Worldbuilding notes for pirate isekai story

ThisAdamGuy

Proud inventor of the chocolate onion
Joined
Sep 4, 2024
Messages
1,008
Points
128
I've spent the past few days making notes for a pirate-themed story I want to write. And before you ask, no, I'm not going to use the "pirate card battle" idea I posted about a couple days ago. I told you I probably wouldn't :P

Anyway, here's what I've got so far. I'd appreciate some feedback on what you think sounds good vs what sounds bad.

It takes place on a world called Shael, which is almost entirely covered by water. There are small islands all over it, but they make up less than 1% of the planet's surface. There are several races living on Shael, humans being one of them, but I haven't developed them enough to be worth talking about.

Thousands of years ago, Shael was ruled by an amphibious race called Sirens. Sirens used a magical language known as the Hymn that only they were capable of speaking, which let them control and alter the world around them. They didn't invent the Hymn, they discovered it, and were constantly researching it to discover even more words so they could expand their power. The Sirens researching their language were known as the Choir, and each member carried a Hymnal that would expand as they learned new and more powerful words.

Eventually, the Choir went too far when they tried using the Hymn to create life itself. Using what eventually became known as the Black Hymn, they attempted to make a new race of creatures that would act as their servants, but quickly lost control--both of the creatures, and of the creation process itself. This resulted in a race of colossal, ravenous beasts that they named the Krakens. A war broke out between the Sirens and the Krakens, but since Black Hymn was completely out of control and creating new Krakens nonstop, the Sirens lost pretty badly.

The last thing the Sirens did was open a gateway to Earth. They used the Hymn to take on a human appearance, and left Shael and its inhabitants to the mercy of the Krakens. Thousands of years passed, and almost all non-Kraken life was wiped out since races that couldn't use the Hymn were completely helpless against them. But when there stopped being enough food to sustain the Krakens, they turned on each other, nearly wiping themselves out as well. The Black Hymn eventually subsided. Krakens were still being created, but nowhere near at the rate they were during the war. Slowly, some semblance of balance began to return to Shael. Considering Shael's terrain, its inhabitants had no choice but to take to the seas if they wanted to expand and survive. The Krakens were still a massive threat, and the inhabitants still had no way to fight them, so they just avoided them as best they could.

Meanwhile, in our world, people have started hearing a mysterious song. If they follow it, they're led to temporary gateways between Earth and Shael. These people are the descendants of the Sirens who came to Earth, almost entirely human but with just enough Siren blood left in them that with training they can learn to use the Hymn. Remnants of the Sirenian empire still exist, most of them left undisturbed at the bottom of the ocean, and that means that occasionally old Hymnals are recovered. Humans who come from our world are known as the New Choir since their ability to learn and speak the Hymn makes them Shael's only living magic users.

Hymnals are hard to explain, but maybe that's just because I haven't developed them enough yet. Basically, they're chock full of magic words, but most human minds aren't able to comprehend them. A word in the Hymn basically encompasses everything a word means, has ever meant, and will ever mean. It's a drop of pure unadulterated Truth, and forcing too much of it into your little mortal noggin can result in big, gooey brainsplosions. As a side effect of being so full of magic, the Hymnals are kinda sorta alive and sentient, and they don't want their owners to die, so they'll limit themselves to keep their owners from melting their own brains. Their pages will appear blank except for the words their owners can handle, and the better their owners get at learning and using the Hymn, the more words they'll reveal. I hope this will give the story the kind of litrpg-lite, progression vibe that webserial fans like so much. I also want to make it so members of the New Choir can steal words from each others' Hymnals if they beat them in battle, but that part is still deep in development.

That's about all I have so far. What do you guys think?
 

Tempokai

The Overworked One
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
1,396
Points
153
1% is too small. Crank it up to at least 10%, better if 20%. It will be nightmare for a human to do anything really, even with magic. Imagine setting sail to Island B and weeks later you're still traveling and so on. This will be boring, even if there's amphibians roaming around for the ordinary human. It's better to use archipelago type world for it. It has all the advantages for the good worldbuilding without sacrifing the believeability.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,666
Points
158
I read a book when I was young (like 8 or so) that was published in the early 60s; I thought the title was "Water World" but can't find any record of it anywhere; anyway, it had a world sounds like Shael except the gates were technological and lost after some kind of accident, stranding humans on a world with a near-human amphibious native life form and monsters the humans called "krakens" causing trouble. Was the first place I ever heard about "copper-based blood" (written about two or three years before Spock was confirmed as having that on Star Trek, but I read it the same year I saw one of the episodes that mentioned it, which was why both facts stuck in my head now almost 50 years later), and this blood was used by one of the few humans who understood technology to fight the things... Made batteries and weapons from killing baby kraken to take out the big ones.

The society was built around floating buildings connected by collapsible ramps (and a LOT of boats of varying sizes traveling between them), because most of the actual land was used for mining and half of the floating buildings had been built from stuff brought through the gates when they worked.

Though the colony traveled about half the distance of North America over the course of the story, the characters were limited to an area a little larger than North Dakota at any given time by the Krakens - and occasional pirates when their buildings got close enough for pirates to risk the trip.
 

