For new authors

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
637
Points
93
I'm pretty new to writing, and I wanted to make a thread for new authors to come and share their work with other new authors so we can all try to improve and help each other gain more popularity!

If you have a story and want some feedback, just post it on here, and (assuming this thread gains any traction at all) someone will read it!
 

AngeloMicheal

New member
Joined
Sep 5, 2025
Messages
1
Points
3
Hello, I am writing a novel and I released a demo version here just now because I wanted to know what people thought, it's called Death God: The Trials Of The Living. This post is a pretty cool idea btw also thanks for anyone who takes the time to read through it, I appreciate all feedback.
 

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
637
Points
93
Hello, I am writing a novel and I released a demo version here just now because I wanted to know what people thought, it's called Death God: The Trials Of The Living. This post is a pretty cool idea btw also thanks for anyone who takes the time to read through it, I appreciate all feedback.
First of all, I recommend including a link when you ask for a review, but I got you. Death God: The Trials Of The Living

Second, I read your Prologue and the first three chapters after, and I think your premise seems really promising, but you definitely could use a little work on grammar and consistency. If you want a more detailed review, I'd be happy to give one, but all in all, a promising story that I'll probably continue reading when I find some more free time. Your characters personalities could use a bit more outlining, I really can't tell what any of them are like yet, other than a classic "three musketeers" style friendship. Also, maybe clear up your protagonist's gender a bit sooner in the story, that name could be used for a boy or a girl, and until chapter three, I wasn't quite sure which it was. And last, your Prologue definitely showed that something interesting was coming, but it wasn't quite strong enough to convince me to read everything, a few grammar mistakes and phrasing choices just put me off a little. But I like the idea you're going for, and depending on where it goes from here, you've got a really strong story.
I think that already exist.
Whoops... didn't know that. But whatever, this one can just be the backup for dummies like me who couldn't find that one.
 
Last edited:

Ouro

New member
Joined
Jun 22, 2025
Messages
2
Points
3
Hey everyone! I’m pretty new to writing system-based stories, so I’d love some tips on how to level up my plot. What details are essential—or what could I improve—to make the genre experience more immersive, this is my novel The Weakest Hunter Levels Up To Get Stronger! thanks for anyone who takes the time to read it, I appreciate all feedback.
 

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
637
Points
93
I just realized I may seem like a hypocrite to have not included my own story in this after being the one who started it, so...
Eidolon Codex

All I ask is that you not judge too harshly, I haven’t even written a real paragraph in years, let alone something like this.

And of course, if their really are that many flaws, I'll do what I can to fix it.
 
Last edited:

Rookieqw

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 15, 2021
Messages
236
Points
103
I just realized I may seem like a hypocrite to have not included my own story in this after being the one who started it, so...
Eidolon Codex

All I ask is that you not judge too harshly, I haven’t even written a real paragraph in years, let alone something like this.

And of course, if their really are that many flaws, I'll do what I can to fix it.
Hello! Not a new writer, but I have spare time on my hands today. Just be aware that I'm the worst writer around here, so take any of my suggestions with care.

Let's start with your cover and synopsis. The cover is good.

Then one day, with little warning, he's dragged into the battle between the ten mages who maintain the balance of the world, making friends, rivals, and forced to face the loss of some dear to him, how will he cope? Will he rise above the pain, and come out better off, or will he fall into despair, crushed by the expectations and losses?
Read the bolded part out loud. It doesn't roll off the tongue. Let's try to game it a little.

,,,and forced to face the loss of some dear to him, how will he cope?
How about

...and forced to face the loss of some dear to him. How will he cope?

Now for the story:

Yet it doesn't belong to everyone. Only ten exalted individuals in the world can wield true magic

We are introduced to a rule...

Magic is passed down through bloodlines, often the youngest of the family's generation awakens with it, but that's not always the case.

But how? If a child can use magic, does her or his parent immediately pop out of existence? That part is confusing to me. There should be far more than ten individuals wielding the sorcery at the same time.

Genki Aikawa, age sixteen, is a high school student living a mostly ordinary life—at least, on the surface. With emerald green eyes and messy, spiky black hair streaked with white from a rare genetic mutation, Genki stands out more than he’d like.



Walking beside him through the streets of Tokyo is Reika Hiiragi, his best friend since childhood. With sharp red eyes and equally wild red hair, Reika’s a fierce contrast to Genki’s laid-back energy.
Repeated descriptions. On its own, there's nothing wrong with it. But try to vary it. Maybe instead of "with," use "sporting" or "boasting"?

