[for readers] what you consider a red flag when you're looking for a new story to read?

TASTYLEADPAINT

Resident Tech priest
Joined
Aug 10, 2020
Messages
596
Points
133
A very large amount of chapters. I know it sounds weird but seeing a story that has 400+ chapters is very off putting. Because to me it signals that this story really should have ended ages ago or this story is really really slow paced. (Or your milking it for money). No hate to those who have written that far but come on you must be bored by now right?
 
Joined
May 25, 2021
Messages
14
Points
18
For me there are a bunch of red flags that I skip. When it comes to browsing through a list, harem and smut are immediate no gos. In the synopsis elements that usually are red flags are bad grammar, revenge in combination with cold and ruthless MC and romance. Of course a synopsis also needs to appeal to me (same goes for the first chapter) but I think those are the main red flags.
 

Moonpearl

The Yuri Empress
Joined
Dec 25, 2018
Messages
764
Points
133
If it's marked as part of the Girls Love genre, but actually has the "Male protagonist" tag... That is not a yuri - that is, if we're being generous, a "Girls Love Subplot" tag.
If you don't know which is which, hold your peace and use neither. Male harem novels do not belong under that genre no matter how you delude yourself.

Most things under the Gender Bender genre, unless it also has the Transgender tag and looks like it's not wholly about transformation or gender.

Also "loli/shota", rape or brainwashing tags, BDSM smut (don't trust the stuff here anymore, it's never normal), 99% of things with a Male Protagonist tag...

Ah, and the "Manly Gay Couple" tag. Nothing loses my respect faster than that tag.
Normally, anything that actually belongs under it cuts out all rationality, personality and self-control from its characters, in the name of meeting pathetically strict gender roles.
Like, yes, your character broke his love interest's nose on first meeting and often goes into long sulks about being emasculated. Please do tell me what a stud of an "Alpha" he is and how terrible those "weak, girly soy boy" BLs are.

I honestly think the only justified use of this tag is if you're writing JoJo fanfiction.
 

Zirrboy

Fueled by anger
Joined
Jan 25, 2021
Messages
1,192
Points
153
If you don't know which is which, hold your peace and use neither.
Which gets the people who don't want to read it annoyed because you didn't tag it.
And by nature of the search engine, you can't specifically exclude the subplot tag if you want to include others, or filter it in the releases, unlike the genre one.
There's always someone going to tell you it's better a different way.
 

Moonpearl

The Yuri Empress
Joined
Dec 25, 2018
Messages
764
Points
133
Which gets the people who don't want to read it annoyed because you didn't tag it.
And by nature of the search engine, you can't specifically exclude the subplot tag if you want to include others, or filter it in the releases, unlike the genre one.
There's always someone going to tell you it's better a different way.
You can add a warning in your description, if you're that worried.

The series finder absolutely does allow you to specify separate tags to include or exclude.

I've never seen anyone who uses the genre for "mere practicality" - they genuinely believe one fanservice side couple makes them a yuri that yuri lovers want to read.
 

Zirrboy

Fueled by anger
Joined
Jan 25, 2021
Messages
1,192
Points
153
You can add a warning in your description, if you're that worried.
So they did for you by adding the male protagonist label. One group has to do the extra work and I've yet to hear someone say that theirs should.

The series finder absolutely does allow you to specify separate tags to include or exclude.
Yeah, mixed that up with something else, my bad on that one.

I've never seen anyone who uses the genre for "mere practicality" - they genuinely believe one fanservice side couple makes them a yuri that yuri lovers want to read.
I don't read much yuri, so I can't confirm nor deny the first part, what I have seen however is people getting quite upset at instances that weren't tagged.
And as for the second: Blanket statement and or gatekeeping.
 

Jailbreak571

Former CEO of Kamazon. Active lurker
Joined
Nov 17, 2021
Messages
402
Points
133
...
I dunno. I guess harem? Or maybe r18 stuff? Yeah, weird. I'm on scribble hub and I don't even read r18. Anyways, Back to the point... I can't think of anything.

...

I guess child mc who is always treated like a goddess or God for no reason.

I can tolerate people who look like 12 years old but is actually older than that like some immortality shit or reincarnation shit but please, no 5 years old(even reincarnated ones) being treated like some god letting her do everything that you adults should do.

The only time that I remember tolerating this thing was because of age progression.
 

Representing_Tromba

Sleep deprived mess of an author begging for feedb
Joined
Jan 29, 2020
Messages
5,966
Points
233
This is a small list of the things that turn me away from just the first chapter.

No cover (it usually means they aren't committed yet)

The story having over 10 chapters but less than 5,000 words in total.

Walls of text without breaks

Lacking basic character or scene descriptions

Political pandering or social pandering no matter the group being pandered too. (Having commentary about political or social issues through the characters or plot is fine though.)

There are more but they are usually hit or miss.
 

Snowyflakes

Active member
Joined
Jul 29, 2022
Messages
85
Points
33
Harem and LitRPG tags are a no-go for me. Then, the synopsis. If it has grammar mistakes or weird writing, such as THIS or tHiS, I stop reading right away. And then, the mix between a bad synopsis with the BL, GL, GB, Sport, and Martial Arts tags.
 
Joined
Jan 15, 2019
Messages
2,410
Points
153
Boring stories.

I couldn't bother to read more and won't force myself to if it just bores me from the get-go. well, others might say it would start to get better around 100 chapters or so, but I'd rather spend my time on things that I immediately would like and stick for long.

and it's kinda hard for me to pick up new stories. so many stuff doesn't interest me anymore.
 

ACertainPassingUser

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 12, 2022
Messages
1,102
Points
153
Multiverse.

Or any badly written self insert.

