Hmm
I like romance, action, magic, oh oh some mystery would be nice! I like a good mystery, haven't read one of those in a while.
I'm down for most genres really, except gore and edgy stuff.
Lay it on me, I'm open to trying new things
Mushoku Tensei (Jobless renincarnation) - Action, Magic, Mystery even adventure(isekai)...Mc is a bit perverted but it's character development and world building is Peak
A Silent Voice - Romance Movie (highly recommended if not watched)
Mob Psycho 100 - Action, Magic and the goal of MC is to confess but not romance driven. (HIghly recommended if you want to try comedy)
And The one anime with all genres you like - Sword Art Online(season 1 is extremely good but can't guarantee if you will like later seasons)
If you are up for a Visual Novel, then When the Seagulls Cry is a great mystery romance. For the best experience I recommend using the Umineko Project mod while playing. It gives full voice acting and animated sprites. The steam version, to my knowledge, doesn’t have voice acting and the Mangagamer version has no voice acting and the og sprites.