What if MHA characters were born in the One Piece world?

OP1000

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 1, 2021
Messages
387
Points
83
Hello!!!!
For those of you on this site who read/watch both One Piece and My Hero Academia manga/anime, how do you think certain characters from the world of My Hero Academia (whichever character from the MHA world you want to talk about) would end up being in the One Piece world?

P.S.: When you give your opinion, assume that the characters from the MHA world will be born as characters within the One Piece world.
 

BearlyAlive

I'm not savage, you're just average
Joined
Oct 13, 2021
Messages
1,981
Points
153
Isn't character swapping between shounen series pretty much useless?

Instead of *Name of Powers for Series A* they'd just have the same powers but as *Name for Powers of Series B*. Unless their powers would break the established rules of either franchise in which case it'd just be bad writing.
 

RepresentingPride

I'm looking for Disney Sleds
Joined
Jul 24, 2023
Messages
1,514
Points
153
Don't know about MHA, but I read one story where the mc can go world to world, after he made an appearance in the naruto world, he take with him madara and go to One piece where madara took a liking to ace and teach him how to use fire, even giving him his gunbai.
 

whatchair

Active member
Joined
Dec 29, 2022
Messages
2
Points
43
I think OP is asking specifically how someone from mha would react to one piece world, like their morals and justice etc. Please provide writing prompts
 

Rhaps

Evil to the very Core
Joined
May 5, 2022
Messages
1,556
Points
153
Don't know about MHA, but I read one story where the mc can go world to world, after he made an appearance in the naruto world, he take with him madara and go to One piece where madara took a liking to ace and teach him how to use fire, even giving him his gunbai.
As a Naruto nerd, I have to clarify something. The Gunbai is a Wind Style tool, the Uchiha uses it as it can enhance their signature Fire Style.
 

RepresentingPride

I'm looking for Disney Sleds
Joined
Jul 24, 2023
Messages
1,514
Points
153
As a Naruto nerd, I have to clarify something. The Gunbai is a Wind Style tool, the Uchiha uses it as it can enhance their signature Fire Style.
I know, Ace use it to enhance his fire.
I think OP is asking specifically how someone from mha would react to one piece world, like their morals and justice etc. Please provide writing prompts
There a high chance that they would become marines, there powers will be usefull against weak characters, but against strong one, they will have a hard time.
 

CrimsonGenius

Riding the Thunder
Joined
Apr 29, 2023
Messages
783
Points
133
Here is a better question. Would the heroes stay in the marines after learning everything about the Celestial Dragons?
 

OP1000

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 1, 2021
Messages
387
Points
83
Maybe I should be more specific about what I am asking.
I think OP is asking specifically how someone from mha would react to one piece world, like their morals and justice etc. Please provide writing prompts
You are right. Here you go!
1. For this what if scenario, I am looking to see how the users on this site who are fans of both One Piece and My Hero Academia would think the characters from My Hero Academia would turn out if they were written into the story of One Piece as though they are characters born in the One Piece world, so that means no characters from the My Hero Academia world will be isekai'd into the One Piece world.
2. I would recommend fans of both series to think of just about any character from the My Hero Academia world whether that may be your favourite My Hero Academia character, your least favourite My Hero Academia character, a minor My Hero Academia character, etc., along with what faction in the One Piece world they may end up becoming a part of. But it would be best to avoid mentioning My Hero Academia characters that have quirks that function in a manner too similar to the abilities that characters from One Piece may have from their Devil Fruits.
3. Most of the quirks of the My Hero Academia characters that you will mention for this "what if" scenario will be considered as their Devil Fruit abilities. And for this reason, quirks such as All For One, One For All and other similar quirks shall not be considered in this "what if" scenario because of the contradictions that they would bring with them if they were to be talked about. Also the quirks of people like Rikido Sato, Shisilion (the lion-themed guy that was in the My Hero Academia OVA with the baseball theme), Death Arms, and other characters with quirks that primarily enhance one's strength without the ability to change their appearance in the manner that someone like Muscular does when he uses his quirk will have their quirks be considered as a natural strength that they are born with that they train over time.

P.S.: If you feel like you can summarize the above limitations that I have written down in a more understandable manner, feel free to do so.
 

