to follow the advice I was given. Cover art problem needs a lot more brainstorming

If anyone's got any advice or thoughts on the very little story content there is, I'd like to hear that too, thx
 

Failnot

Active member
Joined
Dec 6, 2025
Messages
76
Points
33
update

focusing 25% of my brainpower on figuring out what to do with the cover

i'll figure it out soon

edit: also changed the title, if there's any time to do it now it's now
 
Last edited:
Top