Trolley problem but worse.

Tempokai

The Overworked One
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
1,392
Points
153
My dreams today were weird and they gave me a thing I'll call "assimilation problem", it's like a trolley problem but it's body horror.

Here's the scenario:
Four girls fuse together using a ritual to create the ultimate female to fullfill their wishes. Then, using the ultimate body, Ultimate Womanfullfills these wishes without failure.

Now, the question:
Are the four girls happy after achieving it all or the amalgamated being consisting of four souls is happy instead?
 

Astrolust

The Tom Brady of Reverse Rape
Joined
Jul 14, 2024
Messages
86
Points
48
What does this homunculus look like. Lie are we talking 16 arms legs and the rest? Or is it just one regular looking woman with 4 souls?
 

Tempokai

The Overworked One
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
1,392
Points
153
What does this homunculus look like. Lie are we talking 16 arms legs and the rest? Or is it just one regular looking woman with 4 souls?
Regular woman that's too beautiful, too competent, too Mary Sue.
 

Astrolust

The Tom Brady of Reverse Rape
Joined
Jul 14, 2024
Messages
86
Points
48
I feel like the amalgamation is probably happy, because she is the "ultimate female to fullfill their wishes"
 

AnonUnlimited

????????? (???/???)
Joined
Apr 18, 2022
Messages
4,566
Points
183
I feel like... it'll only be successful if the breasts are now 4x the size but everything else is normal.
 

GlassRose

Kaleidoscope of Harmonious Contradiction
Joined
Apr 20, 2021
Messages
402
Points
133
Neither. The four girls no longer exist, and the amalgam, being composed of many different traits from different people mashed together, is thus different from all of them and the end result may not have the same wishes as the components. Furthermore, fulfilling your goals/wishes is not guaranteed to bring happiness. Even further, the amalgam is unlikely to be happy, being a unique being that many would consider an abomination defying nature, resulting in crippling loneliness, negative self worth, and unfulfillment.
 

Cipiteca396

Monarch of Despair 🐉🌺🪽🌊🪶🌑🐦‍🔥🌈
Joined
Jun 6, 2021
Messages
2,700
Points
153
This is nowhere near worth getting troubled over.

The amalgam fulfills their wishes and then separates into four (or five if you somehow believe the amalgam was its own person) 'perfected' versions of the girls it was made of, causing them no harm and helping them better understand themselves.

Alternatively, if they were happier together, then some or all of them may remain as one, or retain the ability to recombine and separate at any moment.

This is what it means to fulfill a wish without failure. There is no downside. If there is a downside, then it must be amended immediately, or the wish is null.
 

RepresentingDesire

Eye of Desire
Joined
Aug 9, 2023
Messages
1,346
Points
153
My dreams today were weird and they gave me a thing I'll call "assimilation problem", it's like a trolley problem but it's body horror.

Here's the scenario:
Four girls fuse together using a ritual to create the ultimate female to fullfill their wishes. Then, using the ultimate body, Ultimate Womanfullfills these wishes without failure.

Now, the question:
Are the four girls happy after achieving it all or the amalgamated being consisting of four souls is happy instead?
That's more the ship of theseus than anything else because the question is if this entity is four women conjoined or a new entity. I would say it's a new entity or rather that's a still just bunch of cells that came from different heaps that unlocked the ability to combine through an eldritch ritual and reform, still just a bunch of bacteria.
 

Nolff

An attractive male of unspecified gender.
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
2,126
Points
153
My dreams today were weird and they gave me a thing I'll call "assimilation problem", it's like a trolley problem but it's body horror.

Here's the scenario:
Four girls fuse together using a ritual to create the ultimate female to fullfill their wishes. Then, using the ultimate body, Ultimate Womanfullfills these wishes without failure.

Now, the question:
Are the four girls happy after achieving it all or the amalgamated being consisting of four souls is happy instead?
How the frick she granted their wishes whilst they themselves were inside he-

Elaborate.

excuseme.jpg

Now, I've read all the other answers.

Those are answers, you don't need mine.

But... How in god's name does that even work!??

Look, they fuse themselves to split themselves and now they're perfect.

wtf.jpg
 

Tempokai

The Overworked One
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
1,392
Points
153
They sat there beneath the waning sun, their faces—what was left of them—shadowed and strange. The ritual had been performed. The darkened altar, the whispered words. Each step carried out in perfect cadence, like a sentence passed down long ago, inexorable. Four girls become one. Flesh, melded. Souls, forgotten.

