[Closed] Easy Going Feedback thread

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,603
Points
158
Yeah, the hooks planned after the first book are stronger IMO. In part by design - book one is an origin story, setting up the rest of the series (and his crossover into Strange Awakening - which takes place after his unwritten third book).
Thanks - it is a genre I haven't really worked in before, and was basically reading two chapters of The Big Sleep then writing one chapter of it during a flight to New Orleans.
As for his city... I keep sending him to real ones. Not sure I want to give him a named home city. My other attempt at a character like him was tied to Detroit, which would probably be my best bet for Jack unless I want to research California, as that was where most US Noirs seem to be set.
 

Racosharko

Fanatically Whimsical
Joined
Jan 1, 2019
Messages
937
Points
133
E
Wasnt sure what is about
Went thru the prologue was confused
couldn't find the dramatic hook
When thru up to chap 3
I found it too hard to follow,
could just be style.

Some times its hard to track who is doing what where and who is talking.

there are few to no paragaphs or "blocks" so it hard for me to know where the beats and scenes are.

So yeah, I don't know maybe people that read a lot of LN can follow it better, but not I.
 

Hoshino

Hoshino not found
Joined
Dec 23, 2024
Messages
1,008
Points
128
Wasnt sure what is about
Went thru the prologue was confused
couldn't find the dramatic hook
When thru up to chap 3
I found it too hard to follow,
could just be style.

Some times its hard to track who is doing what where and who is talking.

there are few to no paragaphs or "blocks" so it hard for me to know where the beats and scenes are.

So yeah, I don't know maybe people that read a lot of LN can follow it better, but not I.
That's unsettling...
But well.. Still thanks!
 

Racosharko

Fanatically Whimsical
Joined
Jan 1, 2019
Messages
937
Points
133
Heyo, feel free to check mine out if you want and give your feedback. It is in the signature.

PS: Much obliged.
Ok... here we go

Chap 0
Amnesiac Protag, learn as MC learns...

As I continued on my journey, having said my farewells, a memory of my younger self waving goodbye to an old man bubbled up to the surface. “Don’t worry, Dad. I won’t forget, and I will not abandon our creed even if it gets hard.”

I quickly wiped my eyes as they had become slightly misty.
Some character revelation, fine.

I think the first chapter is fine, but would be a more interesting read if the pacing is not soooo.... same-y

You see a lot of the "blocks" is told from action to action

As I made my way...
My ruminations came...
I clutched my head...
Curiously, everywhere I looked...
As I continued my journey...

if some of the "blocks" starts with a thing rather than an action it can create more variety IMO
e.g you have
"I clutched my head, trying to prevent an oncoming headache. Opening my eyes, I tried to focus on anything but the temple. My attention was drawn towards the villagers toiling in the fields, occasionally being aided by young children."

Action then thing
action I clutched my head, trying to prevent an oncoming headache. Opening my eyes, I tried to focus on anything but the temple.
thing: My attention was drawn towards the villagers toiling in the fields, occasionally being aided by young children.

change it up might be good



Chapter 1

it's an easier read

I was jolted back to reality by a tap on my shoulder.
Opportunity to enter this beat differently using different patterns, to signify a scene change.


Chapter 2
confusing perspective.
I think there is some difficulty for me to pin where the "Attention centre" is previously you have always used FOV
you opened with dialogue but did not immediately establish time and location.

So I was lost

It had been almost two weeks
Too late in the chapter for me, I had to roll back and re-read the previous chapter a few more times at this point.

Even if you don't want to reveal it immediately. needed some kind of hint that "mc" is different from the mc from the previous chapter. Like what is he wearing or what he is doing but wasn't before, like a clean fix point of narrative centre.


Skimmed the rest
Stopped at Chapter 3

For people who like a slow burn, it would work for them
but unfortunately not for me,

it looks like at the end of chapter 3 the "voice" makes a return

that's good because I feel that in the first part it needed a major driver for the story or a bigger hook.
and I didn't feel the hook was there untill the "voice" came back


ANyway OK
 
Last edited:

HellsPerfectSpawn

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 29, 2024
Messages
118
Points
83
I thank you for your time. I feel more confused after the feedback than before. Obviously I need to brush up on things apparently.
 

Racosharko

Fanatically Whimsical
Joined
Jan 1, 2019
Messages
937
Points
133
Top