So you died, but instead of getting Isekai'd, you wake up in the body of a clone retaining all your memories. Is it really you, or is it a clone thinking it's you?
The rating system in SH is subjective. It's more about the tastes of SH users rather than whether the writing is good or not.
If someone disliked your book, they will just leave you a bad rating and that's it.
If someone hated your book, they will try to express their hatred by spamming...
There is no difference. It's just a matter of perspective. A pessimist would think the glass is half-empty while an optimist would think the glass is half-full.