Am I doing metaphors right?

PBJ_Time

It's Peanut Butter Jelly Time!
Joined
Jun 7, 2023
Messages
263
Points
103
I learned from a friend that even horny scenes or scenes that imply the horny should still fall under the "show, don't tell" aspect of writing. So, I did my best trying to convey a scene in my latest chapter without using words like "meat wand" or phrases like "breasting boobily down the stairs." Here's an excerpt:
“Here’s to Hajime, still being the same, just the way we like him!” said Tokiwa, smiling with her other hand pressed against her chest. “And here’s to my lovely husband, whom I’ll never get tired of carrying to our bed after a rowdy drinking game of who can name the most spell attacks!”

Haruto cleared his throat immediately after the one discrepancy in her statement. “Umm, technically, I’m still not your husband.”

“Just roll with it, babe, or I’ll be milking your ‘P-spot’ double time tonight,” Tokiwa retorted, eyes closed with a pout on her cheeks.

“Well, I’m the one who took both your virginities first, so that means I’m the strongest in that field.”

“Nuh-uh! I went full animal with your happy place for ten minutes before we did the deed. I’ll always surpass you in every field!”

“That doesn’t count, and besides, you should’ve—”

Little did they know that Hajime would give his throat the loudest call for attention in the room. He’d do it again until the heat death of the universe if he must. “Could you guys please take all these tensions back to the sheets? I feel like beating your heads with a wooden bat.”

Tokiwa returned to her seat, placing the glass on its designated coaster. “My apologies, Orca. We didn’t mean anything by it, but I must say, I thought you were the last person to complain about such things. Remember what you did during our summer break?”

Hajime predicted she’d move to the one subject that plunged their school to an endless shock. He wanted to experience a different kind of fun in what started out as a non-risque awareness stream for people like him—people who didn’t care whether the backsides and knockers they got to enjoy came from the metaphysical Mars or Venus. He never regretted setting it to private except for his most loyal followers, having everything to do with shameless pleasure.

Despite the sensation returning to him like an orgasmic bullet train, the idea of three former delinquents who came out of the closet offering him a “spit roast” before the ladies joined in was admittedly too spicy for his budding exploration. Perhaps it wasn’t just the lightning coursing through his veins that wanted things to speed up. Even the noisy springs of his mattress remained in his memories with each admittedly semi-decent thrust.

“That was for charity,” said Hajime, hunched over his chair with a shrug. “I paid them all 5,000 yen at the end of the week. It was time for our aging, decrepit, small-minded ‘leaders’ to see the bigger picture and hear our voices. They never cared about us, but we stood loud and proud.”
Now, tell me, does it truly convey the scene I wanted to show instead of tell? I'm afraid that if I keep this us, no one will understand me.
 

OatMush

up to no good
Joined
Nov 15, 2023
Messages
124
Points
103
Well for starters, it's cool that you've got bisexual male characters, don't see that many places.
I'm not sure I'd consider any of this to be metaphorical, it's just awkward euphemisms, and maybe more to the point, it's all still telling. As in you're telling me that Haruto and Takawa are together but not married and have a kinky sex life, you tell me that Haruto took Takawa's virginity, you tell me there was a bisex stream (I'm not sure I understood this section but that's beside the point). This is all tell.
I'd rework this, remove or at least turn down the euphemisms, and focus more on the characters' relationships to each other. Rather than break the flow by expositing exactly what happened last summer, imply something happened but leave it up to the audiences imagination, or leave it as a juicy mystery to be revealed later.
I know people have been a bit rough to you in your feedbacks (including me back when I did that) but overall I'd say it's commendable that you're working hard on improving your writing, keep it up :)
 

PBJ_Time

It's Peanut Butter Jelly Time!
Joined
Jun 7, 2023
Messages
263
Points
103
Well for starters, it's cool that you've got bisexual male characters, don't see that many places.
I'm not sure I'd consider any of this to be metaphorical, it's just awkward euphemisms, and maybe more to the point, it's all still telling. As in you're telling me that Haruto and Takawa are together but not married and have a kinky sex life, you tell me that Haruto took Takawa's virginity, you tell me there was a bisex stream (I'm not sure I understood this section but that's beside the point). This is all tell.
I'd rework this, remove or at least turn down the euphemisms, and focus more on the characters' relationships to each other. Rather than break the flow by expositing exactly what happened last summer, imply something happened but leave it up to the audiences imagination, or leave it as a juicy mystery to be revealed later.
I know people have been a bit rough to you in your feedbacks (including me back when I did that) but overall I'd say it's commendable that you're working hard on improving your writing, keep it up :)
Thanks, fam. I actually toned down the showing aspect because I really didn't wanna fall into the trap of other authors describing breasts like they're slushy water balloons or how elephants fighting could be a metaphor for the missionary position. They just sound very strange within the context of sex and sexuality. For example, I wanted to describe Haruto and Tokiwa's sex life with a more positive take on A Clockwork Orange's "old in and out" monologue, but it devolved into other metaphors about how a strap-on is like a therapist's hand reaching out to you for comfort.

I do more showing in my writing with fight scenes or if characters are cooking a meal. It's easier to convey something like a fantasy restaurant grilling some steak before freezing them in liquid nitrogen than how you could possibly write about someone's behind in a horny scene without sounding like you're writing about sewer diving.
 
Top