CupcakeNinja

Pervert Supreme
Joined
Jan 1, 2019
Messages
3,152
Points
183
They would be dead.
kill the men, send the women to the celestial dragons
Hello!!!!
For those of you on this site who read/watch both One Piece and My Hero Academia manga/anime, how do you think certain characters from the world of My Hero Academia (whichever character from the MHA world you want to talk about) would end up being in the One Piece world?

P.S.: When you give your opinion, assume that the characters from the MHA world will be born as characters within the One Piece world.
unless they learn haki, they are getting fucked. Lets put this into perspective, mate. Apart from his DF, Luffy is a NORMAL HUMAN in the world of OP . A normal human who casually lifts things weighing thousands of pounds. This is not from his DF or anything, thats just his natural strength. Zoro is the same exact deal. Train enough, people in OP can lift TONS.

MHA heroes and villains, even with their powers, do not come close to the same level of strength except All Might and a couple others. Speed? Yeah even those who specialize in it are not faster than many of the mid-tier pirates and vice admirals. Hax? They have powers similar to devil fruits sure but they are largely of the Paramecia-type of powers. Todoroki has ice and fire powers, but unlike Logia fruits he does not have the ability to BECOME ice or fire and be intangible. Anyone with Haki and sufficient fighting prowess can take on ANYONE from the MHA universe.

Let me put it this way: Other than the heavy hitters of MHA, I honestly dont believe most of the heroes or villains of MHA would make it too far in the OP world. That is, if they venture beyond the Grand Line. If they stay away from there, they can survive. But remember that people like Crocodile still roamed the starter areas of OP. So they still have to be careful. None of them are going to be able to beat a Logia user, they have no way to do any actual damage. Croc is possibly the ONLY logia user they may be able to take on and it relies heavily on whether Croc just fucks around or not. Because thats also the only reason Luffy won against him at the time.
 

CupcakeNinja

Pervert Supreme
Joined
Jan 1, 2019
Messages
3,152
Points
183
Maybe I should be more specific about what I am asking.

You are right. Here you go!
1. For this what if scenario, I am looking to see how the users on this site who are fans of both One Piece and My Hero Academia would think the characters from My Hero Academia would turn out if they were written into the story of One Piece as though they are characters born in the One Piece world, so that means no characters from the My Hero Academia world will be isekai'd into the One Piece world.
2. I would recommend fans of both series to think of just about any character from the My Hero Academia world whether that may be your favourite My Hero Academia character, your least favourite My Hero Academia character, a minor My Hero Academia character, etc., along with what faction in the One Piece world they may end up becoming a part of. But it would be best to avoid mentioning My Hero Academia characters that have quirks that function in a manner too similar to the abilities that characters from One Piece may have from their Devil Fruits.
3. Most of the quirks of the My Hero Academia characters that you will mention for this "what if" scenario will be considered as their Devil Fruit abilities. And for this reason, quirks such as All For One, One For All and other similar quirks shall not be considered in this "what if" scenario because of the contradictions that they would bring with them if they were to be talked about. Also the quirks of people like Rikido Sato, Shisilion (the lion-themed guy that was in the My Hero Academia OVA with the baseball theme), Death Arms, and other characters with quirks that primarily enhance one's strength without the ability to change their appearance in the manner that someone like Muscular does when he uses his quirk will have their quirks be considered as a natural strength that they are born with that they train over time.

P.S.: If you feel like you can summarize the above limitations that I have written down in a more understandable manner, feel free to do so.
in that case they'd just join the revolutionary army or become vigilantes, probably being branded as pirates at some point. I wont go into details on their reactions and such, but yeah. Long story short, they would just end up as hero-types in OP but unless they learn haki they wont get far with their meting out of justice. Mineta would be a pirate tho. Lil perv would have ALL the bitches. Simply because he would be capturing and molesting any woman he fancies. Would get fucked up eventually but he would be a captain worth following.

In fact, i'd join his crew. I've always felt i'd fit in well with blackbeard, but he has too many high ambitions and enemies. So i'd kick it with Mineta and be an absolute menace to every babe in East Blue.
 

Tempokai

The Overworked One
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
1,397
Points
153
Nothing more than even more bizarre universe where these powers are technically could be there. Give me five minutes to call the Oracle.