The land around them was dead. No birds cried out, no wind stirred the grass. Just silence. A silence so thick it weighed down the sky. Feminominatrix—though they did not call her that, for names meant little in the void they now inhabited—sat still, looking out into the distance, where nothing awaited her.

And what was there to say?

There were no wishes. No dreams. What they had thought they’d wanted, that too had withered like the brush along the dry creek bed. They were what remained. A thing built of hope that had curdled into despair. She sat alone, and yet not alone. Inside her, the four girls twisted, shadows upon shadows. Jane. Sarah. Lucy. Emma. Once they had names. Now they were just memories rattling through the cage of her bones.

Her skin was flawless, unmarked, perfect. But beneath it was chaos. You couldn’t see it—no, you couldn’t see it—but it was there, the way a knife lurks in a drawer. A terrible violence, silent and waiting.

Jane had wished for beauty, and she had it. Her beauty was such that to look upon her was to feel a kind of pain in the chest, an ache for something lost, something that could never be. But Jane was gone now, her desire stretched out like skin on a drum, taut and brittle. She’d wanted to be beautiful so the world would love her, but the world was gone. And who was left to love but the void itself?

Sarah had wanted competence. A life without failure. A mind so sharp it could cut through the riddles of existence like butter. But what good is competence when all that’s left is the dust? She could solve every problem in the world, and yet the world itself was unsolvable. Sarah's dreams had been eaten by the thing she had become, and now she wandered through Feminominatrix’s mind like a lost dog, scratching at the door of some place she’d forgotten.

Lucy wanted power, and she had it. All the power she could ever want. She could have moved mountains. Split the sea. Commanded the very stars. But there were no stars left. There was only the endless, empty sky. The horizon stretched out before them like a wound. Lucy was still there, she thought, somewhere deep in the marrow of Feminominatrix, but her power meant nothing now. She was a god with no one left to worship her, a king with no throne.

And Emma. Poor Emma. Emma had wanted happiness. Simple, radiant happiness. And when the four of them had fused, when their souls had stitched together into this monstrous unity, for a brief moment, she’d felt it. Joy like a light that could burn through the night. But it had flickered and died, swallowed up by the immensity of what they had become. Now Emma wandered too, lost inside Feminominatrix, searching for that light, knowing she’d never find it. Knowing that happiness had been a lie from the start.

---

The land was flat. It stretched out for miles, the ground cracked and broken, as if the earth itself had given up trying to hold its shape. Feminominatrix walked. There was nowhere to go, but she walked anyway. Perhaps it was a memory of the girls—some trace of the human need to move, to do something, anything, even when there was nothing left to be done. The girls were all fragments now. Thin and ghostly, they twisted inside her like leaves caught in the wind, brittle and faint.

She stopped, staring at the horizon. It was meaningless, a line drawn by gods who no longer cared. The sun hung low, a dead thing in the sky.

Was Feminominatrix happy?

Could happiness exist in a place like this, a place so bereft of meaning that even the earth refused to remember its own shape? She had fulfilled their wishes. The ritual had been perfect. She was all they’d wanted to be—flawless, invincible, a construct of power and beauty. But there was nothing left to want. Nothing left to strive for.

Inside her, Jane whispered. Then Sarah. Then Lucy. Then Emma. Their voices came together, like water dripping in a well. And then they were gone again.

What had they been before? Who were they now? Did it matter? The ritual had made them perfect, but perfection was just another kind of death. And perhaps they had died already. Perhaps they had died the moment they’d decided to become this thing, this amalgamation of shattered dreams and fading souls.

Feminominatrix took another step. Then another.

In the end, it didn’t matter who was happy. There was no one left to be happy. There was only the horizon, stretching out before her like a scar, and the silence, waiting to swallow them all.
 

GlassRose

Kaleidoscope of Harmonious Contradiction
Joined
Apr 20, 2021
Messages
402
Points
133
They sat there beneath the waning sun, their faces—what was left of them—shadowed and strange. The ritual had been performed. The darkened altar, the whispered words. Each step carried out in perfect cadence, like a sentence passed down long ago, inexorable. Four girls become one. Flesh, melded. Souls, forgotten.

