AI-Generated Music & Songs

[CarburetorThompson]

It’s funny that companies are all into defending ai art, writing, coding, but as soon as ai music becomes a thing they pull out every stop to get it shut down

 

[ElijahRyne]

More ‘Experiments’
https://suno.com/song/ed01dd80-6f87-4992-baa2-918b8564ff1d <- A bit to chill
https://suno.com/song/6c5b93e1-589a-46d2-97b2-009e3e42d108 <- Hmm… Good, but needs work.
https://suno.com/song/76303347-ae52-4918-bcf7-e05d8b38a4e8 <- Pretty good, don’t know if it is the correct vibe though…
https://suno.com/song/6a6bc9c8-93b0-4c2f-9a4d-a57319208f3d <- Good opening riff and chorus, strange execution of the verses.
https://suno.com/song/92729049-0541-46a2-94d8-d6c67e1ff81d <- A bit too melancholic
https://suno.com/song/8ff6b7c6-64d7-4150-9229-95f0800c3236 <- A bit too smooth jazzy, but it seems to get better the farther it goes.
https://suno.com/song/0a9e8476-c681-4d5c-86fc-aab6f8d456df <- Best so far this round, imo
https://suno.com/song/2f962d54-fdb1-4db3-bb9e-30b95c82dd32 <- Meh, not bad just meh
https://suno.com/song/0611111b-6e98-4805-9713-2a5348fbc9f0 <- IDK what to think of this one…
https://suno.com/song/f8790abc-0b1d-4175-9345-39ea3102eb9e <- A bit too aggressive imo

 

[gaylolis]

Tried it with Sax this time, overall it sounds pretty nice

Jazz Fusion

https://suno.com/song/a82aa037-3d29-4361-ad3f-759c6604024d

https://suno.com/song/dfd1d50e-7500-43a6-8c15-4a682c0c30ed

https://suno.com/song/c157b49e-6c57-4de2-af72-ca04ef841b6d

https://suno.com/song/a56397b1-a767-4e37-8f62-0812fde955c0

Prog Rock (kinda failed, still sounds like jazz fusion)

https://suno.com/song/5962d170-e2f2-4663-a9a3-936e0f2d8ce9

https://suno.com/song/c1147abc-0fdf-4ac2-84ab-c3df9a816501

Avant garde

https://suno.com/song/16c22b64-72be-4184-a7c6-4bb359d2a094 (this sounds somewhat very technical lol)

https://suno.com/song/edb273b4-ebd7-45c9-a7e4-a36502756145

Free Jazz

https://suno.com/song/977138c6-d880-475d-9cbf-739d5353d327

(this is where it starts to sounds proggy)

https://suno.com/song/1ca8e514-89b4-4ca6-97f2-6a5e97117df0

(overall solid composition from the AI, it does suck that it ends after a strong build up)

tl;dr: you can't separate sax and jazz, at least not for this model

 

[Nolff]

I haven't listened to AI-generated songs, and I think I prefer not to. It feels unauthentic.

 

[ElijahRyne]

I haven't listened to AI-generated songs, and I think I prefer not to. It feels unauthentic.

They are not the best songs, I say the ‘fun’ comes from the ‘creation’, and even that is only because I don’t want to unpack and turn on my laptop, and open up MuseScore.

 

[Nolff]

They are not the best songs, I say the ‘fun’ comes from the ‘creation’, and even that is only because I don’t want to unpack and turn on my laptop, and open up MuseScore.

Lol xD

 

[ElijahRyne]

More experiments:
https://suno.com/song/86176c4d-5955-46d9-853c-35d0ec874b2a <- Lacks energy
https://suno.com/song/93357016-fd7c-4595-a9e3-ff09a2006fd4 <- Slightly more interesting texturally than above, but still mediocre.
https://suno.com/song/0d523f6e-f49d-40e4-9e76-57b35603fa84 <- Getting better, but too cliche imo.
https://suno.com/song/6c19d3be-819b-452c-9360-434c49327cd3 <- Better, but a bit boring.
https://suno.com/song/e9abafd7-0d0c-47d5-9cb6-d452761a42a2 <- Feels like something is inherently missing, but it got the chorus similar to the original.
https://suno.com/song/ddf79ea6-5a41-4147-89fa-3bb1e45ab131 <- A bit too experimental…
https://suno.com/song/d5f87046-b21c-40d4-a941-93745548833a <- Getting better.
https://suno.com/song/d429354d-d386-427b-a2bd-b5d0787f5775 <- Good, but a bit too thin/flat imo.
https://suno.com/song/9f6a0c3a-c98b-45b3-9193-0eff4eb12b47<- I Did not expect this, 5/10
https://suno.com/song/f34ee1fe-a173-47de-9a26-637a85bd563d <- The best in this batch, by far imo. 6/10.
All of these fall flat of the original, 10/10, but what should I have expected…

