Is Avatar the Last Airbender an Isekai Anime or a Xianxia Donghua?

[jabathehut]

At this point I just think that crown fall is shitposting.

Let this thread get drown.

 

[Deleted member 25151]

View attachment 2851

 

[Ral]

I guess crownfall just want to antagonize people? I guess I just ignore him then.

 

[jabathehut]

Sorry, but you're getting owned with facts and logic.

 

[AliceShiki]

The creators don't define what they create, if they did then we would pronounce "gif" as "jif".

You're right, the ones that define what they create are the publishers that set the genres, and the bookstores that sell the books.

Guess what? None of them used your out of place genre, because xuanhuan isn't a thing in Japan.

Just like how Xuanhuan isn't a thing in the West either. (Save for Webnovels from fans of the genre)

 

[jabathehut]

You're right, the ones that define what they create are the publishers that set the genres, and the bookstores that sell the books.

Guess what? None of them used your out of place genre, because xuanhuan isn't a thing in Japan.

Just like how Xuanhuan isn't a thing in the West either. (Save for Webnovels from fans of the genre)

So its an isekai?

 

[AliceShiki]

So its an isekai?

It is not.

 

[GeorgeHaufman]

This avatar is closer to isekai than ATLA. In fact this Avatar movie is basically SAO season 1 arch 2.

 

[jabathehut]

View attachment 2858
This avatar is closer to isekai than ATLA. In fact this Avatar movie is basically SAO season 1 arch 2.

That is not an isekai. The character is still alive in his main body, no reincarnation. It is new world so it is like VRMMO where the VRMMO is a real world, super overdone.

 

[GeorgeHaufman]

That is not an isekai. The character is still alive in his main body, no reincarnation. It is new world so it is like VRMMO where the VRMMO is a real world, super overdone.

this defeats your main point then because aang is still alive no reincarnation

 

[jabathehut]

View attachment 2858
This avatar is closer to isekai than ATLA. In fact this Avatar movie is basically SAO season 1 arch 2.

big office isekai is more like captain america 2 (he is also frozen in ice like aang from the isekai avatar)

 

[jabathehut]

this defeats your main point then because aang is still alive no reincarnation

No everyone thiniks the avatar is dead.

 

[GeorgeHaufman]

No everyone thiniks the avatar is dead.

THAT DOESNT MATTER

 

[jabathehut]

No everyone thiniks the avatar is dead.

Plus avatar is reincarnated hundreds of times through the avatars. Clearly reincarnated

 

[GeorgeHaufman]

Plus avatar is reincarnated hundreds of times through the avatars. Clearly reincarnated
View attachment 2860

that literally doesn't matter because its not even the same type of reincarnation.

 

[jabathehut]

that literally doesn't matter because its not even the same type of reincarnation.

so u admit its reincarnation

 

[GeorgeHaufman]

so u admit its reincarnation

yes but not the same general idea of reincarnation as most isekais of this type are based off of. ATLA reincarnation is based off of buddist beliefs

 

[jabathehut]

yes but not the same general idea of reincarnation as most isekais of this type are based off of. ATLA reincarnation is based off of buddist beliefs

XUANHUAN REINCARNATION IS BASED ON TAO WHICH IS BUDDHIST ITS THE SAME

 

[jabathehut]

 

[GeorgeHaufman]

XUANHUAN REINCARNATION IS BASED ON TAO WHICH IS BUDDHIST ITS THE SAME

idc about that i just dont think its an isekai