The land around them was dead. No birds cried out, no wind stirred the grass. Just silence. A silence so thick it weighed down the sky. Feminominatrix—though they did not call her that, for names meant little in the void they now inhabited—sat still, looking out into the distance, where nothing awaited her.

And what was there to say?

There were no wishes. No dreams. What they had thought they’d wanted, that too had withered like the brush along the dry creek bed. They were what remained. A thing built of hope that had curdled into despair. She sat alone, and yet not alone. Inside her, the four girls twisted, shadows upon shadows. Jane. Sarah. Lucy. Emma. Once they had names. Now they were just memories rattling through the cage of her bones.

Her skin was flawless, unmarked, perfect. But beneath it was chaos. You couldn’t see it—no, you couldn’t see it—but it was there, the way a knife lurks in a drawer. A terrible violence, silent and waiting.

Jane had wished for beauty, and she had it. Her beauty was such that to look upon her was to feel a kind of pain in the chest, an ache for something lost, something that could never be. But Jane was gone now, her desire stretched out like skin on a drum, taut and brittle. She’d wanted to be beautiful so the world would love her, but the world was gone. And who was left to love but the void itself?

Sarah had wanted competence. A life without failure. A mind so sharp it could cut through the riddles of existence like butter. But what good is competence when all that’s left is the dust? She could solve every problem in the world, and yet the world itself was unsolvable. Sarah's dreams had been eaten by the thing she had become, and now she wandered through Feminominatrix’s mind like a lost dog, scratching at the door of some place she’d forgotten.

Lucy wanted power, and she had it. All the power she could ever want. She could have moved mountains. Split the sea. Commanded the very stars. But there were no stars left. There was only the endless, empty sky. The horizon stretched out before them like a wound. Lucy was still there, she thought, somewhere deep in the marrow of Feminominatrix, but her power meant nothing now. She was a god with no one left to worship her, a king with no throne.

And Emma. Poor Emma. Emma had wanted happiness. Simple, radiant happiness. And when the four of them had fused, when their souls had stitched together into this monstrous unity, for a brief moment, she’d felt it. Joy like a light that could burn through the night. But it had flickered and died, swallowed up by the immensity of what they had become. Now Emma wandered too, lost inside Feminominatrix, searching for that light, knowing she’d never find it. Knowing that happiness had been a lie from the start.

---

The land was flat. It stretched out for miles, the ground cracked and broken, as if the earth itself had given up trying to hold its shape. Feminominatrix walked. There was nowhere to go, but she walked anyway. Perhaps it was a memory of the girls—some trace of the human need to move, to do something, anything, even when there was nothing left to be done. The girls were all fragments now. Thin and ghostly, they twisted inside her like leaves caught in the wind, brittle and faint.

She stopped, staring at the horizon. It was meaningless, a line drawn by gods who no longer cared. The sun hung low, a dead thing in the sky.

Was Feminominatrix happy?

Could happiness exist in a place like this, a place so bereft of meaning that even the earth refused to remember its own shape? She had fulfilled their wishes. The ritual had been perfect. She was all they’d wanted to be—flawless, invincible, a construct of power and beauty. But there was nothing left to want. Nothing left to strive for.

Inside her, Jane whispered. Then Sarah. Then Lucy. Then Emma. Their voices came together, like water dripping in a well. And then they were gone again.

What had they been before? Who were they now? Did it matter? The ritual had made them perfect, but perfection was just another kind of death. And perhaps they had died already. Perhaps they had died the moment they’d decided to become this thing, this amalgamation of shattered dreams and fading souls.

Feminominatrix took another step. Then another.

In the end, it didn’t matter who was happy. There was no one left to be happy. There was only the horizon, stretching out before her like a scar, and the silence, waiting to swallow them all.
Her name is Feminominatrix? No wonder she's unhappy, that's almost as horrible as her conception.
 

melchi

What is a custom title?
Joined
May 2, 2021
Messages
2,870
Points
153
Regular woman that's too beautiful, too competent, too Mary Sue.
You know, if you look at it from a certain perspective this is like a game character in an AAA studio.

Person 1.) You have the writer of her lines.
Person 2.) You have the voice actress.
Person 3.) You have the motion capture person. (not sure what the right term is for this)

All three are working together to make your favorite character.
 
Top