Ai checkers are dumb

IshiharaNiaoka

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 8, 2022
Messages
243
Points
103
I wanted to test out if ai checkers are actually legit, so I made chatgpt generate a prompt and I pasted it into the ai. It said 0% ai so it's written by a human ? then I pasted my African friend's new story inside and omit said 27% ai mix and I was like wtf, she didn't use ai.

So the ai checker is dumb, how can you say 0% ai to something chatgpt literally wrote but 27% ai to what an African lady wrote? I also did some more research and it stated that ai checkers tend to consider work written by non English natives ai work

Maybe I wasn't using the right ai checker
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20230807-101714.jpg
    Screenshot_20230807-101714.jpg
    391.9 KB · Views: 118
  • Screenshot_20230807-101016.jpg
    Screenshot_20230807-101016.jpg
    401.1 KB · Views: 119
Last edited:

TheMonotonePuppet

A Puppet Colored by Medication
Joined
Apr 24, 2023
Messages
2,839
Points
153
I wanted to test out if ai checkers are actually legit, so I made chatgpt generate a prompt and I pasted it into the ai. It said 0% ai so it's written by a human ? then I pasted my African friend's new story inside and omit said 27% ai mix and I was like wtf, she didn't use ai.

So the ai checker is dumb, how can you say 0% ai to something chatgpt literally wrote but 27% ai to what an African lady wrote? I also did some more research and it stated that ai checkers tend to consider work written by non English natives ai work
At first, I thought you were talking about AI checkers, as in, the board game Checkers with an AI behind it, but now I get it.
Stars above, that's absolutely insane! That's also kind of disheartening. I wonder how many people have been falsely accused of AI work.
 

NotaNuffian

This does spark joy.
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
5,287
Points
233
I wanted to test out if ai checkers are actually legit, so I made chatgpt generate a prompt and I pasted it into the ai. It said 0% ai so it's written by a human ? then I pasted my African friend's new story inside and omit said 27% ai mix and I was like wtf, she didn't use ai.

So the ai checker is dumb, how can you say 0% ai to something chatgpt literally wrote but 27% ai to what an African lady wrote? I also did some more research and it stated that ai checkers tend to consider work written by non English natives ai work
... Do you think that the AI Checker just did favorism to his homey?
 

IshiharaNiaoka

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 8, 2022
Messages
243
Points
103
... Do you think that the AI Checker just did favorism to his homey?
?? Yes their are both ai's so their just helping each other out
At first, I thought you were talking about AI checkers, as in, the board game Checkers with an AI behind it, but now I get it.
Stars above, that's absolutely insane! That's also kind of disheartening. I wonder how many people have been falsely accused of AI work.
Indeed
 

katienugget

Active member
Joined
May 29, 2021
Messages
3
Points
43
It's not just you, they're worse than chance in many cases and it's causing problems with schools and universities trying to use them as if they actually work
 

KrakenRiderEmma

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 27, 2023
Messages
225
Points
103
The fancy one that's being used for things like newspapers' investigative reports is Originality.AI since it's a different kind of AI that's trained only to recognize patterns in AI and human content. But it's expensive: $1 per 10000 words but with a $30 minimum.

Almost all the other AI detectors use really unreliable methods like... a generalist AI that's not specifically trained. Or checking the "burstiness" or "perplexity" score of text (this is part of what makes some AI writing sound bland) -- but some humans write like that anyway, and someoneone making AI stories can just ask the AI to change the burstiness or perplexity, etc.
 

IshiharaNiaoka

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 8, 2022
Messages
243
Points
103
??
That is very disheartening to say the least! Could you give me the Ai checker's link so I can see if my story by AI rated by an Ai?
Sure

It's not just you, they're worse than chance in many cases and it's causing problems with schools and universities trying to use them as if they actually work
Sadly
yes, OP.. link the ai checker!
Here
The fancy one that's being used for things like newspapers' investigative reports is Originality.AI since it's a different kind of AI that's trained only to recognize patterns in AI and human content. But it's expensive: $1 per 10000 words but with a $30 minimum.

Almost all the other AI detectors use really unreliable methods like... a generalist AI that's not specifically trained. Or checking the "burstiness" or "perplexity" score of text (this is part of what makes some AI writing sound bland) -- but some humans write like that anyway, and someoneone making AI stories can just ask the AI to change the burstiness or perplexity, etc.
So true!!! And it could even by pass Ai system, meanwhile normal writers would take the fall
 

Ai-chan

Queen of Yuri Devourer of Traps
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
1,668
Points
153
Oi! What did you say about Ai? Your repeated dissing of Ai within the same post has summoned Ai-chan!

And also, chatgpt lies. It can only interact to prompts within the same session. That's why if your college professor runs your essay through chatgpt, that bastard will claim all the credit and you'll fail the semester.
 
Top