I'm perfectly happy with a slow burn opening. I might be getting to know things about the character that will serve me well later on, to know what makews him tick. Its like in music, an extended intro, typically lighter in theme, gives more "weight" to the piece. Andf so I tended to write like that.
this, however, does not make everyone happy. I was chastised, castigated, and damn near all but castrated for it on the site I came from. Everyone espoused basically the "fantasy fiction formula" (a real book, BTW) which basiucallyu states, with smarmy smug authority, mind you... you *must* put your character in peril, in the first paragraph. Preferably? In the first sentence! No exceptiopns!
that made all those agents and publishing houses that say they read the first page, and into the trash it goiies if it doesnt get somewhere right the fuck now and hook the reader immediately. print readers or even people that pay for e-books are more willing to wait a little to build up, but WN? by and large, no.
The theory of this comes from screenwriters, and it got applied to novels now. that said, in a movie? you see it a *lot* an opening action sequence with high stakes and drama. Then you get to the build up to the rest. other rules in the fantasy fiction formula are equally smug and smarmy. You're not tolkein, limit yourself as a new author to 200 perhaps 300 pages, tops. Its all the book equivalent of "dont bore us, get to the chorus... two and a half minutes, and bring it to an end. Done."
*shrugs*
so I started learning to make tighter paced novels. Now I have to go back and invent a "punchy" perilous first chapter, or no one wants to read it. otherwise i can't save an otherwise good story. It can feel as if the author is making a nine course big meal, and everyone is yelling at him to just whip up a happy meal so they can eat on the run. But? I want readers, so I'm forcing myself to adapt to this.
I like both. p[unchy opening, or slow burn where I get to learn about the character(s) a couple chapters that seem slice of life to me, but I'm probably learning things the author wants me to know. I feel as if everyopne has learned to yell "navel gazing!" just so they have something that sounds authoritative to be a critic about, sometimes.
last site I was on? This stuff is *mantra* and *dogma*. Here, I'm seeing I might have enough heretics around who will permit me to do such things, i don't know how to act. you guys might spoil me.