Which would be better?

OnmyoKirkir

Active member
Joined
Apr 30, 2020
Messages
2
Points
43
I have a few ideas for a story to actually start and hopefully finish, but I don't know which one to do. Also, in every option, the protagonist either starts as a deity or will become one quite quickly.
  1. A modern fantasy story where the protagonist was a human, turned into a deity-monster-thing
  2. A modern fantasy story where the protagonist was some sort of animal that is turned into a humanoid of that animal, and then gets granted divinity
  3. A science fiction story where the protagonist was an alien creature with basic thoughts that is granted several blessings from multiple deities
  4. An interactive story that is either modern fantasy OR science fiction where the protagonist is randomly generated and practically a lot of everything else is chosen by the readers
Which one sounds the most interesting/fun to read? If wanted, I can make any of the first four options interactive, if wanted. Anyway, thank you for reading this, if you have!
 

Succubiome

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 25, 2023
Messages
623
Points
133
I'd actually say not a pure #4-- you can leave up a lot of stuff to readers, but unless you start with some sort of prompt/focus it's actually harder to engage with.

#1 would probably be the best seed for an interactive story IMO from hearing those things alone.

Why do you wanna write about a deity, and what do you want to write about them? Which of the paths you could go supports that best?
 

TsumiHokiro

Just another chick in the universe
Joined
Nov 1, 2023
Messages
804
Points
93
I have a few ideas for a story to actually start and hopefully finish, but I don't know which one to do. Also, in every option, the protagonist either starts as a deity or will become one quite quickly.
  1. A modern fantasy story where the protagonist was a human, turned into a deity-monster-thing
  2. A modern fantasy story where the protagonist was some sort of animal that is turned into a humanoid of that animal, and then gets granted divinity
  3. A science fiction story where the protagonist was an alien creature with basic thoughts that is granted several blessings from multiple deities
  4. An interactive story that is either modern fantasy OR science fiction where the protagonist is randomly generated and practically a lot of everything else is chosen by the readers
Which one sounds the most interesting/fun to read? If wanted, I can make any of the first four options interactive, if wanted. Anyway, thank you for reading this, if you have!
3 does not sound sci-fi at all. It sounds fantasy. Good thing you're not making it.
 

J_Chemist

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 17, 2022
Messages
2,191
Points
153
#4 is something I see fail regularly. It requires a very active reader base that can support the weekly need from the Author. And there's just not enough people who care that will actually vote, to be honest. Unless, like Cupcake mentioned, you already have an established and active reader base that will actually cooperate. If you want to do something like this, then you should instead make it semi-interactive. Write your story and then occasionally allow the readers to affect the story. Maybe if the characters need to make a decision, you put up a poll and request the readers to influence the decision.

Otherwise, #3 without the deities would actually be pretty interesting. A sci-fi adventure that follows an Alien protag going through the bs of their existence. Maybe the Gods influence them but it's rather cliché for that. I'd find something else instead.
 

Representing_Tromba

Sleep deprived mess of an author begging for feedb
Joined
Jan 29, 2020
Messages
5,999
Points
233
#2 but make it an animal that is obsessed with things like crows and Shiny objects. Then you can explain through the story that all the other characters think they're autistic and their animal desires are their obsessions.
 

OnmyoKirkir

Active member
Joined
Apr 30, 2020
Messages
2
Points
43
#2 but make it an animal that is obsessed with things like crows and Shiny objects. Then you can explain through the story that all the other characters think they're autistic and their animal desires are their obsessions.
I might just do this one, based on the suggestions of the other people. If interactive stories fail without a large enough reader base, then I think I'll go with this one. Thanks for the help!
 

TsumiHokiro

Just another chick in the universe
Joined
Nov 1, 2023
Messages
804
Points
93
I might just do this one, based on the suggestions of the other people. If interactive stories fail without a large enough reader base, then I think I'll go with this one. Thanks for the help!
If you need people to interact with, you could try other places. Places where people are expected to interact with you. SH is not the place for interactive stories...
 

CupcakeNinja

Pervert Supreme
Joined
Jan 1, 2019
Messages
3,152
Points
183
#4 is something I see fail regularly. It requires a very active reader base that can support the weekly need from the Author. And there's just not enough people who care that will actually vote, to be honest. Unless, like Cupcake mentioned, you already have an established and active reader base that will actually cooperate. If you want to do something like this, then you should instead make it semi-interactive. Write your story and then occasionally allow the readers to affect the story. Maybe if the characters need to make a decision, you put up a poll and request the readers to influence the decision.

Otherwise, #3 without the deities would actually be pretty interesting. A sci-fi adventure that follows an Alien protag going through the bs of their existence. Maybe the Gods influence them but it's rather cliché for that. I'd find something else instead.
yep and people who like to plan out their stories might also experience more trouble because the choices add an extra dimension to the story and may require you to just adapt to the choices unless you deliberately narrow the options or at least tailor them to the character so nothing outrageous happens

I recall doing this once in a minor way. Told readers they can provide a backstory for a character and whichever got the most likes, i'd implement it. One guy basically took a character from another story of mine and made a fairly compelling tale regarding how that character went from an erotica to a high fantasy comedy. Ended up changing the entire direction of the story because of how that character and another interacted.

