Would you take responsibility for someone you accidentally charmed? (Poll)

[minacia]

Welcome to the Magic Academy! When you were a second year student, you were fooling in the headmaster's forbidden library with all kinds of forbidden magic books and accidentally caused a spell to misfire. The spell hit one of your friends.​

​

It turns out that it was an irreversible charm spell, the most powerful one in existence.​

​

Your friend is now hopelessly in love with you, and their feelings for you will never fade, and it is now impossible for them to fall in love with anyone else.​

​

The spell is considered "forbidden" / "irreversible" because it is etched onto the target's soul. It is literally impossible to undo (or override) it without erasing the target's soul in its entirety. The headmaster thinks this is a very serious situation and contacts both of your parents. The headmaster explains to you that it is almost like psychological torture for your friend to be apart from you, and the most humane thing to do is to simply enter a relationship (and later marry) your charmed friend.​

​

For the time being, they placed your friend under a sleeping spell to spare them of the powerful lovesickness, but they don't think it's a good idea to keep your friend asleep forever.​

1. What would you do?

2. What if your friend didn't match your tastes, or was not the gender that you prefer?

3. Suppose that your friend begs you to allow them to stay at your side. Even if you don't date them, they're happy to be close to you... as long as you allow them to stay nearby.......

4. How would you feel if you were the friend, and you were aware that all of the feelings that you felt were artificial? How would you deal with all of the urges? Does it change the way that you think knowing that it's impossible for you to like anyone else?

 

[Milk.Milkan]

1. What would you do?

2. What if your friend didn't match your tastes, or was not the gender that you prefer?

3. Suppose that your friend begs you to allow them to stay at your side. Even if you don't date them, they're happy to be close to you... as long as you allow them to stay nearby.......

4. How would you feel if you were the friend, and you were aware that all of the feelings that you felt were artificial? How would you deal with all of the urges? Does it change the way that you think knowing that it's impossible for you to like anyone else?

Why marry? Since when a stamp in a passport is a humane thing to do?
Oh welp.

1. Dats ma friend eh? Dan id like to be together still. At least me hope dat lovesickness wont kill its original personality dat was a reason for us to be friends in the first place.

2. Being together, living together. Isnt love about feelings of being near each other, warmth and stuff? Or should me want to fuck? I no think me want to fuck and whatever you attracted in ur life most likely dere is no way to find urself an ideal nutshell. So even if ma friend is someone me no considered as a love partner at first me might start to like enough to love.

3. Dat was my point. Sure, stay. Ill also stay. Me also need no search for some human being who s not garbage so me could do dating. Come here, ill gib ya a hug. Lets be together.

4. Eeh, if its artificial and i know dat i no think dat something will prevent me of saying dat. Like "Me love ya so much but me also know dat ma feelings r no true but still cant control myself." I think in dis situation it is an important thing to say so dat further discussion can be held.

 

[GDLiZy]

 

[RepresentingCaution]

*sigh* Fine, I'll marry him or her as long as they're OK with me having other partners as well.

In the friend's position . . . I would at least *try* to fall in love with someone else. I mean, that's pretty much how I became polyamorous in the first place. I've fallen in love with new people, but I never stopped loving my first love. Just like I've told every romantic partner since 2008 that I'm still in love with my first love, I would also be forthright about the spell. I would let them know that there's a possibility I can never return their feelings, but I'd like to try.

 

[CupcakeNinja]

Welcome to the Magic Academy! When you were a second year student, you were fooling in the headmaster's forbidden library with all kinds of forbidden magic books and accidentally caused a spell to misfire. The spell hit one of your friends.​

​

It turns out that it was an irreversible charm spell, the most powerful one in existence.​

​

Your friend is now hopelessly in love with you, and their feelings for you will never fade, and it is now impossible for them to fall in love with anyone else.​

​

The spell is considered "forbidden" / "irreversible" because it is etched onto the target's soul. It is literally impossible to undo (or override) it without erasing the target's soul in its entirety. The headmaster thinks this is a very serious situation and contacts both of your parents. The headmaster explains to you that it is almost like psychological torture for your friend to be apart from you, and the most humane thing to do is to simply enter a relationship (and later marry) your charmed friend.​

​

For the time being, they placed your friend under a sleeping spell to spare them of the powerful lovesickness, but they don't think it's a good idea to keep your friend asleep forever.​

1. What would you do?

2. What if your friend didn't match your tastes, or was not the gender that you prefer?

3. Suppose that your friend begs you to allow them to stay at your side. Even if you don't date them, they're happy to be close to you... as long as you allow them to stay nearby.......

