Search results

  1. TheIcMan

    Feedback wanted for first few chapters of unposted story

    Wait what? Since when are first person pov's always supposed to be making the reader the main character? Have I been reading wrong? Was I supposed to be like "ah yes, I am Katniss Everdeen" or something? Because from a cursory glance of the prologue, shit looks proper. Better than the usual...
  2. TheIcMan

    Feedback wanted for first few chapters of unposted story

    Hmm. Gotcha. I feel like it'd be a much easier read if you named the two girls immediately: That way it's easier to associate the pronouns with actual characters rather than some void blob of words and ideas. Also that entire paragraph bit for the synopsis is awkward. The latter sentence feels...
  3. TheIcMan

    Feedback wanted for first few chapters of unposted story

    Yeah I'm confused with the pronouns. Is Thomas they now because he's two girls or what?
  4. TheIcMan

    Warning to all Authors, do not fall victim to "professional editors."

    Oh, yeah, this is what I got with Tapas like 10 years ago. Had a very convincing email sent to me about signing me up for a contract. Good thing 16-year-old me was a coward!
  5. TheIcMan

    [Feedback Request-First-timer] Does my opening hook work? (First 3 chapters)

    >me when i want to read, but the god damn page is nuked
  6. TheIcMan

    Deep POV Story

    Ehh, I really feel like this is just a level of experience you need to have. Frankly, I just have umbrage with "deep" being a new word for a concept that already exists :sweat_smile: But also, if we're using this "deep" word, then I don't think you're doing it at all. Here's the usual...
  7. TheIcMan

    Is This Chapter 1 Good Enough? (Part 2)

    Read enough slop and you appreciate even things that do stuff just decently :blobrofl:
  8. TheIcMan

    Is This Chapter 1 Good Enough? (Part 2)

    Oh nice. Hmmmm... Okay for rating: Two things. If the last two sentences weren't there, it'd be an 8/10. Otherwise it reads pretty cringe personally. Like 99% of the time lines like that are completely unnecessary. Another thing is I'd forgive it more if you continued on the events after, but...
  9. TheIcMan

    Would love your feedback, reviews, rating and criticism

    on god??? genuine question here: was AI used at all in this response. because good lord is it a night and day difference from the asinine output chatgpt gave you in this entire thread. you actually sound human! (as long as it didn't get a train run on it by mr. ram-stealer, and if it did and it...
  10. TheIcMan

    Would love your feedback, reviews, rating and criticism

    which is the crux of the issue. being afraid to make mistakes and being ashamed of it is fine. but own up to it. people will make fun of you, sure, but you'll be earnest and people can respect that. AI-ify it, and all respect goes out the window. we all start from somewhere. mtl'ing your own...
  11. TheIcMan

    Would love your feedback, reviews, rating and criticism

    Ah yeah, when like half of the posts are AI written and try to pass it off as not? Yep. Hell on earth I say. It's funny mr. OP hasn't responded to me yet. Because I will throw ad hominems at AI """writers""" every chance I get. Or are AI """writers""" incapable of knowing what an ad hominem...
  12. TheIcMan

    Would love your feedback, reviews, rating and criticism

    you talk like chatgpt for one. all of this sounds inhuman out the ass. "you're so right--it's such a cliche!" ??? holy lmao. out of anything else in this shit ass world, i don't want scribblehub falling to more ai slop.
  13. TheIcMan

    Would love your feedback, reviews, rating and criticism

    .....is this entire thread AI?
  14. TheIcMan

    I would love to receive feedback on my novel.

    Second on the Lira. I've fucked around with silly AI stuff, and that name comes up frequently under the right circumstances lmao
  15. TheIcMan

    Advice for my story

    Uhh wow. This is most definitely not for me because everything made me cringe LMAO. Dialogue, prose, setup. Felt exactly what 16 year old me would like, and yes, obviously that's the point given the age of the protagonist. But damn, I'm at the point in my life where I can't stand this...
  16. TheIcMan

    Just want a quick review for my novel

    Formatting needs some work, and so does the sentence structures. They're all the same long sentences with multiple parts.
  17. TheIcMan

    Oh thank you! Funny timing I come back and look at this page for the first time in a while lmao

    Oh thank you! Funny timing I come back and look at this page for the first time in a while lmao
  18. TheIcMan

    Prologue

    Fukou da? Man thinks he's Touma. So, there are a lot of these awkward reading sentences. Basketball that was stiff? Yeah, no, sorry. The first impression is already pretty poor because of that. Something like "I jumped out of my seat, stepped on a game controller, and hit my back on a stiff (as...
  19. TheIcMan

    Another Feedback Thread

    That is such an ingenious yet terrifying idea LMAO. I'd be too coward to post shit I wrote when I was 13.
Top