Spoiler: Original

 

[gaylolis]

Trying the Jpop and Visual Novel arrangement with some unusual setups

https://suno.com/song/99aef81e-84f4-42c6-8a7d-64703c4a3f39 (sounds like standard jazz instead of jpop)

https://suno.com/song/6eec64ee-c74f-4ef9-829b-7fb6c6ed8b8d (sounds like the battle theme in visual novel)

https://suno.com/song/c0ed9866-cbd8-4bd6-9219-1fc84ebc65ca (i really enjoy how the intro turns to a jazzy breakdown)

https://suno.com/song/9bf85c28-304a-40ef-b062-b429f3ed7038 (the beginning sounds like death tone from rengoku teien, oh damn some singing got mixed up)

https://suno.com/song/3d1cf8af-5c58-49f6-b4cf-c277747d5b37 (i only kept the weird time signature for this one, doesn't really sound that weeby for me, but it'd be fucking epic theme for when the idiot friend steps up in a medieval or fantasy themed one)

https://suno.com/song/a286731e-a4c9-4b01-b92f-50ab36daade9 (same as above, but it turns out to be my fav arrangement on this batch. it goes hard from the first bars)

 

[MatchaChocolate69]

https://suno.com/song/99aef81e-84f4-42c6-8a7d-64703c4a3f39 (sounds like standard jazz instead of jpop)

So good the piano work

https://suno.com/song/6eec64ee-c74f-4ef9-829b-7fb6c6ed8b8d (sounds like the battle theme in visual novel)

Rpg Maker Batlle theme

https://suno.com/song/c0ed9866-cbd8-4bd6-9219-1fc84ebc65ca (i really enjoy how the intro turns to a jazzy breakdown)

Love the sudden change

https://suno.com/song/3d1cf8af-5c58-49f6-b4cf-c277747d5b37 (i only kept the weird time signature for this one, doesn't really sound that weeby for me, but it'd be fucking epic theme for when the idiot friend steps up in a medieval or fantasy themed one)

Funny theme

https://suno.com/song/f34ee1fe-a173-47de-9a26-637a85bd563d <- The best in this batch, by far imo. 6/10.

North Korean jazz

it sounds more like the backing track from the police songs

i feel canterbury scene is more like this

Are you by any chance a connoisseur of progressive rock? It's one of my favorite music genres. It's not easy to meet people who share this preference. Indeed, the AI's result doesn't much resemble classic Canterbury, but I didn't mind the outcome. For me, Camel is more representative of Canterbury:

this feels like the song that the backstreet boys don't want to release cuz it makes their teenage girl fans on suicide watch

I couldn't have described the song better!

A69
Heavy Metal, Nu Metal, Alternative Metal, Progressive Metal, Metalcore
A robust guitar solo using one of @gaylolis prompts.

sounds pretty djent

Indeed, I'm quite satisfied with the result. It would also make a good Boss Battle Theme.

Good lyrics, sounds nice. I made an account just to save to a playlist.
Would love some neoclassical or orchestral power metal. (not heavy metal)

I'm very glad you like it! I would like to try making some power metal pieces like Rhapsody of Fire once I've gotten a bit more practice with the AI.

I really like the sound of this one

Sorry Ane-San? It came out very well.

ok, imma have to try this suno thing out sometime. so weird when the song just ends.

We need dragon songs!

