Editing Help with 1st Chapter

Nolff

An attractive male of unspecified gender.
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
2,125
Points
153
I need general help with the 1st chapter for my LitRPG to make it more appealing. At the moment I think it sets a grim tone well but I am looking for suggestions to streamline it and make it flow better. Thank you.

Here it is;

https://www.scribblehub.com/read/1083725-im-the-villain-but-so-what-grimdark-litrpg/chapter/1083761/
No one's gonna bother looking, though some caring people would peek in.

Tips from me, learn English more thoroughly. Also, use Grammarly.

Just from the title alone, I (as a reader) can already guess that your novel isn't promising.

Even if the idea's good, your novel's title is what the readers going to see first. And guess what? You made a mistake when you put a title on your novel.

What's the mistake?

Figure it out yourself. Or, well, give up and I'll explain what was wrong.
 

tobascoasako

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2022
Messages
82
Points
58
No one's gonna bother looking, though some caring people would peek in.

Tips from me, learn English more thoroughly. Also, use Grammarly.

Just from the title alone, I (as a reader) can already guess that your novel isn't promising.

Even if the idea's good, your novel's title is what the readers going to see first. And guess what? You made a mistake when you put a title on your novel.

What's the mistake?

Figure it out yourself. Or, well, give up and I'll explain what was wrong.

Thank you.
 

greyblob

"Staff Memeber" pleasr
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
2,743
Points
153
Why do you feel the need to change this? The chapter seems fine to me. A bit lengthy but otherwise okay.

However if we're talking from a genre pov, three fourth of it is pretty much filler. Isekai novels usually start by dying and meeting the diety or straight from the new world. Origin/backstory is considered a prologue.
 

tobascoasako

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2022
Messages
82
Points
58
Why do you feel the need to change this? The chapter seems fine to me. A bit lengthy but otherwise okay.

However if we're talking from a genre pov, three fourth of it is pretty much filler. Isekai novels usually start by dying and meeting the diety or straight from the new world. Origin/backstory is considered a prologue.
Thank you. Just deciding on where to trim it down. Or would it be better to start from chapter 2 and have it go back to that as a memory sequence or something?
 
Last edited:

greyblob

"Staff Memeber" pleasr
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
2,743
Points
153
Thank you. Just deciding on where to trim it down. Or would it be better to start from chapter 2 and have it go back to that as a memory sequence or something?
had a similar discussion about this very subject with @KoyukiMegumi on here

tldr: a short intro about their past or getting straight into the action is better than ch1 being a backstory imo
 

Tempokai

The Overworked One
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
1,392
Points
153
It has good enough quality for being a webnovel, so don't worry much. Here's AI, but it just really nitpicking imho:
Here is a comprehensive analysis and suggestions for improving the narrative flow and making it more appealing:

Analysis​

1. Introduction:

  • The opening quote sets a grim and epic tone, which is effective for a LitRPG genre. It establishes the stakes and provides background information.
2. Transition from Dream to Reality:

  • The transition from the dream world to reality is smoothly done, capturing the protagonist's thoughts and feelings effectively.
  • The use of sensory details (sound of the city, cold breeze) immerses the reader in the scene.
3. Character's Daily Life:

  • The protagonist's mundane morning routine juxtaposed with the vivid dreams creates a strong contrast.
  • Describing the financial struggles and messy room effectively portrays the character's current life situation.
  • The internal monologue about the dreams and financial woes adds depth to the character.
4. Park Scene:

  • The park scene provides a serene contrast to the earlier urban setting.
  • The interaction with the ducks adds a touch of whimsy and normalcy before the story transitions to more fantastical elements.
5. Lecture Hall Scene:

  • The description of the lecture hall and the protagonist's daydreaming serves to highlight his disconnect from reality.
  • The detailed observation of the girl in the lecture hall adds a touch of personal interest and potential subplot.
6. Supernatural Encounter:

  • The sudden shift from reality to the supernatural is jarring, in a good way, reflecting the protagonist's confusion and fear.
  • The introduction of the goddess Avaria and the subsequent encounter with the malevolent entity are well-crafted and intense.
  • The dialogue with the entities conveys a sense of epic importance and establishes the protagonist's role in the unfolding events.

Suggestions for Improvement​

1. Streamlining the Narrative:

  • Trim Excess Details: While the details enrich the narrative, consider trimming some descriptions that do not directly advance the plot. For example, the detailed description of the books and the exact contents of the fridge could be condensed.
  • Focus on Key Moments: Highlight the most important scenes (e.g., the dream, the supernatural encounters) by reducing the emphasis on less critical moments.
2. Enhancing Pacing:

  • Balance Description and Action: Ensure a balance between descriptive passages and action to maintain reader engagement. The current chapter has a good mix, but some descriptive parts could be more concise.
  • Use of Cliffhangers: Consider ending scenes with subtle cliffhangers or hints of what's to come to keep readers invested.
3. Character Development:

  • Internal Conflict: Delve deeper into the protagonist's internal conflict about his mundane life versus the vivid dreams. This can provide a richer psychological layer.
  • Dialogue: Introduce more dialogue earlier in the chapter to break up the prose and reveal character traits through conversations.
4. Clarity in Supernatural Elements:

  • Clear Descriptions: Ensure that the supernatural elements are described clearly but not overly explained. The reader should feel the protagonist's confusion but still grasp the essential details.
  • Foreshadowing: Introduce subtle foreshadowing of the supernatural elements earlier in the chapter to prepare the reader for the shift.

Revised Excerpt​

Here is a revised version of a portion of the chapter to illustrate the suggestions:


Original:

A cold breeze played across from the open window, bringing with it the sounds of an awakening city. The radio blared out the morning news, the announcer's sonorous voice filling the emptiness of my small room and waking me.
Revised:

A cold breeze slipped through the open window, carrying the sounds of the awakening city. The radio's morning news filled the emptiness of my small room, stirring me from sleep.

Original:

Staring into the mirror, my mind turned once more to the dreams; how stimulating would it be to live in a world like that?
Revised:

As I stared into the mirror, my thoughts drifted back to the dreams. How exhilarating it would be to live in a world like that.

Original:

Moving to the door to leave, I noticed a new letter from the management company of the building. I already knew it was going to be asking me to pay this month’s rent which was already two weeks late.
Revised:

At the door, I noticed a letter from the building management. Another reminder to pay the overdue rent, no doubt.

Original:

The history lecturer’s loud voice, as it had done so many times in the past, brought me back to my current reality. I tried to focus on his words, but my mind began to wander again.
Revised:

The history lecturer's booming voice snapped me back to reality. I tried to focus on his words, but my mind drifted again.

Original:

A voice rumbled with laughter which betrayed an infinite slowness of eons and had the volume of a meteor impact.
Revised:

A rumbling laugh echoed, timeless and powerful, like a meteor impact.

By streamlining the prose, enhancing pacing, and focusing on key elements, the narrative flow can be significantly improved while maintaining the rich details and immersive world-building essential to a LitRPG story.
 

tobascoasako

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2022
Messages
82
Points
58
Thanks everyone, I am just going to straight into the new world and have the backstory in a later chapter. This way also keeps a bit more of the mystery! thanks guys
 
Top