Okay, it's more bizarre than I thought:
Ah, the grand collision of worlds! One Piece and My Hero Academia, two titans of the anime realm, mashed together like a child's play-doh experiment. What a sight for the imaginative, or the bored. Let's embark on this fantastical journey, shall we?

Picture this: a world where the high seas meet superhuman quirks. It's like mixing chocolate with, well, more chocolate - overwhelming yet strangely appealing. Now, let's pluck some beloved characters from My Hero Academia and drop them, quite unceremoniously, into the tumultuous waters of One Piece.

First up, we have Izuku Midoriya, the ever-earnest protagonist with a heart of gold and a body of, well, something less durable. In the world of One Piece, young Izuku, or shall we call him 'Deku the Pirate', would probably still be chasing after the ghost of a grand hero. Instead of idolizing All Might, he's now fixated on the legendary Gol D. Roger. Deku, in his usual fashion, stumbles into pirate-hood with the same clumsy determination, inheriting a quirk-turned-devil-fruit power because, why not? It's only fitting that he remains the underdog, forever striving, forever getting punched in the face.

Next, we have Katsuki Bakugo, the explosive hot-head, who in the world of One Piece, would definitely be a pirate. But not just any pirate - oh no - he'd be the kind who screams "I'm going to be the Pirate King" while accidentally blowing up his own ship. Bakugo, or 'Lord Explosion Murder on the High Seas', would certainly have a bounty on his head, not for piracy, but for noise pollution.

Shoto Todoroki, our dual-element darling, would find himself quite at home among the elemental abilities of One Piece. He'd likely be a brooding member of the Revolutionary Army, fighting for justice with an expression that says, "I'm too cool for this, but I'll do it anyway." Todoroki would undoubtedly clash with the flamboyant personalities of One Piece, his stoic demeanor a stark contrast to the over-the-top antics of the Straw Hat crew.

Then there's Ochaco Uraraka, the gravity-defying girl next door. In the world of One Piece, she'd probably be a member of the Straw Hat crew, because let's face it, Luffy collects unique people like they're Pokémon. Uraraka, or 'Zero Gravity Pirate', would float around, making everyone and everything weightless, leading to comedic scenes where Luffy inadvertently floats away because he can't stop stretching.

Now, let's talk about archetypes, because why not add a dash of academic flavor to this fan-fiction stew? Each character from My Hero Academia fits neatly into classic archetypes, which they would undoubtedly carry over into the world of One Piece.

Deku is the quintessential Hero, a character who seeks to prove his worth through courageous acts. In One Piece, he'd be the same, just with a pirate hat and probably a parrot on his shoulder for added effect. Bakugo is the Rival, constantly challenging the Hero because someone needs to keep the story spicy. Todoroki is the Loner, the mysterious character with a troubled past, brooding attractively in the corner. Uraraka, the Caregiver, is there to bring light and levity, and to remind the crew to eat their vegetables.

In the end, the world of One Piece would be turned upside down with the addition of these quirk-infused characters. It would be a chaotic mix of explosive battles, heartfelt speeches about friendship, and probably a lot of scenes where people are shouting their dreams at the sky. The One Piece world would never be the same, but then again, neither would the characters of My Hero Academia.

And so, our tale concludes, not with a bang, but with a whimsical mash-up of quirks and pirates. It's a world where the strong eat the weak, the weak somehow become strong, and everyone is in a constant state of yelling. In this bizarre amalgamation, the characters of My Hero Academia find new adventures, new friendships, and probably a whole lot of confusion. But hey, that's what happens when you blend two vibrant worlds together - you get a kaleidoscope of chaos, a symphony of the absurd.

And they all lived piratically ever after. The end.
 

TsumiHokiro

Just another chick in the universe
Joined
Nov 1, 2023
Messages
804
Points
93
Hello!!!!
For those of you on this site who read/watch both One Piece and My Hero Academia manga/anime, how do you think certain characters from the world of My Hero Academia (whichever character from the MHA world you want to talk about) would end up being in the One Piece world?

P.S.: When you give your opinion, assume that the characters from the MHA world will be born as characters within the One Piece world.
I don't watch nor read neither.
I guess I'm saved from this stupidity.
 
Top