 

[gaylolis]

So good the piano work


Rpg Maker Batlle theme

Love the sudden change


Funny theme


North Korean jazz


Are you by any chance a connoisseur of progressive rock? It's one of my favorite music genres. It's not easy to meet people who share this preference. Indeed, the AI's result doesn't much resemble classic Canterbury, but I didn't mind the outcome. For me, Camel is more representative of Canterbury:

CAMEL discography and reviews

according to progarchives camel is described more as symphonic prog

there's also list of bands that fit under the canterbury scene

Canterbury Scene, a progressive rock music sub-genre

some of the prominent bands are caravan, khan, gong, hatfield and the north, national health and soft machine

i may describe it as a bri'ish men playing jazz fusion prog rock or maybe the jazzy prog rock that gives you the beatles vibe? they did have that unique vibe that's hard to describe lol

to your question, indeed i was an avid fan of prog, though i also listen to classical and jazz as well. camel is among the great bands, so you have a nice taste :D

the 70s bands are overall great but i don't really pick any favorites since a lot of them are great. i just listen to whatever sound fancy my ears.

if i name a few, i'd pick gabriel era genesis, gentle giant, camel, iq and big big train. a lot of their music are a hit for me.

Indeed, I'm quite satisfied with the result. It would also make a good Boss Battle Theme.

probably something like this, kinda giving dream theater vibes

 

[ElijahRyne]

Experiments
https://suno.com/song/9ba106e8-af1a-4fd4-96fd-8517dbf8c92f <- A bit aggressive
https://suno.com/song/0f65162a-adb4-42ac-98c3-27afface7452 <- Better than yesterday’s batch. 6.5/10
https://suno.com/song/c058dd5f-8fc2-4707-a4c1-abc62a04abf6 <- worse than above 5/10
https://suno.com/song/fb8eb4cf-ba47-45cd-87b1-5dded8edf3cb <- a bit better. 6/10
https://suno.com/song/2cc5bc0e-3af7-4aff-ba49-d2561cac2aa5 <- A bit off, but still good. 6.2/10
https://suno.com/song/0460f6ae-4780-477e-9023-1a5631ae9ce9 <- good instrumentals, but I can barely hear vocals. 6/10
https://suno.com/song/903fae0f-31a0-4f35-b1e2-945ad0f2851c <- A bit unique, but it drags. 5.4
https://suno.com/song/1af57c86-d933-40ab-b6bb-4cf732c228a5 <- Better 5.8/10
https://suno.com/song/3eda9182-8767-42ec-adb8-c32076f059f6 <- Best this batch 7/10
https://suno.com/song/326b7172-775f-4904-984b-57c1c76c47e8 <- Hmm… 6.2/10

 

[gaylolis]

just experiment with jpop songs, translate the lyrics at your own risk lol

personally just google tl'd them to jp and the contents are pretty unhinged

https://suno.com/song/6c301476-5f11-490d-ad80-b27aff36d390 (the story is about the girl's big brother turning to a girl but her pp were still big)

https://suno.com/song/aec977d2-c9ac-4e7e-97e3-a389b70bad3a (same song but different arrangement)

https://suno.com/song/5afb2ffb-4a38-42da-b1a7-19343123f37a (the fairy persuades a young man to become a loli for the sake of world domination)

https://suno.com/song/f3e88b90-fff7-4d54-9b23-8e25b8541042 (just different arrangement of the song above)

https://suno.com/song/fbbb91e1-8149-40a8-904d-df5c7afe30ee (unhinged rap about how society sucks after she failed to confess to girl she love, and how she wanted to start over by being a bald monk girl secretly cooking mixtapes)

https://suno.com/song/aebdceb9-789b-46b6-8db5-7c2834e4f1eb (different arrangement of above song)

also lol

did they really have anti nsfw filter on their lyrics? how tf these go through xD

 

[ElijahRyne]

