Would you exile anyone from the island? (Poll)

[minacia]

So in this setting, you have become the demigod of a small island floating in space.​

​

The way this island works is that there are constantly souls being transmigrated into your world, at approximately the rate of a dozen random people every day. These souls are perfectly random, consisting of almost every human who has existed or will exist on Earth (past, present, and future).​

​

As a demi-god, you can do virtually anything (i.e. create matter, grow plants, build a city, add sheep) except create new sentient life. The only way to add sentient life to your island-world is to wait for transmigrators to stumble across your pocket of space.​

​

Everything has been fine and dandy... except not everyone who shows up on your island suits your tastes. For example, think of the Internet -- how often do you encounter someone toxic or someone you hate? There is bound to be transmigrators that you dislike. Some people will be hyper-conservative, hyper-progressive, or even come from different time periods from you (i.e. you could get someone from Victorian-era England or Feudal Japan).​

​

You have the magic ability to kick anyone you want off the island.​

1. How often will you exclude people from your island?

2. Do you consider yourself very tolerant of people?

3. What are the pros and cons of inclusivity vs. exclusivity?

4. How would you try to make/design your island?

 

[KuroYousei]

First of all, do space sharks exist to eat the people you expel from the island, or do they just drop into an endless void and vanish? And secondly, since sheep are apparently not considered sentient life in this setting, can't you just take someone's soul and put it into the sheep? It seems like a much better option than just kicking them off the island.

 

[FDSIO]

1) Most of the time.

2) No.

3) Wut!?

4) Waifuland! Whoever is not my waifu, out! My island, my rules!

EDIT:

Also, for fairness sake, I will create something named ’waifu scholarship’ were people not introduced to the term can learn and train to be my perfect waifus. Umu, umu. There will be a test at the end of it so they shouldn't take it for granted either. Umu, umu.

Ah, but the guys can go to the void... Catapult them into the closest sun or something... yeah.

Oh, and how could I forget about it... Maids! A lot of them muhahaa... Ehem, ehem, ok everyone. The ones who fail the ’waifu exam’ can apply for being maids! Genius. Umu, umu.

 

[Discount_Blade]

2) No.

3) Wut!?

4) Waifuland! Whoever is not my waifu, out! My island, my rules!

EDIT:

Also, for fairness sake, I will create something named ’waifu scholarship’ were people not introduced to the term can learn and train to be my perfect waifus. Umu, umu. There will be a test at the end of it so they shouldn't take it for granted either. Umu, umu.

Ah, but the guys can go to the void... Catapult them into the closest sun or something... yeah.

Oh, and how could I forget about it... Maids! A lot of them muhahaa... Ehem, ehem, ok everyone. The ones who fail the ’waifu exam’ can apply for being maids! Genius. Umu, umu.

Snorted hard at waifu scholarship XDDD

 

[CupcakeNinja]

So in this setting, you have become the demigod of a small island floating in space.​

​

The way this island works is that there are constantly souls being transmigrated into your world, at approximately the rate of a dozen random people every day. These souls are perfectly random, consisting of almost every human who has existed or will exist on Earth (past, present, and future).​

​

As a demi-god, you can do virtually anything (i.e. create matter, grow plants, build a city, add sheep) except create new sentient life. The only way to add sentient life to your island-world is to wait for transmigrators to stumble across your pocket of space.​

​

Everything has been fine and dandy... except not everyone who shows up on your island suits your tastes. For example, think of the Internet -- how often do you encounter someone toxic or someone you hate? There is bound to be transmigrators that you dislike. Some people will be hyper-conservative, hyper-progressive, or even come from different time periods from you (i.e. you could get someone from Victorian-era England or Feudal Japan).​

​

You have the magic ability to kick anyone you want off the island.​

1. How often will you exclude people from your island?

2. Do you consider yourself very tolerant of people?

3. What are the pros and cons of inclusivity vs. exclusivity?

4. How would you try to make/design your island?

Anyone who isnt a hot women gets yote into space

 

[minacia]

First of all, do space sharks exist to eat the people you expel from the island, or do they just drop into an endless void and vanish?

Let's just say their soul passes on and goes somewhere else.

And secondly, since sheep are apparently not considered sentient life in this setting, can't you just take someone's soul and put it into the sheep? It seems like a much better option than just kicking them off the island.

You're basically a demigod, so yeah, if you want.

