The Demon Lord’s Castle – A Mafia Game (Evil Victory)

[Amok]

True.. but she also claimed Vanillatown, and I'm somewhat inclined to believe her, since last game she was mafia. I doubt someone can get mafia twice in a row.

i played two games in a row on another site where the exact same two players were in the scum team. so never bank on this kind of out of game meta. these things are random.

 

[Amok]

True.. but she also claimed Vanillatown, and I'm somewhat inclined to believe her, since last game she was mafia. I doubt someone can get mafia twice in a row.

but I agree with you for now i trust mellohwa's claim. And No Exe is the best vote here. My ability is spent but let the prophets sort out the evils by night.

 

[GreenHexagon]

i played two games in a row on another site where the exact same two players were in the scum team. so never bank on this kind of out of game meta. these things are random.

Huh. Well, I guess that has dropped my trust to like 10%. I still say we need information.

 

[Plus1]

Huh. Well, I guess that has dropped my trust to like 10%. I still say we need information.

Lol. This is true random, roles in past games don’t matter.

 

[AnonUnlimited]

@Jailbreak571 Any thoughts?

 

[Plus1]

Okay, so let me get this straight;

-Amok claims Disciple, clears Greyblob and Anon (how could he clear two people? Can he investigate two people in one night?)
-Anon clears Agentt
-Greenhex claims Deathknight
-Mello and Aaqil claim Brave. (Regular townie)

Since a lot of roles have already been exposed, I think it would be okay for the normal “Good Braves” to come out. With just the two it’s not enough to clear them, but if more people claim to have the same role it would be safe to clear Aaqil, who revealed the name of the role.

There can’t be only two of them, right? That would mean there are at least 5prs, potentially 6, on the Good side, which would just be ridiculous.

 

[Plus1]

Oh, and Anon also clears Jailbreak. How? Unclear.

 

[GreenHexagon]

Noone has claimed Prophet either, which is weird considering from the info we've gotten from Amok, we can't have disciple without prophet.

 

[GreenHexagon]

-Anon clears Agentt

I feel like this clear makes it seem like Anon is prophet. Maybe. @Anon2021

 

[Plus1]

Yeah, it seemed pretty obvious to me, I just didn’t want to say it so mafia wouldn’t find out. Ever since you revealed the role, I was 95% sure it was Anon, just from his role play on D1

 

[Plus1]

Question is, how can they clear two ppl each?

 

[AnonUnlimited]

Question is, how can they clear two ppl each?

Disciples know their prophets and vice versa.

 

[GreenHexagon]

Disciples know their prophets and vice versa.

if that's true then that clears both you and amok, at the risk of being mafia killed. It also clears Greyblob and Agentt, assuming they don't have mafia roles that show up as town to prophet/disciple. It's not hard to believe considering I have a town role that shows up as mafia to you two.

I Trust Aaqil's brave claim, considering he was the one to give the name. Mello, not so much.

@Plus1 you said you have a PR right?

So...

Least Suspicious
@Anon2021
@Aaqil
@Amok
Somewhat Suspicious
@Mellohwa
@greyblob
@Agentt
@Plus1
Suspicious
@Jailbreak571

 

[Plus1]

@Anon2021 Yeah… unless there’s a double pair of prophet-disciple (which would just be stupid), it still doesn’t make sense. It would make sense that Amok cleared both you and Greyblob, but then why did you say that Amok was ‘probably’ cleared, and not ‘definitely’ cleared, if you knew he was your disciple?

Also, how could you n turn clear two unrelated people, namely Agentt and Jail?

 

[Plus1]

Okay. Okay. Everyone, hear me out. Actually, screw it. I’m pinning everyone. @Mellohwa @GreenHexagon @Anon2021 @Agentt @Jailbreak571 @Aaqil @greyblob @Amok... I think that’s everybody.

Alright, so please seriously consider what I have to say:

First of all, the lore seems to imply there’s only a single Mafia; the demon king’s succesor. However, that’s absurd, right? A 1vs8? No way!

But what if there is a way?

Greenhexagon’s previous message got me thinking.

What’s our strongest weapon in this game? The prophet and disciple pair, of course. With those two, even if there were two mafia, the game would still be an easy win. Even three would be doable. But as Greenhexagon claims—and I am heavily inclined to believe him due to information only I have access to— his role is Deathknight, and he will show up as Evil if examined by the prophet.

So, would it be that far-fetched to believe that the Demon King has the same power, in reverse? To come up as Good when under scrutiny? I believe that is the key to this game; the Good side has an overwhelming advantage in both numbers and varied abilities, but they will be working with faulty information while the Evil walks amongst them, unhindered, picking them off one by one.

Now, why was there no kill on night one? I have little clue. I doubt it was due to the Demon King (I’m just gonna go with that moniker from now on) trying to kill Mellowha, who was coincidentally protected by Greenhexagon. It’s still a possibility, though.

Perhaps the ability to appear as Good is not inherent but takes a night to apply, or they have some other, unknown ability. In any case, there will probably be a kill next night.

In conclusion, while I do believe Amok, Anon and Greenhexagon are clear, along with (to a lesser degree) Aaqil, the rest are still worth doubting, in my eyes.

Any thoughts?

 

[Mellohwa]

So, would it be that far-fetched to believe that the Demon King has the same power, in reverse? To come up as Good when under scrutiny? I believe that is the key to this game; the Good side has an overwhelming advantage in both numbers and varied abilities, but they will be working with faulty information while the Evil walks amongst them, unhindered, picking them off one by one.

There's a possibility of that happened

Any thoughts?

I still don't get how prophet and disciples works...

 

[Mellohwa]

I feel like this clear makes it seem like Anon is prophet. Maybe. @Anon2021

Is he really the prophet?

 

[Plus1]

There's a possibility of that happened

I still don't get how prophet and disciples works...

Okay, so prophet was like the Onmyouji in the inn game, he can discern people’s alignment, unless their role modifies the result.

The disciple can do the same thing, but only once, and turns into prophet when the prophet dies.

I think.

 

[Plus1]

Is he really the prophet?

Yup. He pretty much confirmed it himself. I’d be surprised if he wasn’t.

 

[Mellohwa]

disciple is backup to profit. means that when prophet dies, I become the prophet.

disciple only has 1-shot night investigation, while prophet has all-night. I visited Anon2021 last night, they are good

So based on this, Amok is a disciple. But he still investigate Anon(prophet?) who claimed;

Disciples know their prophets and vice versa.