‘Experiments‘
https://suno.com/song/535b7b8e-26a4-45dc-a8e2-5fdf86e4073b <- A bit too operatic, but still okay. 4/10
https://suno.com/song/611ed996-8294-4560-acea-d393863c3445 <- Feels antiquated, and too operatic. 3.2/10
https://suno.com/song/934a77a4-2874-4920-8a58-d2bb78a15bab <- Hard too hear the lyrics. 3.8/10
https://suno.com/song/459d3eed-8f23-4293-b790-3dbd64e1a6c1 <- Getting better. 4/10
https://suno.com/song/ad28661e-805c-4959-a391-4e5744e64886 <- Mediocre, but still an improvement. 4.2/10
https://suno.com/song/75040e80-633c-400f-97ee-310a10cfe80f <- Better. 4.8/10
https://suno.com/song/ab6261be-c55d-4412-8e4e-1eabc98103fb <- I don’t think my prompts are helping much… 5/10
https://suno.com/song/029f688d-66d7-44a5-a136-95e8e6719a86 <- I am changing directio. 4.5/10
https://suno.com/song/d0148e09-a4c7-4fe4-845e-fe29524e9b3d <- Better, but wrong vibe. 5/10
https://suno.com/song/9bbfb721-517a-4c2a-bd98-351bbafc1d02 <- Better, but a bit generic 5.4/10

I will continue this ‘experiment’ tomorrow, until I get a 7/10 or higher.

 

[gaylolis]

just some jpop singing gibberish

https://suno.com/song/1ac51ee7-aa2a-41a8-8c18-8d9a032d6e6d

https://suno.com/song/541d45d7-7378-40ba-a26e-4dc8a3a02f14

the rest i didn't post since i might get banned for it, so i tried to make it sing really perverted lyric in japanese and make it really close to speaking instead of singing

i had slightly successful result but i immediately deleted them after saving it lol

also, the nsfw filter might work mostly on the song title. i can get away with really pervy lyrics in jp (probably won't work if it's in english tho)

 

[ElijahRyne]

Continuing yesterday’s ‘experiments‘
https://suno.com/song/dc7985b3-aeb3-4f95-9ece-2f3e8f500bf9 <- Okay starting point. 5/10
https://suno.com/song/0f0823b8-8ac2-4d4d-a86c-01177ab301cc <- weak second verse. 5/10
https://suno.com/song/8977a33c-ca45-4194-9629-8736492c21ba <- to lackadaisical 4.8/10
https://suno.com/song/c74cc492-efcb-4f02-9989-09cbc472c478 <- Better. 5.2/10
https://suno.com/song/ed995851-5481-45dd-9931-97218280de0a <- Much better. 5.6/10
https://suno.com/song/ba6e66a0-3de5-487a-a2da-73632633ba72 <- Mediocre. 5/10
https://suno.com/song/f11136a9-8eef-40c1-919f-522698e8a250 <- A bit too psychedelic… 5.1/10
https://suno.com/song/67dabf8c-51e1-463c-8dd4-3b77c906b84b <- Weird and a bit too Beatles-y, but good. 6/10
https://suno.com/song/7c00229d-32c5-4f93-b829-ac5e22102923 <- Good beginning, mid mid, better end. 6.2/10
https://suno.com/song/825e2a50-4acc-45b5-aa92-391479b49fbf <- A bit muddy, at least texture wise. 5/10
Continuing tomorrow

 

[gaylolis]

i got lazy to write my own lyrics so i just went with the ones i got

still using jpop tag

https://suno.com/song/1af6ceb2-26fe-4a79-abc0-1964d508c220 (ride on time en ver)

https://suno.com/song/ae24c613-6feb-44e1-a146-2d0c6e2cc9ea (sekaiju no dare yori kito en ver, my fav among the others)

https://suno.com/song/48843afa-3328-481d-be6d-d1290f60ddc5 (ride on time using the original jp lyrics but in romaji, guess it also works)

i like how the engrish accent still get here even when they sing in english

 

[ElijahRyne]

Continued ‘Experiments‘
https://suno.com/song/471e0ed9-37ef-4ce8-b841-d32814999073 <- Okay. 5/10
https://suno.com/song/82eec482-ecd0-4470-8c59-e1da62b8250e <- Better. 5.4/10
https://suno.com/song/350f489d-1ed7-4573-b0c0-75ea098afee5 <- Strange. 5/10
https://suno.com/song/e3790236-38d8-4969-8a18-d5f721780f37 <- Mediocre. 5/10
https://suno.com/song/678c64de-be74-4a1c-ab49-903025b6e5c7 <- Better, I can swear the lead singer has a Russian accent. 5.5/10
https://suno.com/song/71c16403-79dc-4f73-a2da-7f5cd5f41e4d <- Better, a bit muddled. 6/10
https://suno.com/song/d1e03be8-0df8-4781-ade9-299cdcfb69d2 <- Meh… 5.2/10
https://suno.com/song/44dbc45d-cbe1-43c8-95d8-740d5bc9c36b <- Better, but a bit generic. 5.7/10
https://suno.com/song/5e6064d8-472b-46f1-ac04-f8b656a14f90 <- Lol, decided to just ignore my lyrics. 5/10
https://suno.com/song/e23c962b-30aa-4c49-8bf6-4b7ac00864c6 <- Not what I had in mind, lol. 5/10