“I can’t believe I failed another math test,” Reika groaned, dragging her feet as they walked home.



Genki glanced sideways at her, a smirk tugging at the corner of his lips. “Maybe if you didn’t sleep through every class, you’d actually pass one for once.”



Reika stuck her tongue out. “Easy for you to say. You ace everything without even studying. I’ve never seen you open a book!”



Genki shrugged, the smirk widening. “What can I say? I’m just a prodigy.”



She rolled her eyes. “You always say that…”
That's sort of butler speech, to spoon-feed info to the audience. Both characters already know Reika had failed the test. So maybe try:

"Mom's going to force me to clean all the floors because of that stupid exam!"

"Try to stay awake in class for a change; maybe then you'll avoid the punishment."

Rough, awful, but I think it is a step in the right direction. Since Reika knows she can't pass the test, she has no reason to believe she can pass it.

They’d met when they were just kids. Genki had been raised mostly by his uncle, and back then, whenever his uncle had work meetings, he’d take Genki along. That’s how he met Reika. her father had been involved in a controversial research project, one Genki’s uncle strongly opposed.

First, missed capitalization. Two, Genki was mentioned too often in the segment.

Also, side note (I checked your comment section), but be wary of people who claim to love your work and then will try to get you to pay them in exchange for art. I doubt any of them really care, and you may lose money.
 
Last edited:

mythosandmagic

Active member
Joined
Aug 13, 2025
Messages
128
Points
43
Hello all,
I would appreciate it if anyone could have a look at my story and provide feedback. It's my first novel, and I have been working on it for over a decade.
Thank you for any and all comments.

 

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
637
Points
93
Hello! Not a new writer, but I have spare time on my hands today. Just be aware that I'm the worst writer around here, so take any of my suggestions with care.

Let's start with your cover and synopsis. The cover is good.


Read the bolded part out loud. It doesn't roll off the tongue. Let's try to game it a little.


How about

...and forced to face the loss of some dear to him. How will he cope?

Now for the story:



We are introduced to a rule...



But how? If a child can use magic, does her or his parent immediately pop out of existence? That part is confusing to me. There should be far more than ten individuals wielding the sorcery at the same time.


Repeated descriptions. On its own, there's nothing wrong with it. But try to vary it. Maybe instead of "with," use "sporting" or "boasting"?


That's sort of butler speech, to spoon-feed info to the audience. Both characters already know Reika had failed the test. So maybe try:

"Mom's going to force me to clean all the floors because of that stupid exam!"

"Try to stay awake in class for a change; maybe then you'll avoid the punishment."

Rough, awful, but I think it is a step in the right direction. Since Reika knows she can't pass the test, she has no reason to believe she can pass it.



First, missed capitalization. Two, Genki was mentioned too often in the segment.

Also, side note (I checked your comment section), but be wary of people who claim to love your work and then will try to get you to pay them in exchange for art. I doubt any of them really care, and you may lose money.
Oh, yeah, some of those are errors I went through with the intention to clean up, and kinda forgot to fix, so thanks for pointing out the issue with the ten mages bit, second, I already spoke to the person in the comments, and yes, they did ask if I wanted to do a new cover, but I declined. And I guess some of the dialog did need polishing, so I'll try and adjust it a bit to make it a bit more realistic, though I'll definitely be trying to do it in a way that fits my writing style. I appreciate the input!
 

Rookieqw

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 15, 2021
Messages
236
Points
103
I already spoke to the person in the comments, and yes, they did ask if I wanted to do a new cover
Ha, it's like clockwork! Always the same pattern. I recommend not exchanging insults or engaging in dialogue with them, as this bunch is vengeful (I remember one author complaining after these fellows went after them and used review bombings). It's easy enough to understand their intentions. Often they drop a favorite or even a rating, so rather than letting them profit off you, just ignore them or write "thank you" and take any sudden benefit as a bonus.

I appreciate the input!
No problem. Happy writing, and always stay healthy and happy!
 

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
637
Points
93
Ha, it's like clockwork! Always the same pattern. I recommend not exchanging insults or engaging in dialogue with them, as this bunch is vengeful (I remember one author complaining after these fellows went after them and used review bombings). It's easy enough to understand their intentions. Often they drop a favorite or even a rating, so rather than letting them profit off you, just ignore them or write "thank you" and take any sudden benefit as a bonus.