4. How would you feel if you were the friend, and you were aware that all of the feelings that you felt were artificial? How would you deal with all of the urges? Does it change the way that you think knowing that it's impossible for you to like anyone else?

I'd keep them as a fuck friend if they are cute. at least. Why not? They love me unconditionally apparently

Also these questions are so damn specific every time. What's your game here "minacia"? Huh? *squints suspiciously*

Fishing for ideas? Making us come up with your material? Tell us the truth, ya bastard! *shakes you furiously*

 

[minacia]

I'd keep them as a fuck friend if they are cute. at least. Why not? They love me unconditionally apparently

Also these questions are so damn specific every time. What's your game here "minacia"? Huh? *squints suspiciously*

Fishing for ideas? Making us come up with your material? Tell us the truth, ya bastard! *shakes you furiously*

It’s probably disappointing, but there really isn’t a purpose XD

 

[Nahrenne]

Welcome to the Magic Academy! When you were a second year student, you were fooling in the headmaster's forbidden library with all kinds of forbidden magic books and accidentally caused a spell to misfire. The spell hit one of your friends.​

​

It turns out that it was an irreversible charm spell, the most powerful one in existence.​

​

Your friend is now hopelessly in love with you, and their feelings for you will never fade, and it is now impossible for them to fall in love with anyone else.​

​

The spell is considered "forbidden" / "irreversible" because it is etched onto the target's soul. It is literally impossible to undo (or override) it without erasing the target's soul in its entirety. The headmaster thinks this is a very serious situation and contacts both of your parents. The headmaster explains to you that it is almost like psychological torture for your friend to be apart from you, and the most humane thing to do is to simply enter a relationship (and later marry) your charmed friend.​

​

For the time being, they placed your friend under a sleeping spell to spare them of the powerful lovesickness, but they don't think it's a good idea to keep your friend asleep forever.​

1. What would you do?

2. What if your friend didn't match your tastes, or was not the gender that you prefer?

3. Suppose that your friend begs you to allow them to stay at your side. Even if you don't date them, they're happy to be close to you... as long as you allow them to stay nearby.......

4. How would you feel if you were the friend, and you were aware that all of the feelings that you felt were artificial? How would you deal with all of the urges? Does it change the way that you think knowing that it's impossible for you to like anyone else?

1. Cast the same spell on myself, or have that friend cast it on me so we both love each other and suffer the consequences together.
'-'
2. I kind of answered that in the first one; the spell would make such a thing pointless to think about, no?
3. I mean, I would be in the same boat with them due to 1.'s answer.
'-'
4. Knowing that the other side would be putting themselves in the same predicament would make me feel more at ease.
Urges? Love doesn't have to be sexual, or at least physical. There is such a thing as platonic love.
'-'
I mean, I imagine that being under the spell would make it so such thoughts of never loving anyone else would never even enter the mind in the first place.
'-'


All in all, though...

Spoiler: My feelings on this scenario

HOW THE HECK DID I MANAGE TO CAST SUCH A POWERFUL SPELL AS A SECOND YEAR SCHOOL STUDENT?!

'-'

X

 

[CupcakeNinja]

It’s probably disappointing, but there really isn’t a purpose XD

not disappointing. Disgusting. How dare you make such uselessly elaborate threads so thoughtlessly?

 

[minacia]

not disappointing. Disgusting. How dare you make such uselessly elaborate threads so thoughtlessly?

I feel so... validated!!! Thank you for your encouraging feedback!

 

[BenJepheneT]

Fellas, is it gay to grant your fellow homie eternal love he so deserves?

 

[CupcakeNinja]

Fellas, is it gay to grant your fellow homie eternal love he so deserves?

Nah mate. No homo is omnipotent

 

[minacia]

I dislike this one too! Mainly because I almost always like someone...

If I didn’t like my friend, most likely that would mean that I already had a crush on someone else (very typical for me), and then I would be sad