Will continue with these lyrics until I get a 7/10.

 

[ElijahRyne]

Continuing the ‘Experiment’
https://suno.com/song/62311759-e9fd-4f20-b172-78ef7be0373a <- Too operatic. 3/10
https://suno.com/song/6d3807a0-a960-49a8-832d-0e59b040234b <- Too muddled and boring. 4/10
https://suno.com/song/b15dfdfa-0f52-4478-a4c9-4341da8d952d <- Better. 4.5/10
https://suno.com/song/f7aa29be-90d9-4a27-bc0a-56d4ed785244 <- Good intro, rest is Meh. 4.5/10
https://suno.com/song/2c65a19e-8a0f-47f8-b93f-b46955a233c7 <- Better. 4.7/10
https://suno.com/song/baa09944-6883-4307-a16e-1f53221e0408 <- Doesn’t fit the vibe of the lyrics. 4.5/10
https://suno.com/song/bc493e42-2ffc-469c-b147-b660f961b401 <- Better, a bit muddled, but still better. 4.9/10
https://suno.com/song/54583e8b-8cf7-486f-ab61-20eab67c5e98 <- Lol. 5/10
https://suno.com/song/bd8d5735-c088-49b0-9e4f-1139d186d34f <- Better. 5.2/10
https://suno.com/song/5b73e7a0-6214-4e23-935d-d8f0efdca631 Better. 5.7

I feel as if I am on the cusp of that 7

 

[gaylolis]

some more experiment

https://suno.com/song/9a2ae1cf-bfb1-4eb7-b512-87632e60ca07

https://suno.com/song/16d7cd48-b99a-4164-9c7f-0167c64f3adb

using the pinyin ver of super idol. even with jpop tags, though it sang the song as if chinese pop lol

==

this one with japanese lyrics (romaji of sekaijuu no dare yori kito, it now feels like jpop)

https://suno.com/song/d626e558-195f-4101-a91e-bf484b630f92

==

ride on time but using the prog rock prompt and some bits at the beginning, still sounds like jpop

https://suno.com/song/8fe5b6b6-2f83-4700-ae8c-9d9d2169e94a

https://suno.com/song/30d7acde-642c-4afb-b9c7-3205325096ad

==

Kimi Ga Suki Da To Sakebitai (Slam Dunk OP) tried with the prog rock as well, but it's also more like jpop

https://suno.com/song/7aebe272-53d3-4bf2-8a1b-902ec65b36fa

https://suno.com/song/2627488b-1f1b-486d-9db3-cff551488b57

==

sekaijuu no dare yori kito, but with jazz fusion prompt, Jpop sounding too. though the arrangement so far is my fav.

the time signature and major scale thing doesn't seem to work though.

https://suno.com/song/50fb694e-2e98-4f39-8eee-ecfe0642a80e

https://suno.com/song/236c37e5-e256-4174-9d48-e6780044c898 (now it starts to sound like jazz fusion)

==

tl;dr they didn't seem to recognize prog rock as musical style

the lyric language might play a bigger role for vocal songs than the musical setting in the start

 

[MatchaChocolate69]

CAMEL discography and reviews
according to progarchives camel is described more as symphonic prog

there's also list of bands that fit under the canterbury scene

Canterbury Scene, a progressive rock music sub-genre
some of the prominent bands are caravan, khan, gong, hatfield and the north, national health and soft machine

i may describe it as a bri'ish men playing jazz fusion prog rock or maybe the jazzy prog rock that gives you the beatles vibe? they did have that unique vibe that's hard to describe lol

I guess I made a mistake. Prog is so full of subgenres and scenes that it's easy to get confused sometimes.
You're right, I believe Symphonic Prog is an accurate description of Camel.
I wasn't aware of this site; it's a great source of references to explore. Thanks for sharing it!?

to your question, indeed i was an avid fan of prog, though i also listen to classical and jazz as well. camel is among the great bands, so you have a nice taste :D

the 70s bands are overall great but i don't really pick any favorites since a lot of them are great. i just listen to whatever sound fancy my ears.

if i name a few, i'd pick gabriel era genesis, gentle giant, camel, iq and big big train. a lot of their music are a hit for me.

