• Thread starter Deleted member 89995
  • Start date

Representing_Tromba

Sleep deprived mess of an author begging for feedb
Joined
Jan 29, 2020
Messages
5,974
Points
233
Yes. If I didn't then I wouldn't be striving to get better. If my writing isn't up to par with Bernard Cornwell's writing(or at the very least, Brent Weeks) then I need to study and write more.
 

StainedGlassThreads

Well-known member
Joined
May 25, 2022
Messages
35
Points
58
I try not to. I end up doing so anyways.

Quality is subjective and won't always guarantee success. Sometimes things succeed specifically because they're bad, and everyone wants to watch the trainwreck. Or it's a work that's just mediocre, but because it doesn't require deep thought and is reasonably exciting, it takes off in popularity. Sometimes I compare myself to those authors, and assure myself that even if I'll never get as popular as them, I've written a better story than them by my own standards. When I'm down, it's a quick ego trip.
Other times I read stories that are both popular and very good, by my own standards. Yeah, sometimes I get envious. It's something that requires a lot of self-discipline to avoid ever becoming, I think. I feel like their characters are more engaging, their stories more exciting, their jokes funnier and more frequent, their worlds more consistent, their prose more poetic. Or maybe I'm just mildly terrified by how they can write three chapters a week of decent quality, somehow.

But I've been trying to be proud of what I CAN accomplish. I wrote twenty chapters. That's not nothing. I've stuck with an original story for maybe 200 pages, after struggling to stick to even a fanfic that long for several years. That's incredible. Someone told me they really enjoy my character voices. That makes me feel warm and fuzzy.
I knew going in my story wouldn't be very popular for a number of reasons, being a rather niche-y story. But maybe it can still find its niche.
 
D

Deleted member 84247

Guest
I try not to. I end up doing so anyways.

Quality is subjective and won't always guarantee success. Sometimes things succeed specifically because they're bad, and everyone wants to watch the trainwreck. Or it's a work that's just mediocre, but because it doesn't require deep thought and is reasonably exciting, it takes off in popularity. Sometimes I compare myself to those authors, and assure myself that even if I'll never get as popular as them, I've written a better story than them by my own standards. When I'm down, it's a quick ego trip.
Other times I read stories that are both popular and very good, by my own standards. Yeah, sometimes I get envious. It's something that requires a lot of self-discipline to avoid ever becoming, I think. I feel like their characters are more engaging, their stories more exciting, their jokes funnier and more frequent, their worlds more consistent, their prose more poetic. Or maybe I'm just mildly terrified by how they can write three chapters a week of decent quality, somehow.

But I've been trying to be proud of what I CAN accomplish. I wrote twenty chapters. That's not nothing. I've stuck with an original story for maybe 200 pages, after struggling to stick to even a fanfic that long for several years. That's incredible. Someone told me they really enjoy my character voices. That makes me feel warm and fuzzy.
I knew going in my story wouldn't be very popular for a number of reasons, being a rather niche-y story. But maybe it can still find its niche.
Somehow my stories end up gaining decent traction on this site, but I don't think I am a very good writer. I just write what is trendy and easy.
 

StainedGlassThreads

Well-known member
Joined
May 25, 2022
Messages
35
Points
58
Somehow my stories end up gaining decent traction on this site, but I don't think I am a very good writer. I just write what is trendy and easy.

Regrettably, if I try to write something that's trendy and easy, there's a 70% chance my brain shuts down and refuses to write until I make it significantly more complex and difficult. XD There's a good reason I don't get very popular while others do, and whether you believe you're a good author or not, you've gotten this far for a reason, and there's no reason you can't improve.
You may also find it encouraging that I believe having or being a decent editor is a lot more important than being a good writer. Keep things consistent, coherent, and legible, and that's all that's really necessary.
 

AuntieMaysLittleCousin

Level 73 Practical Procastinator
Joined
Nov 4, 2022
Messages
152
Points
43
I do, I try to criticize as harsh as I can someone else's story and then I look for every single critic that can also be applied to my own story. I also look for comedy stories and try to compare the funny bits between them and my own story.
 

Kidd_Wadsworth

Active member
Joined
Sep 29, 2022
Messages
113
Points
28
No. I don't compare my work.

What I do is read great work and ask myself how did the author elicit that emotional response in me. Then I try the same technique in my own work.

--Kidd
 

DireBadger

Fanatical Writer
Joined
Nov 22, 2022
Messages
525
Points
133
I Only compare myself in words written per hour.
I beat almost everyone else :)
 

ACertainPassingUser

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 12, 2022
Messages
1,102
Points
153
Even if they rejected, they will always compared themselves to other at some point.

It's only matter of what to compare and what to do with the comparison result.
 

Thekherham

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 18, 2020
Messages
44
Points
48
If I were to compare myself to other authors I should be writing horror novels since I read a lot of Stephen King.
 
Top