Forum Mafia: Nichijou version(Day 3) Mafia Victory

Nifty

Member
Joined
May 26, 2024
Messages
5
Points
13
Edit: I saw the explanation you gave, it felt a little awkwardly pieced together (which is fine D1) but apart from that, and you voted for the only option that would tie the votes and have and place someone else on the table as an option too. That's why I called it opportunistic.
 

Nifty

Member
Joined
May 26, 2024
Messages
5
Points
13
I still think FBI is suspicious. She has been putting me on top or close to the top of the sus list but hasn't really been willing to vote on it.
 

Nifty

Member
Joined
May 26, 2024
Messages
5
Points
13
"dare"? XD Not bonking you makes sense, because you are already sus for the lack of quality content. Nifty has so much content and is quite steady, there is no reason NOT to NK Nifty. + Lore is the reason why I lived last phase. I would certainly take that as taking my side.
Saying that "Nifty is super sus if not dead by D2" probably didn't help in that regard, speaking of which, this also feels like you've been leading up to a push on me for this reason since D1. There's also a possibility that mafia is taking advantage of this to let us both live and fight it out among ourselves but I'm leaning towards the first case.
 

FBI

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2021
Messages
6
Points
53
I still think FBI is suspicious. She has been putting me on top or close to the top of the sus list but hasn't really been willing to vote on it.
I was gonna vote you as well, but then I would have literally voted for every other player because of my indecisiveness and its quite embarrassing to refrained.

Saying that "Nifty is super sus if not dead by D2" probably didn't help in that regard, speaking of which, this also feels like you've been leading up to a push on me for this reason since D1. There's also a possibility that mafia is taking advantage of this to let us both live and fight it out among ourselves but I'm leaning towards the first case.
I have because both you and GoodPerson have been so unreadable. And I felt if I didn't push you, you'd relax a bit and I could catch you, somehow.

Plus, I clearly made that statement saying *if* I townread GoodPerson. If I townread you instead, then GoodPerson would be sus for being alive D2.

But none of that matters, because we didn't get a flip D1 anyway.
 

FBI

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2021
Messages
6
Points
53
I don't have a strong reason to suspect GoodPerson. But there is not a strong reason to believe them either.

Nifty is joining my strong townlean alongside LuoirM.

There is only GoodPerson left. Nifty's posts and actions are way more believable in comparison.

---

First, GoodPerson townread Nifty for their read list (in which they were town?). Other than that, they haven't vocalized their impressions about others.

Then, they admit that they would target the most towniest person. Lore was towny to me and Nifty. Which brings the question of whether a mafia would be so open about this. A WIFOM which I will take.

And the fact that they haven't given their reads begs the question of if they are scared of retaliation so they are going the No Elim way.

---

LuoirM openly wanting another person to die so the choices get narrowed down is too weird for mafia.
 

FBI

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2021
Messages
6
Points
53
In the case that it's No Elim and I live N2:
- if Nifty dies,
I vote GoodPerson.
- if GoodPerson dies,
I vote Nifty.
- if LuoirM dies,
I vote GoodPerson.

Mafia, do with this information as you like.

Highly unlikely I get NKed, yall would have to lynch me. Most probable person to get lynched if we don't vote is LuoirM.
 

LuoirM

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 5, 2021
Messages
1,444
Points
153
LuoirM openly wanting another person to die so the choices get narrowed down is too weird for mafia.
I could be wasting time by not elim.voting and at night I won't bonk anyone either, keeping the numb at 4
 

FBI

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2021
Messages
6
Points
53
If I give GoodPerson the tentative townlean for making the effort before voting, then it boils down to Nifty and Luoir. If we lynch Luoir for memeing and they end up NOT being mafia, and Nifty lives to D2... maybe Nifty is mafia.
Now I know what you two were talking about. I completely forget I even posted this.

Obviously, if I went by this, then I would get rid of Nifty so I can push Luoir. (Or vide versa.) What can I do when both of you are alive? Make it make sense, gamers.
 

FBI

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2021
Messages
6
Points
53
I could be wasting time by not elim.voting and at night I won't bonk anyone either, keeping the numb at 4
True. I actually expected mafia to sleep N1. XD but surprise, surprise. Anyway, it's in our favor to get rid of someone toDay. So do your best to push and sus.
 

FBI

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2021
Messages
6
Points
53
Lynching is better than NK. So we are avoiding No Elim at all costs. You gotta vote someone no matter who, with good reason. Stop being passive, town.
 

FBI

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2021
Messages
6
Points
53
I am being led by the nose by mafia, I feel. I only feel paranoia (as GoodPerson correctly pointed out).

GoodPerson is so suspicious. I don't know if that's the right call tho.
 

Nolff

An attractive male of unspecified gender.
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
2,135
Points
153
I don't have a strong reason to suspect GoodPerson. But there is not a strong reason to believe them either.

Nifty is joining my strong townlean alongside LuoirM.

There is only GoodPerson left. Nifty's posts and actions are way more believable in comparison.

---

First, GoodPerson townread Nifty for their read list (in which they were town?). Other than that, they haven't vocalized their impressions about others.

Then, they admit that they would target the most towniest person. Lore was towny to me and Nifty. Which brings the question of whether a mafia would be so open about this. A WIFOM which I will take.

And the fact that they haven't given their reads begs the question of if they are scared of retaliation so they are going the No Elim way.

---
For this one, I'm changing my strategy. I'm voting for someone, soon enough.
Now I know what you two were talking about. I completely forget I even posted this.

Obviously, if I went by this, then I would get rid of Nifty so I can push Luoir. (Or vide versa.) What can I do when both of you are alive? Make it make sense, gamers.
I wish to establish an alliance.
Lynching is better than NK. So we are avoiding No Elim at all costs. You gotta vote someone no matter who, with good reason. Stop being passive, town.
Alright, alright.
I am being led by the nose by mafia, I feel. I only feel paranoia (as GoodPerson correctly pointed out).
Then can you trust me at least?

It's a high risk, but we'll never trust each other if no one attempts to get close.

Should I give you a detailed invitation or a straight-to-the-point one?
GoodPerson is so suspicious. I don't know if that's the right call tho.
It's false, I can assure you.
 

FBI

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2021
Messages
6
Points
53
For this one, I'm changing my strategy. I'm voting for someone, soon enough.

I wish to establish an alliance.

Alright, alright.

Then can you trust me at least?

It's a high risk, but we'll never trust each other if no one attempts to get close.

Should I give you a detailed invitation or a straight-to-the-point one?

It's false, I can assure you.
If you are giving me an invitation, do you mean you trust me? How come? What are your ideas for who is most probably mafia?
 

Nifty

Member
Joined
May 26, 2024
Messages
5
Points
13
Lynching is better than NK. So we are avoiding No Elim at all costs. You gotta vote someone no matter who, with good reason. Stop being passive, town.
I think we're in one of those rare cases where it's just not. We get to eliminate 1 option via night kill no matter who it is so it narrows it down. If we have a concrete option to go for I wouldn't say this but I actually don't think I'm confident enough on anyone being mafia that I would go for the game ending elimination now.
 

Nifty

Member
Joined
May 26, 2024
Messages
5
Points
13
I also just want to say that no PR's game is confusing to be in. There's no real information around to judge people based on, completely social which is *pulls out a handful of hair*.
 
Top