It's totally a mixed bag of junk candies. I really don't know how good it would be or of I would like it or not.

Especially if the MC just hit it off with the "waifus"/"husbando" character without any challenges or difficulty.

Especially if the waifus character has troublesome or extremely bad red flag for friendship/relationship, and the MC just do it easily while many other person in that world didn't go with that person.

And I'm angry that those people that wrtire within fandom just write story about how MC get used to the world easily and meet the characters.

People should be suspecting MC for their too suspicious knowledge, or even disgusted for their attempt at approaching the "waifus"/"husbando".

And MC shouldn't go straight to the main characters, because there's a lot to explore and many stuff is different from our world. Especially if those animes were made in 2004-2008, the old technology would bring nostalgia and feel of alienation to the MC, and how did they find living place and not becoming homeless is also very questionable.

If I'm teleported to some old animes like DxD/Fate/other anime less than 2010, I would ignore the main characters and just enjoy the technology and feel the nostalgic memories. I can't stop JK Kennedy Assassination, let alone stop world destroying event, especially if the main characters would naturally solve it.

except if you're teleported to one of horribly written scribble hub fic with lots of tragedy and clear bad ending that you can solve, in that case go ahead and try to save your ass. If you're not terrified and feel frightened just to move, because you don't have the guts to destroy the world ending tragedy, which everyone feels that too.

That's why I prefer to stay at one fandom so that the author can focus at one aspect and not just fuck around with those important characters.

But anyway, I think I need to go ahead and read nonfiction book to not file my brain with too much trashes.
 

BearlyAlive

I'm not savage, you're just average
Joined
Oct 13, 2021
Messages
1,962
Points
153
Fanfics. Especially if it's multiple fandoms. This is a frigging hobbyist site, nobody's gonna raid you shaking their spears for having bad ideas, plot and characters. So at least commit to it completely. Inspirations are great, but fanfics are outright stealing. Hold it right there, criminal scum!

When a character gets/buys a slave of the opposite gender less than 5 chapters in the story. You just know it will turn into totally-not-japanese-harem-animu-novel #12343564758432615283943827123432.5.

harem seeking characters. Never got the need to collect trophies or fill the pokedex, so...

protagonist being the only one doing X/getting X done. Yeah, nope. Not buying it. Coincidences bordering on deus ex machina are alright, if explained but MC going "hey, uh? Ever tried knocking on that door to get the godslaying blade behind? Maybe they'll just opem it" isn't genius writing (unless it's a parody).

Gender bending to have "straight GL", you either go full lezz or just leave 'em with their sausage, but no "oh well, time to be an alpha male with tits wearing a skirt". I don't mean stories about coming out or transgender stuff. I mean the GL harems especially.


So yeah, harems, harem tropes and bad writing in general are red flags that make me drop or outright avoid stories faster than bombs on an air raid.
 

LAJistics

Is it gay, if it's with a futa?
Joined
Sep 24, 2022
Messages
64
Points
33
If they mention how good looking the characters are from a 1st person perspective. That's an immediate no go.

"My chiselled abs glistened in the light."

"God, I know I'm a hunk."

"The girls in my school are basically sprinklers when I walk past."
 

mysterious_cube

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 10, 2020
Messages
59
Points
58
Half-assed philosophy/rhetorical questions instead of a summary

Lots of typos in the summary and/or first few paragraphs

The author using the word "loli"

"I'm bad at summaries. Just read it."

The story isn't marked as completed, and hasn't been updated in a long time
 

Hashira

Active member
Joined
Sep 21, 2022
Messages
2
Points
43
imagine you're browsing through scribblehub for a new story to read, what kind of things that would instantly make you "nope" and just close the tab and start looking for another story to read?

assuming you're not the kind of person who will read through anything you stumble into at first no matter how terrible it is.

for me: the status board in the first chapter.

I will definitely close the tab and stay away from any kind of story that mentions the main character has xx/xx hp point, xx point of str, age, etc at the very first chapter without even explaining anything about what the hell are those status parameters are worth.
For me its the mc being like "o there's a stupidly weak elder ill hide from him and hide my power even though I can destroy the universe with one snap" ps I fixed ur grammar in ur question ur welcome
 

InceTagn

A stranger passing by.
Joined
Oct 23, 2019
Messages
151
Points
83
Info dump in the first chapter.

There was a story, the runesmith.

The first time I tried to read it, I got a headache at the first chapter and dropped It.

It is only later after finding out another story by the same author, likable I decided to check on that Story.
And here I am almost addicted to that story.
Poor me.
 

LilRora

Mostly formless
Joined
Mar 27, 2022
Messages
1,349
Points
153
For me it would be three things: harem and smut, that combination vary rarely ends well, misunderstandings in tags, because they are, great majority of times, either completely stupid or completely unfunnily exagerrated, and boy's love, because I don't like the genre.

Generally there are way too many things that might put me off to list them all, but those are the main three at the moment.
 

bulmabriefs144

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 30, 2021
Messages
274
Points
83
1665954117586.png

When the author feels the need to bullet point features of the story. Now, I've probably listed features of games and stuff myself, but telling what a fiction is like beforehand like this, particularly with "if you don't like then leave" says that alot of people have basically commented badly on this. Just write the synopsis then quit. Ranting about what the webnovel had tends to seem desperate to be liked when at the same time nervous of harsh comments. That screams "This person probably doesn't know what he's doing."

You under estimate how entertaining a fan fiction can be if you replace characters in them. It takes away the need to write background and let’s you go straight to the point. Also pretty fun to do as an author.
They also underestimate that it's actually fun to walk around in the setting of their favorite fantasy.

What I also hate is #3 on that bullet list. Please for the love of God, stop making OP characters. Especially isekai OP characters.
 
Top