HI! I'm a new writer. can someone review my story and give me his opinion about it?

Bimbanana

Dismembered member
Joined
Oct 8, 2025
Messages
74
Points
18
1. Your synopsis contradict itself, if they are made because the city crime is too much for the existing police, why are they underfunded?
2. Cannot imagine what the city looks like, because you dont even try to describe it that much
3. Cannot imagine who is being where
4. Cannot even imagine the characters
5. All above because you obviously too excited to start writing the action scene
6. Bye

Oh i forgot,

7. There will be messages coming to you saying your story had potential, i got an idea for your story, blablabla.
Well guess what? None of us are that special

Bye

Building World Peace with My Bloodthirsty Demon Army
Your paragraph text (1).jpg
 
Last edited:

oussama_schrodinger

New member
Joined
Dec 4, 2025
Messages
19
Points
3
lol chill dude.
1. Your synopsis contradict itself, if they are made because the city crime is too much for the existing police, why are they underfunded?
2. Cannot imagine what the city looks like, because you dont even try to describe it that much
3. Cannot imagine who is being where
4. Cannot even imagine the characters
5. All above because you obviously too excited to start writing the action scene
6. Bye

Oh i forgot,

7. There will be messages coming to you saying your story had potential, i got an idea for your story, blablabla.
Well guess what? None of us are that special

Bye

Building World Peace with My Bloodthirsty Demon Army
View attachment 44113
lol chill dude.
 
Last edited:

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
637
Points
93
lol chill dude.

lol chill dude.
Actually, he's got a point with 7, though he could've worded that part better. You will get a lot of scammers trying to tell you they have ideas, and then just sell you AI generated art for your cover. As for the rest, I didn't read your story, but based on what he said, let me try to translate, but nicer.

1. I don't think I could phrase that much better, if they made some sort of agency to handle things since the police couldn't, then it makes more sense that the regular police are underfunded, not this new system.
2. You should probably give a better description of the city, at least the general atmosphere and what type of era (cyberpunk, modern, medieval).
3. Didn't really understand that one too well, but I think he means you're transitioning to where characters are is a bit confusing, so he can't keep track of that.
4. Probably just means to add descriptions for you characters.
5. Even if your story is mostly about action, without a good plot, you're basically solo leveling without any of the good animation, so maybe work on your pacing a bit, and add more character development.
6. Bye.

Of course, that's all just me guessing based on what he said, I didn't actually have time to read it, so I could be totally wrong about what they meant.
 

oussama_schrodinger

New member
Joined
Dec 4, 2025
Messages
19
Points
3
Actually, he's got a point with 7, though he could've worded that part better. You will get a lot of scammers trying to tell you they have ideas, and then just sell you AI generated art for your cover. As for the rest, I didn't read your story, but based on what he said, let me try to translate, but nicer.

1. I don't think I could phrase that much better, if they made some sort of agency to handle things since the police couldn't, then it makes more sense that the regular police are underfunded, not this new system.
2. You should probably give a better description of the city, at least the general atmosphere and what type of era (cyberpunk, modern, medieval).
3. Didn't really understand that one too well, but I think he means you're transitioning to where characters are is a bit confusing, so he can't keep track of that.
4. Probably just means to add descriptions for you characters.
5. Even if your story is mostly about action, without a good plot, you're basically solo leveling without any of the good animation, so maybe work on your pacing a bit, and add more character development.
6. Bye.

Of course, that's all just me guessing based on what he said, I didn't actually have time to read it, so I could be totally wrong about what they meant.
Thank you! that's much better, i like 'Constructive' criticism. but he is lying. there was no view yet on my story, he didn't read it too. he just did read the blurb and moved on. I didn't wanna info dump on the FIRST chapter so, thanks for being a normal human being. that dude probably got no readers and he is projecting.
 
Top