 

[UYScuti]

Number 4 will determine the answer to 1, 2, and 3

4. Let’s say my goal is to sell the best cabbages at the best prices within the known universe while maintaining a determined profit margin.

1. If you are detrimental to the bottom line, then you are booted off the island.

2. My people will be tolerant in this way. Person A is going to live their life, person B will live their life. They can interact with each other, or they can choose to not interact with each other. Person A will not tell Person B how to live your life, and vice versa. They coexist happily as long as they do not agress against each other or use my power to agress upon one another. If you violate this non-aggression principle, you’re off.

3. On my space island there can be many different opinions, thoughts, etc etc, as long as there is one goal. Our goal is to sell cabbage. Some may say we must focus on the soil. Others may say we need to focus on the amount of water, but the goal is the same.

The moment one group decides to change the goal, then they’re off.

 

[RepresentingCaution]

Ah, but the guys can go to the void... Catapult them into the closest sun or something... yeah.

I'll catapult the waifus to you, and you catapult the husbandos to me.

 

[CupcakeNinja]

I'll catapult the waifus to you, and you catapult the husbandos to me.

Whore

 

[Nahrenne]

So in this setting, you have become the demigod of a small island floating in space.​

​

The way this island works is that there are constantly souls being transmigrated into your world, at approximately the rate of a dozen random people every day. These souls are perfectly random, consisting of almost every human who has existed or will exist on Earth (past, present, and future).​

​

As a demi-god, you can do virtually anything (i.e. create matter, grow plants, build a city, add sheep) except create new sentient life. The only way to add sentient life to your island-world is to wait for transmigrators to stumble across your pocket of space.​

​

Everything has been fine and dandy... except not everyone who shows up on your island suits your tastes. For example, think of the Internet -- how often do you encounter someone toxic or someone you hate? There is bound to be transmigrators that you dislike. Some people will be hyper-conservative, hyper-progressive, or even come from different time periods from you (i.e. you could get someone from Victorian-era England or Feudal Japan).​

​

You have the magic ability to kick anyone you want off the island.​

1. How often will you exclude people from your island?

2. Do you consider yourself very tolerant of people?

3. What are the pros and cons of inclusivity vs. exclusivity?

4. How would you try to make/design your island?

I will preface this by saying: if I can do anything, except create new sentient life, then what's to stop me from altering the personalities of the transmigrated people, etc...if I wished to be so...tyrannical/dictatorial?

1. Never, since I can simply put the bad eggs in one place and...'punish' them, or 'teach' them a lesson, per se...
I'm thinking turn them into animals for the others to eat?
jk
>w>
<w<
2. Maybe?
I'd say I have patience, however that can wear thin over time and repeated straining.
3. No one's 100% happy.
Fake happiness/false freedom.
4. No idea.
I'd at least try and have food resources available.
>w<

X

 

[Mephi]

Realistically speaking, I'd establish laws with exile as punishment for serious crimes. Not whim.

Maybe tolerant? I don't like a lot of things, but just ignore what I don't like.

Exclusivity is a result of struggle for finite resources. As a demigod, there are no finite resources except friends and followers.

I'd make the island kind of like Aincraid, aka Sword Art Online. Different floors, different biomes.

 

[TRNRLogan]

Depends what happens when i exile them. Although like has been said realistically if they break a "law" then I'll do so.

 

[tyler89558]

I’d let natural selection do its work and laugh as everyone fights each other.

I’m not a good person.

 

[BenJepheneT]

Nah, I'll just reincarnate their souls as puppies. In China.

 

[Valmond]

If you are gonna exile anyone, do it ‘Total Drama’ style. ?

 

[CL]

1. How often will you exclude people from your island?
Answer: Why would I? I can create matter. Why don't I simply transfer their spirit into a tree or something of the like. I can have an Ent farm.

2. Do you consider yourself very tolerant of people?
Answer: Patient, not tolerant. I will wait for them to get their act together and show respect towards others (aka: behaving). If it takes too long to figure out what they have been doing wrong, I guess they'll have to take a time out and learn things the hard way (in the tree you go).

3. What are the pros and cons of inclusivity vs. exclusivity?
Answer: Behave or else learn the hard way towards patience (trees live a long time). I hope they won't take too long to process their problem with cooperating in our society or else I fear others may require lumber. Such projects like... Well, islands can be expanded with the "dike" process, but we don't require drying anything out (like water) for expansion purposes; we just require resources. The more people who arrive, the more resources are available.

