I'll rate your cover

[Pixytokisaki14]

I couldn't find the original cover

 

[PancakesWitch]

 

[Glitched]

 

[Hans.Trondheim]

You know the drill, time-traveling bro.

 

[Glitched]

You know the drill, time-traveling bro.

View attachment 30287View attachment 30288View attachment 30289View attachment 30290View attachment 30291View attachment 30292View attachment 30293View attachment 30294View attachment 30295View attachment 30296
View attachment 30297View attachment 30298View attachment 30299View attachment 30300View attachment 30301View attachment 30302View attachment 30303View attachment 30304View attachment 30305View attachment 30306
View attachment 30307View attachment 30308
View attachment 30309View attachment 30310View attachment 30311

Hans flexing on everyone I see.

 

[RepresentingWrath]

You know the drill, time-traveling bro.

View attachment 30287View attachment 30288View attachment 30289View attachment 30290View attachment 30291View attachment 30292View attachment 30293View attachment 30294View attachment 30295View attachment 30296
View attachment 30297View attachment 30298View attachment 30299View attachment 30300View attachment 30301View attachment 30302View attachment 30303View attachment 30304View attachment 30305View attachment 30306
View attachment 30307View attachment 30308
View attachment 30309View attachment 30310View attachment 30311

Supremely based.

 

[Jailbreak571]

I'm surprised no one haven't posted the scribble hub cover yet

 

[RepresentingWrath]

I'm surprised no one haven't posted the scribble hub cover yet

Do it.

 

[Representing_Tromba]

View attachment 30274

Really good contrast with eye catching effects. The title is a bit off center to the left and the font feels bland but the color is good. There's a lot of extra free space, which is okay.

4/5

Adding mine to the mix. Although, understandably, it probably doesn't make much since without reading the story.

Amazing concept and design. Well thought out contrast in both character design and between top and bottom. Well placed title with fitting font. The background is also wonderfully filled with pleasing art. I'm not a fan of AI but I get that we have to work with what we have.

5/5

Thank you!

Very eye catching characters but the color pallet of black, red, and grey makes most of it meld together. The title has a good font, color, and is well placed.

3.5/5

View attachment 30277
I made this thing in Canva btw

Props for using canva. I too enjoy turning celebrities into 2D dress up dolls.

The title is good and the color pallet is very eye catching. I'm gonna be honest though, I have no clue what is supposed to be happening here. It feels like an advertisement in the 90s. Is it an orb of clashing waves? .... it's a fushigi.

4/5

View attachment 30280
It's for an insect hive queen story.

Denoting a point for lacking a title. There is room near the bottom for it. Absolutely gorgeous, otherwise! If this was on a shelf, I would pick it up.

4.5/5

4 years and still don't know the chicken and roosters are for. Love the title and color pallet. Could be easily chosen by cover alone.

4/5

I couldn't find the original cover
View attachment 30284

Decent cover. It fits the vibe of the title. Though the title is hard to read with the white-ish background. No unused space so good job.

3.5/5

 

[Rokuro-Sama]

Post your cover. I'll rate it. Super simple.

The "Ocean" Samurai's Reincarnation

 

[Representing_Tromba]

View attachment 30285View attachment 30286

#1 very good color pallet with eye catching elements throughout. Zero wasted space. Title is clear with a good font and color. Would probably see on trending.

5/5

#2 Same as the 1st with the color pallet and eye catching elements. Used the space well with a clear title, good font, and color. Though I'm not sure who the ice dragon is supposed to be as neither character fit that descriptor. Though if it's the villian, or if Ice Dragon is a title, I can understand.

4.5/5

Love the use of various colors in the title to contrast the Grey's and whites of the character and background. Though the font for Project Ninety Seven is a bit hard to read despite looking really cool.

4.5/5

 

[NotaNuffian]

I see tits.

I like.

But most likely will not step in due to how many bloody times getting catfished.

 

[TASTYLEADPAINT]

 

[Zinless]

Thanks in advance for the feedback! A friend did the art, but I made the title/logo (I also made @/Glitched's title/logo.)

 

[QuercusMalus]

Going for a Lighthearted Teen Slice of Life Romcom. I think I nailed it.

 

[Representing_Tromba]

You know the drill, time-traveling bro.