A fellow prog enjoyer! ?
After all, classical music is the foundation of prog rock music, especially the more technical bands, and it has also been influenced by jazz. But then again, what hasn't been influenced by jazz?
I love Camel, but there are even more substantial bands that come before them. My absolute favorite band is Yes, and "Close To The Edge" is my all-time favorite album. It's a somewhat predictable choice, but it's objectively a timeless masterpiece. Following them are King Crimson and Genesis with Peter Gabriel.

My favorite pieces are "Starless" and "In The Wake Of Poseidon" (King Crimson), "Firth of Fifth" (Genesis), "Heart of The Sunrise" and "Close to the Edge" (YES).
Each of them interprets the genre in their own way, and every music is always a journey.

did they really have anti nsfw filter on their lyrics? how tf these go through xD

also, the nsfw filter might work mostly on the song title. i can get away with really pervy lyrics in jp (probably won't work if it's in english tho)

It wouldn't let me use the words "torture" or "?️iggas." I think the filter only works in English, judging by your songs in Japanese...

https://suno.com/song/71c16403-79dc-4f73-a2da-7f5cd5f41e4d <- Better, a bit muddled. 6/10

The choir makes it all epic.

https://suno.com/song/67dabf8c-51e1-463c-8dd4-3b77c906b84b <- Weird and a bit too Beatles-y, but good. 6/10

I like this folk-style version.

https://suno.com/song/6c301476-5f11-490d-ad80-b27aff36d390 (the story is about the girl's big brother turning to a girl but her pp were still big)

https://suno.com/song/aec977d2-c9ac-4e7e-97e3-a389b70bad3a (same song but different arrangement)

https://suno.com/song/5afb2ffb-4a38-42da-b1a7-19343123f37a (the fairy persuades a young man to become a loli for the sake of world domination)

https://suno.com/song/f3e88b90-fff7-4d54-9b23-8e25b8541042 (just different arrangement of the song above)

https://suno.com/song/fbbb91e1-8149-40a8-904d-df5c7afe30ee (unhinged rap about how society sucks after she failed to confess to girl she love, and how she wanted to start over by being a bald monk girl secretly cooking mixtapes)

https://suno.com/song/aebdceb9-789b-46b6-8db5-7c2834e4f1eb (different arrangement of above song)

The contrast between the lyrics and the music style really makes me laugh; they are all great experiments nonetheless. This AI performs really well in Japanese.

tl;dr they didn't seem to recognize prog rock as musical style

the lyric language might play a bigger role for vocal songs than the musical setting in the start

Maybe I've managed to create something that can be defined as prog? I figured out how to make longer songs, but it cost me quite a few credits.
Since you're an expert, maybe you can tell with your ear if it fits the genre. It's definitely experimental. I used several of your prompts for the instrumental parts, though I'm not sure if it followed them exactly.
I like the experiment, just a shame about a bit of noise.


COSMIC SKIES
Progressive Rock, Prog, Progressive Metal, Synthwave, Synth, Electronic, Organ, Ambient, Experimental,


By extending the songs, I've created a Jungle, Breakcore, Drum and Bass piece that's quite good and serves as the closing theme for the latest chapter I wrote for the Scribble Hub fan fiction. I really like the result.


A SIMPLE FANTASY
Female singer,Jungle, Breakcore, Synthwave, Synth, DnB, Electronic, Drum and Bass, Ambient, Experimental


To conclude, an R&B piece about a festival in honor of a daikon deity, trying to make use of the Japanese bamboo flute. The result is pleasing.


Shūkaku-sai
Shakuhachi, R&B