4. How would you try to make/design your island?
Answer: Good question. I would leave that to those who arrive. I wouldn't make all the decisions on my own and credit those who have suggested great ideas. I would even reconsider my treatment towards "trees" if they had offered a better method towards reforming acceptable behavior.

 

[Laeyioun]

1. Depending on my planning

2. I can be. But if I think they're not contributing any good to anything I will avoid them. I also would dislike unforgivable people.

3. Neither should be done, it's best to have a mix of both

Meritocracy - every person who goes on the island has to prove themselves. By extensive testing and trials. Probably if I had the ability to create VR I would use it so I can push human nature to the limits and they won't die (also to not inflict traumas)

I'd also invent a tool to scan the person's true nature if there are unsuspecting actors. I will put my desired values in it. It will give me feedback based on the compatibility to my values.

The feedback will be {desirable - less desirable and less undesirable - undesirable - evaluate for expulsion}

Any person will get a rating based on the tests, but they will be demoted and promoted based on their actions. I won't filter out every bad thing because I would be just strangling them, but I won't allow corruption or ruining innocent's lives.

If they want to be promoted then they must toil based on what they can do.

Any grave crime, and additionally any psychos will be held on trial and expulsed (probably I will make an example, but the humans will
do it, before doing so)

4. Planning for everything regarding the future. Everything would be gradual, experimental, and moderate so it would be progressive and present and future oriented.

human-related issues like
plagues and medicine; sanitation, settlement, real estate and housing; governance, authority and system which would be probably voting that is educated and needed to be earned; mandatory education and correction facilities (probably with secular, open-minded, intellectual, and honest but capable values) to facilitate adapting to my world, instill the importance of not learning and not repeating past mistakes and mistakes in history, sort out time and culture differences, toxicity, xenophobia, extremism, sheep-thinking, addiction, discrimination, fanaticism, and other social issues. Critical thinking and creativity are the most important things to teach; population control; resources stock and procurement; transportation; entertainment and all things related to culture; wealth distribution and the like; establishing all sectors blah blah. I'll accept all genders, but every person must have a child, whether by conception, adoption, or artificially (I'm not sure of the future) and also having councilors for marriages, families, and parenting. Monogamy, polygamy, divorces, remarriages, annulment etc? I'll do my best, and leave the uncertain parts to the experts and let it be developed steadily ??

But there is no perfect government. I guess I would increase transparency in all actions in all sectors, and promote open-ness or honesty as much as possible in the culture and traditions so that problems can be solved given effort, while still being capable. Also, if there are invaders of course there would be training and protocol regarding that and their treatment. Also, there is no true equality in my opinion, but fairness in opportunities and in the system would be important in everything.

Of course I would do the thinking, but I would get help from professional humans. And I won't spoon-feed them but let them be capable of managing themselves and creating everything themselves together - creating a symbiotic relationship, a sense of belonging, and respect and admiration towards me. Maybe I will make a body that transcends human looks to inspire authority? But even if I talked about 'righteous' things, I would surely make the government continually improve, while putting hard rules for the benefit of me and me only - there would be no human rights, only humane values and actions, with corresponding punishment for breaking it.

Dealing with inevitable issues important to the world like industrialization, global-warming, conservation, recycling, instilling non-wastefulness, pollution, resource depletion regulation and recovery, disasters, terraforming and nature, gradual development and more unmentioned.

There would be more, but it is unneeded to be said here, nor can I think of more for now ?
Also though, psychologists and communities for everybody.

TL;DR - learning from earth's ingenuity and mistakes, and emphasizing the importance of progressiveness, open-ness, and not repeating history.

edit: Does the world have magic, cultivation, fantasy, supernatural stuff, systems, sci-fi rules etc.
Cause I would develop those, but technology as a priority.

 

[minacia]

I was thinking about this one more, and inclusivity is something that means a lot to me. Maybe I’m idealistic in some ways, but I really wish there is a way that everyone can stay.

Um... I sort of think that everyone is precious, as long as you spend enough effort to understand what it is that makes them work.

And then I think people can change, so I don’t think certain bad relationships have to last forever.

This is especially the case if I’m able to be a demigod that engineers the environment. Perhaps there is a way to get different kinds of people to sit together and see each other’s commonalities... at least, that’s sort of my naive hope.

So in short, my desire would be to make a place where everyone can get along, I guess.