No problem. Happy writing, and always stay healthy and happy!
Too late for that, Lol, but they were civil enough once I told them I was a broke college student.
 

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,552
Points
283

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
637
Points
93
I'm seriously considering adding a limit to how many chapters should be allowed for "new" authors in the thread...
 

LuciferVermillion

The sadist & madman
Joined
Nov 29, 2020
Messages
111
Points
83
Does rewriting a work counts as new? Ignore the synopsis, I'm still working on it, and just read the first two chapters, please~

 

Rookieqw

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 15, 2021
Messages
236
Points
103
Does rewriting a work counts as new? Ignore the synopsis, I'm still working on it, and just read the first two chapters, please~

As usual, before we continue, keep in mind that I'm by far the worst writer around here, so take any of my suggestions with distrust.

You told me it was not time yet, Cione. Did you lie to me?
This comes as inner thoughts of the character. I recommend marking them something like:

Ten seconds. No more. Then it vanished into nothing, as though it had never existed at all.

I understood far too well. Far earlier than I was meant to.

You told me it was not time yet, Cione. Did you lie to me?
So, Your Grace—” Herman began carefully, “do you mind explaining why you woke us at three in the morning to fly to the Silesia Republic?”



The cup halted halfway to my lips. Slowly, I lowered it again and looked around. Their postures were straight. Their eyes fixed forward. Their silence— thicker than before.
The empty space between sentences comes as unneeded, unless you plan to place an image there.
“Well, he’s a pilot. We’re not,” Herman said, forcing a casual shrug. “The rest of us aren’t built for that kind of energy to work two four slash seven.”
Sorry, but the incoming betrayal was coming far too obviously. The MC had spotted that something was off and still drank the cup. Did he have a death wish? Either you should write the scene for the MC to come off as more oblivious, or you should not make him drink it. I mean:

My eyes narrowed. “Hmph. Playing dumb, are we?” I let the edge return to my voice, cold and deliberate. “What’s going on? You’re never this nervous in an emergency.”

His silence stretched a beat too long. Then—

“…Because you’ve never been this worried,” Herman murmured, the words slipping out low. His eyes didn’t quite meet mine, but the unease in them was there, sharp as a blade hidden in cloth.

You're drumming "Betrayer! Betrayer!" to a reader. If I, who never met these characters, could guess that Herman was a traitor, it should be obvious to the MC.

It’s pointless, you fakes— I’ve already seen through your tricks.
Still think that thoughts should be marked with another style.

Steel flashed— a low slash angling for my ribs. I caught his wrist mid-swing; tendons jumped under my grip, then crack—bone slipped and split. His eyes flared wide, breath hitching for a cry that never came. My fist drove into his gut; he folded, weight collapsing into my twist. One wrench—snap— and his neck gave beneath my hands.

Cool way to hint at the superhuman nature of the MC.

“…I’m sorry, but you are an obstacle.” Her blade whispered free from her boot. She advanced in measured steps, nothing wasted. No smirk. No tremor. Her eyes met mine—steady, weighted—like someone stepping into a storm she knew she could not survive.

Why boot? She's a knight, why conceal a weapon?

No, the part about "nothing wasted" doesn't work, because you already establish her:

“You shouldn’t have skipped the procedures, O shadow of the wise prince,” Fake Luna said, her voice cutting through the cabin—low, even, unshaken.

She gloated, already wasting potential surprise.

“You shouldn’t have skipped the procedures, O shadow of the wise prince,” Fake Luna said, her voice cutting through the cabin—low, even, unshaken.

O shadow of the wise prince.
I assume it refers to the fact that he is the original, while the clone is not, but she is not aware of it. Anyway, I don't get why you repeated it twice, or who even thinks it at the moment.

The rest recoiled in shock, but Herman was already moving. He sank low, sweeping his knife in a ruthless arc across their ankles. Tendons parted; balance failed. They collapsed forward, forced into knees as if the floor itself demanded it.
That part is on me, but, IMO, you should've given us some descriptions of how they looked. Now I understand that none of the knights had any armor on, but since they were, well, knights, I assumed that they had heavy plates. Or mails. Or power armor.

“You monster,” he whispered with a strange gentleness. “I even sacrificed my comrades—just to make you believe. Just to make you lower your guard.”
Even though I saw it coming (since there was no way for him to be here without the killers' noticing), it was a very cool twist.

Sorry about doing only one chapter; I don't have time for two.
 
Top