Resolved comments and reviews

[MariPRV]

Hi, sorry for my poor English, but I have to use Google Translate to write.

I wanted to know if anyone else has written a review, and if it only appears after logging in, but disappears when you don't use your personal profile.
First of all, I wrote a positive review over five days ago, and I still don't see it unless I use my profile.

Then I noticed I replied to an author's comment, pointing out that the story looks like it was written by AI, and every time I check my comment, it's gone. Initially, I thought I hadn't sent the first message correctly, so I replied a second time and even took a photo just in case. A few hours later, I checked and it had disappeared again.Was my comment deleted by the author, or is there simply a bug?

 

[Deleted member 206441]

Which novel?

 

[MariPRV]

Which novel?

The fall of imperial light: for comments (chapter 3)
Arcane chef: for review

 

[Corty]

Reviews need manual moderator approval before appearing. If you can't see it 48hours later, then report it as a bug. Otherwise, it has not yet been approved by the mod team.

 

[Alski]

Your comment is there and has been for 6 days already.

 

[MariPRV]

Il tuo commento è lì da ormai 6 giorni.

View attachment 40741

The first message yes, but my reply to the author is not there, rather the two messages since I sent a second one yesterday when I noticed that the first one had disappeared. I took the photo yesterday right after sending the message

 

[Alski]

Ah i found your problem, you used a phone to take a picture of your own computer screen.

 

[MariPRV]

Ah i found your problem, you used a phone to take a picture of your own computer screen.

Thanks, I know that too . But I wanted to know if my replies to the author were deleted or disappeared due to a bug.

 

[Alski]

Did you actualy write the comment in english or did you post it as Itallian.

 

[MariPRV]

Did you actualy write the comment in english or did you post it as Itallian.

are you saying now or the comment I left on chapter 3? why does it happen that even though I wrote it in English I then published it in Italian by mistake

 

[Alski]

are you saying now or the comment I left on chapter 3? why does it happen that even though I wrote it in English I then published it in Italian by mistake

The comment you left on chapter 3, you already fixed the one your posted in here.

 

[MariPRV]

The comment you left on chapter 3, you already fixed the one your posted in here.

It shows me written in English

 

[Alski]

It shows me written in English

Yea, but considering you are using auto translate to interact with this site you may of had it auto set.

 

[MariPRV]

in fact I cancelled it to check and it appears to be written in English, does it show you in Italian?

 

[Alski]

in fact I cancelled it to check and it appears to be written in English, does it show you in Italian?

No, google translate isnt smart enough to tanslate pictures by default, and since your comment isnt on the chapter itself we have no way of actualy checking.

 

[MariPRV]

No, google translate isnt smart enough to tanslate pictures by default, and since your comment isnt on the chapter itself we have no way of actualy checking.

Do you recommend trying to write the comment again in English and being careful not to publish it in Italian?

 

[Alski]

Do you recommend trying to write the comment again in English and being careful not to publish it in Italian?

I recomend getting to the point where you can navigate this site without google translate before making comments and reviews. While google translate is fine for casual back and forth banter between people its a little lacking when it comes to translating stories, especialy if they themselves have been translated from another language.

 

[MariPRV]

I'll tell you, if the story is well written with few mistakes I'll read it without any problems, obviously I'll never comment on the grammar for obvious reasons.
Anyway, problem solved. I think the messages in which I explained my impression to the author were deleted because they were considered trivial comments, even though I was actually pointing out the impression that had left me.