View attachment 30287View attachment 30288View attachment 30289View attachment 30290View attachment 30291View attachment 30292View attachment 30293View attachment 30294View attachment 30295View attachment 30296
View attachment 30297View attachment 30298View attachment 30299View attachment 30300View attachment 30301View attachment 30302View attachment 30303View attachment 30304View attachment 30305View attachment 30306
View attachment 30307View attachment 30308
View attachment 30309View attachment 30310View attachment 30311

#1 3/5
#2 4/5
#3 3.5/5
#4 4/5
#5 4/5
#6 4.5/5
#7 3/5
#8 4.5/5
#9 5/5 You can see a major shift in the color styles between 9 & 10 that really makes it stand out more to the naked eye.
#10 5/5
#11 4.5/5
#12 5/5
#13 4/5
#14 4.5/5
#15 6/5
#16 4.5/5
#17 4/5
#18 3/5
#19 4.5/5
#20 4.5/5
The other world series has some really good art as well as a great story that fits with the style. Sorry I couldn't spend more time on it. There was a lot a once. Well placed titles and fonts.
#21 5/5
#22 3.8/5
#23 4/5
#24 4.5/5
#25 5/5
These last three are beautiful! Absolutely stunning and worthy of a museum exhibit of phenomenal artwork

 

[Hans.Trondheim]

#1 3/5
#2 4/5
#3 3.5/5
#4 4/5
#5 4/5
#6 4.5/5
#7 3/5
#8 4.5/5
#9 5/5 You can see a major shift in the color styles between 9 & 10 that really makes it stand out more to the naked eye.
#10 5/5
#11 4.5/5
#12 5/5
#13 4/5
#14 4.5/5
#15 6/5
#16 4.5/5
#17 4/5
#18 3/5
#19 4.5/5
#20 4.5/5
The other world series has some really good art as well as a great story that fits with the style. Sorry I couldn't spend more time on it. There was a lot a once. Well placed titles and fonts.
#21 5/5
#22 3.8/5
#23 4/5
#24 4.5/5
#25 5/5
These last three are beautiful! Absolutely stunning and worthy of a museum exhibit of phenomenal artwork

Thanks for this. I've always wondered about the impression of others with the covers I made, so this is still a good feedback.

(As I am a teacher, I computed the average score of all the covers (the Saint Series) and got a 4.25 rating, which is good for me.)

Hans flexing on everyone I see.

Nope. I don't. Even if it looks like it, it's not my intention.

I want to know the impression of others on the covers I made for my own work, just to see if I can still effectively 'attract' readers. Many would say my art style looked 'retro anime' nowadays, see?

 

[lambenttyto]

I just made this one.

 

[Representing_Tromba]

The "Ocean" Samurai's Reincarnation
View attachment 30312

Denoting a point for lack of title. Could easily see it in the top right behind her head. Most of the space has been used so good job there. This doesn't tell me much about the story other than give me a character design and a the local fauna. Good art but her left knee and hands are a little off.

3/5

Thanks in advance for the feedback! A friend did the art, but I made the title/logo (I also made @/Glitched's title/logo.)

The title, logo, and color pallet are great. Thecontast between blue/white/purple and yellow/white/brown on the left and right are wonderful. Eyes could be lined up better but that isn't a big issue. The author/illustrator and volume number make it feel like a published light novel.

4./5

Going for a Lighthearted Teen Slice of Life Romcom. I think I nailed it.




View attachment 30323

I was gonna say that this fits the perfect vibe of an early 2000s thriller/horror novel but now that you say it's a teen slice-of-life romcom, I think I may need to rethink this. Color contrasting the face and splatters is well done for horror. for slice-of-life romcom, I would put a PNG flower on her hair and lighten the red shading.

thriller/horror 4.5/5
slice-of-life romcom 1.5/5

I just made this one.

I love it. The cover is very traditional. This is a personal bias so you don't have to take this to heart but I am not a fan of having the author's name being bigger than the title because it draws your eyes to that before the title itself. I can understand for marketing your brand but it can be very annoying for potential readers picking it up to read the title. Otherwise, it seems perfect.

4.5/5

 

[LesserCodex]

I used Seaai art, thankfully it's free and got pretty good results from it.