I humbly request all to read the story I have posted

ICANEATFIRE

Active member
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
2
Points
41
This one is something I have wanted to do for a long time. I hope I can receive some feedback.

Link
https://www.scribblehub.com/series/354236/carefree-demon/
carefree-demon-aaaabzw7sba.jpg
 

SakeVision

Sama/kisama
Joined
Jul 30, 2021
Messages
1,013
Points
153
checked out the blurb, the preface(kinda bloggy but I found the content agreeable so whatever), the evolution chapter(unnecessary to explain it in a separate chapter, you should rather feed the information to the reader organically) and then snow prologue...

and that's when things got seriously wrong. The chapter is ridden with a lot of tell-not-show, and things happen too quickly.
I understand it's just a prologue and you want to skim through events and get to the action quickly, but I feel like it should have been several times longer, and maybe constitute its own mini-arc. Show how he is bright and hard-working, introduce us to other villagers, show how he interacts with them....

If the village is going to betray him and/or get destroyed, it would do you well to describe its inhabitants and geography in detail, so that when they die or turn on the mc it will hurt the reader who already started growing attached to them.

also, while I'm usually not the one to pay attention to grammar and style, as most of what I read are poorly translated Chinese xianxia novels and I grew used to it and enjoy them despiteit, it would do you well to remove some redundancies in writing.

example

"tears ran down both of his cheeks."----> "tears ran down his cheeks"

here both is unnecessary unless he is some kind of creature that has more or fewer cheeks than humans do and it is necessary to list exactly how many cheeks he has
 

ICANEATFIRE

Active member
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
2
Points
41
checked out the blurb, the preface(kinda bloggy but I found the content agreeable so whatever), the evolution chapter(unnecessary to explain it in a separate chapter, you should rather feed the information to the reader organically) and then snow prologue...

and that's when things got seriously wrong. The chapter is ridden with a lot of tell-not-show, and things happen too quickly.
I understand it's just a prologue and you want to skim through events and get to the action quickly, but I feel like it should have been several times longer, and maybe constitute its own mini-arc. Show how he is bright and hard-working, introduce us to other villagers, show how he interacts with them....

If the village is going to betray him and/or get destroyed, it would do you well to describe its inhabitants and geography in detail, so that when they die or turn on the mc it will hurt the reader who already started growing attached to them.

also, while I'm usually not the one to pay attention to grammar and style, as most of what I read are poorly translated Chinese xianxia novels and I grew used to it and enjoy them despiteit, it would do you well to remove some redundancies in writing.

example

"tears ran down both of his cheeks."----> "tears ran down his cheeks"

here both is unnecessary unless he is some kind of creature that has more or fewer cheeks than humans do and it is necessary to list exactly how many cheeks he has
Thanks for your valuable feedback, I will pay attention to it and make the necessary changes.
 

SakeVision

Sama/kisama
Joined
Jul 30, 2021
Messages
1,013
Points
153
Thanks for your valuable feedback, I will pay attention to it and make the necessary changes.

well, they aren't really "necessary" it's just my 5 cents. As long as you are enjoying your own story, you don't have to change anything.
 

Snusmumriken

Vagabond and traveller
Joined
May 22, 2021
Messages
449
Points
103
I would agree with SakeVision. at the moment the 1st chapter feels more like a list of descriptions rather than a story. You are telling readers about characters rather than allow them to come up with conclusions themselves. Like you told us that he is hardworking yet the only thing he does in the chapter is run to the water and skips a stone. As such readers would find it much harder to imagine this character for them he is but a description, a statement rather than a character. And because of that what happens to the village doesn't feel as dramatic anymore.

Also, pay attention to your tenses (you have a few verbs in present tense) and on the transition between the dialogue and the supporting sentences. Some of them don't belong to be right after (or before the quotation marks
 

Representing_Tromba

Sleep deprived mess of an author begging for feedb
Joined
Jan 29, 2020
Messages
5,988
Points
233
I shall take a look. However, I request that you do the same for my stories if you would be so kind.
 
Top