Kenjona

His member well-known
Joined
Apr 12, 2020
Messages
705
Points
133
First the Travel times as noted by Tempokai, the bigger the world the vaster its oceans the more travel time is required between
"islands".
So unless you can speed up your travel times, voyages are going to be long to very very very very long. I might have missed a "very" or a few in there. Or your adventure can be in a smaller area. Example the Hawaiian Island chain, from one end to the other of the main islands it takes about several hours to days in a modern sailing vessel.
  • O'ahu and the Big Island: A non-stop trip of 150 nautical miles at 5 knots takes 30 hours
  • O'ahu and Maui: A non-stop trip of 75 nautical miles at 5 knots takes 15 hours
  • O'ahu and Kaua'i: A non-stop trip of 90 nautical miles at 5 knots takes 18 hours
  • O'ahu itself (Going around the island): A non-stop trip of 100 nautical miles at 5 knots takes 20 hours
    Some notorious crossings include the Alenuihāhā Channel between Maui and the Big Island, and the Kaiwi Channel between O'ahu and Maui. These channels are known for their steep waves and high winds. So take some sailing skill to cross swiftly and safely depending on vessels.
This is what it takes to go over 60 knots (70+MPH or 111+KMH) in our modern world with a sailing vessel: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vestas_Sailrocket
This is the best speed of a Clipper ship probably the outmost sailing technology before the steam kicked to death into the proverbial curb. Sovereign of the Seas: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_of_the_Seas_(clipper)

Depth:
Is this a Deep Ocean World?
If so you might have bands of depth where only certain types of creatures can survive. Then islands become islands for even the mer type folk.
Shallow Oceans are not so bad for a Mer/siren/whatever person can live on the bottom and spread throughout the world. In which case what advantage do islanders have over mer folk? If none then border taxes, no go zones and such will be enacted on "Islanders".

Moons do you have any? Tides, oh the tides that can be done. Or not done. Throw in solar tides also and any other celestial body. It can be as complicated as you like, or not at all.
Waves, if there is nothing to block a wave it will get bigger; and eventually, even bigger (Not a mistype).
If there is nothing to block the wind, waves (swells) get bigger. Once a wave forms it does not stop until it gets stopped by hitting something else, and it again can get continually bigger.

Then of course you could just hand wave everything away and ignore it all. Which could be good as long as you are consistent with it.
I read a book when I was young (like 8 or so) that was published in the early 60s; I thought the title was "Water World" but can't find any record of it anywhere; anyway, it had a world sounds like Shael except the gates were technological and lost after some kind of accident, stranding humans on a world with a near-human amphibious native life form and monsters the humans called "krakens" causing trouble. Was the first place I ever heard about "copper-based blood" (written about two or three years before Spock was confirmed as having that on Star Trek, but I read it the same year I saw one of the episodes that mentioned it, which was why both facts stuck in my head now almost 50 years later), and this blood was used by one of the few humans who understood technology to fight the things... Made batteries and weapons from killing baby kraken to take out the big ones.

The society was built around floating buildings connected by collapsible ramps (and a LOT of boats of varying sizes traveling between them), because most of the actual land was used for mining and half of the floating buildings had been built from stuff brought through the gates when they worked.

Though the colony traveled about half the distance of North America over the course of the story, the characters were limited to an area a little larger than North Dakota at any given time by the Krakens - and occasional pirates when their buildings got close enough for pirates to risk the trip.
The Blue World By Jack Vance? Most of Jack Vance's stuff does not survive a modern readers palate, but he was a prolific Sci-fi Author during the 60's and 70's. he was one of the "names' I would always look for when I visited a new Library as a kid.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 2, 2020
Messages
810
Points
133
I know this sounds arrogant, but if your novel exceed 50 chapters I will read it. I want to read novels about pirates since I like LOTM(Arc 3) and Deep Sea Embers. However, I want to read novels with at least 50 chapters. Just remind me and I'll surely comment and give you a review.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,666
Points
158
The Blue World By Jack Vance? Most of Jack Vance's stuff does not survive a modern readers palate, but he was a prolific Sci-fi Author during the 60's and 70's. he was one of the "names' I would always look for when I visited a new Library as a kid.
That is definitely possible - like I said, it was almost 50 years ago. I do remember looking for stuff by him and a few others (many I no longer remember the names of, like the guy who wrote "House with a Clock in its Walls"; and others like E(dith) Nesbitt; C. S. Lewis; Robert Heinlein; and Robert Arthur - before I found out there were THREE, and one of them was a "studio name" the other a father and son team who started a bunch of series then sold them to the publisher and started other series)
 

ThisAdamGuy

Proud inventor of the chocolate onion
Joined
Sep 4, 2024
Messages
1,008
Points
128
There's one more thing I'm wanting to add to the story, but I'm having trouble thinking of the right word for it. There's a special skill Choir members can learn that allows them to add words to other things. So if you have a sword, they can add the Hymn word for fire to it and make a flaming sword.

This is a big part of how the Krakens were made. Since they were creating life out of nothing, they essentially built the Krakens purely out of the words that described how they wanted them to turn out. Then the Black Hymn started assigning words to them indiscriminately, giving them traits the Choir didn't want them to have, like giant, rage, hunger, armored, etc.

I swear there's a blacksmithing (?) word that essentially means what I'm talking about. The act of adding something to an existing thing to reinforce it or something like that. But no matter how hard I think about it, I can't remember it.

Ideas?
 
Top