Gotta be careful is all im saying. I barely plan at all but i still got annoyed. I liked that character, too, but alas. I had to hit her and unfortunately an entire city with eldritch horrors. Really couldn't have gone any other way given the other party's personality
 

TsumiHokiro

Just another chick in the universe
Joined
Nov 1, 2023
Messages
804
Points
93
yep and people who like to plan out their stories might also experience more trouble because the choices add an extra dimension to the story and may require you to just adapt to the choices unless you deliberately narrow the options or at least tailor them to the character so nothing outrageous happens

I recall doing this once in a minor way. Told readers they can provide a backstory for a character and whichever got the most likes, i'd implement it. One guy basically took a character from another story of mine and made a fairly compelling tale regarding how that character went from an erotica to a high fantasy comedy. Ended up changing the entire direction of the story because of how that character and another interacted.

Gotta be careful is all im saying. I barely plan at all but i still got annoyed. I liked that character, too, but alas. I had to hit her and unfortunately an entire city with eldritch horrors. Really couldn't have gone any other way given the other party's personality
My condolences. But you asked for it.
 

Tempokai

The Overworked One
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
1,397
Points
153
Every idea can be good, but it's all about the execution. Most fun to me looks the 3, but 4 is close to it and it will be chaos you must mentally prepare AND have audience for.

Here's AI:
Oh, joyous day! A writer in the throes of decision paralysis, pondering which story to breathe life into from a quartet of equally promising yet likely-to-be-abandoned ideas. How novel, how utterly original! But fear not, dear writer, for I, your ever-sardonic narrator, am here to lead you through this labyrinth of creative indecision with all the grace of a cat walking on a keyboard.

First, let’s dissect these wonderfully unique, never-before-seen concepts, shall we? Starting with your modern fantasy story where a human turns into a deity-monster-thing. Ah, the classic "I woke up like this" but with divine powers and probably more scales or fur. A tale as old as time, or at least as old as the last time someone watched too much late-night anime and thought, “Hey, that could be a novel!”

Then there’s the heartwarming story of an animal turned humanoid deity. It’s like every Disney movie met Kafka’s "Metamorphosis" and they decided to have a literary baby. I can already envision the merchandising possibilities. Plush toys of your divine animal hero? Check. Cartoon spin-offs? Double check. A subtle exploration of identity and existence? Optional, but could be a fun footnote.

Ah, but wait! There’s more! A science fiction epic featuring an alien with the mental capacity of a toaster, suddenly blessed by a smorgasbord of deities. It’s like someone threw darts at a board labeled “sci-fi tropes” and decided to run with whatever stuck. I’m already bracing myself for the philosophical musings of an alien who previously contemplated nothing beyond its next space-snack.

Finally, the pièce de résistance, an interactive story. Because why make decisions yourself when you can crowdsource them? This concept merges the timeless charm of a “Choose Your Own Adventure” book with the existential dread of realizing that your readers might have more bizarre ideas than you do. Modern fantasy or science fiction, it matters not. What matters is the thrill of watching your carefully crafted plot get hijacked by reader whims. Will your protagonist be a three-headed space accountant with a penchant for interpretive dance? Only the fates (and your readers) will know.

But let’s cut through the cosmic fog of sarcasm for a moment and address the pulsating neutron star in the room: it’s not about the idea; it’s about the execution. You could take the most clichéd concept, like a boy wizard going to a magical school, and turn it into a worldwide phenomenon. Alternatively, you could take the most groundbreaking idea and watch it fizzle out faster than a comet in a black hole if the execution is as dull as a conference on paint drying techniques.

Each of your ideas has the potential to be a masterpiece or a cautionary tale in a creative writing class. The modern fantasy with the human-turned-deity-monster-thing? Make sure it’s not just a parade of cool powers and epic battles. Give us a character who struggles with their newfound divinity, who grapples with the monster in the mirror. Maybe they start longing for the days when the biggest challenge was choosing what to watch on Netflix, not deciding the fate of mankind.

The animal-to-humanoid deity? That’s a gold mine for exploring themes of identity, transformation, and the eternal question of whether a divine squirrel should store its nuts in heaven or on earth. But tread carefully. You don’t want your readers to feel like they’re reading the diary of someone who got a little too obsessed with their pet hamster.

As for your alien blessed by the deities? Here’s a chance to delve into the nature of consciousness and the impact of sudden, overwhelming knowledge. Just ensure that your alien’s journey from simplicity to divinity is more gripping than a documentary about watching paint dry.

And the interactive story? It’s a wild card, a literary Russian roulette. It could be a riotous journey through the collective id of your readership or a trainwreck that makes you question the very nature of storytelling. Embrace the chaos, but maybe have a stiff drink at hand.

In conclusion, dear writer, pick the idea that makes your heart sing or at least hums a catchy tune. Whether it’s a monstrous deity or a philosophizing alien, the magic is in how you spin the tale. So, wield your pen like a wand, and may the muse of sardonic wit bless your literary endeavors. And remember, if all else fails, there’s always the possibility of a career in writing sarcastic commentary. Just saying.
 
Top