Threads of writing left unshared!

DaelyxLenAuphydas

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 8, 2024
Messages
94
Points
48
So I just thought of this because of my wanting to share some bits of writing in another thread. I ultimately decided not to since it was only somewhat on topic, and it felt kinda scummy to divert it with what might seem like self promotion. But I got to thinking; I often have bits of writing that are not part of my story 'proper' but instead are character interactions or bits displaced from the main story in some way. Sometimes these eventually find their way into the main narrative but more often they just linger around in my big ol' "inspiration document" to help me think about how to flesh out the characters and help keep in sights what their character arc is like.

The problem is, these are often some of my favorite bits of writing, and many of them never actually end up in a story! Or if they do, its so late that it feels so draining trying to wait for them! So I wondered. Does anyone else have sections of writing that they are proud of and want to talk to people about or share with the world, but generally don't because they dont wind up in the actual story? Maybe we could share those kinds of things around, if anyone else has a similar experience.

For my part, I was just talking about sibling relationships in that other thread I mentioned and started thinking about some of the 'inspiration' bits I wrote for my Generation C project which isn't live yet. Some of my favorite writing is in those sections but I dont get to share them around! Well. Here's my chance I'm giving myself, I guess. Have some sibling drama!

“Why would you do something like that!? Did you even think of the consequences? If I hadn’t caught you, you could have… You’d have…” Ceridwen chokes up, unable to finish the statement as he jabs Seren in the chest with his hoof.

Seren bristles in response, glaring back. “And so what if I would have? My life is mine to spend as I wish. I won’t ever see the world I want to without taking risks.”

“That’s… You….” Ceridwen stammers out, staring into Seren’s eyes incredulously, before he finally stomps his hoof back onto the ground, fuming. “Fine. If that’s how it is. But just remember this; When you risk your life, you’re risking two ponies lives. We came into this world together, and I won’t suffer the indignity of lingering in it alone. If you go, I’ll be right behind you, and that’s a promise.”

Seren gnashes her beak in frustration, finally stomping on the ground. “Open your eyes, Starhawk!” She finally shouts, shaking her dejected brother by the shoulder. “None of us would even be here if not for you! Back at Luddas, you were the one who protected me from our father. At Portslamb, you were the miracle that changed the tide of the battle! You found this place to build our new home. Even before the war, when I was wounded and weak when Torrent came for me, you kept him at bay. Hell’s teeth, even the Knights father sent out, you were the one who stopped them! I wouldn’t have even known where to look without your help, back in the archives, without you knowing why I wanted to know. None of us would even be here if not for you.”

Ceridwen shoots a dirty look back. “What, you mean when I betrayed our father’s servants, took advantage of their trust and stabbed them in the back? When I killed my own flesh and blood with my own four hooves? When I left our mother all alone with an army of vengeful revolutionaries?” He quips sardonically. “How about when I chased my own sister down, just to… Get these heavensforsaken feelings for her?”

“Because I keep putting you in these positions!” Seren shouts back. “You suffer the consequences of my actions, and then you’re left to carry all of their weight! When I left you alone back in Luddas, when you had to kill to escape, when I forced you to kill over and over again just to protect me! That was all me, but you’re still saddled with the guilt!” Seren’s voice breaks, as she winces, her heart rising in her throat making it harder to speak.

When she continues, her voice is quiet and unsteady. “Every time I thought my little escapade was at it's end, that I’d gotten as far as I could, you were there to bail me out. My stupid, shortsighted actions caused every problem you’ve ever had, and yet you’re still here with me. I love you, Starhawk, more than you could possibly know. To everypony else, you’re the miracle at Portslamb, who turned the tide when things looked hopeless. Who let us make this whole new world together! But to me, you were my miracle a long, long time before that. Because by our old faith, by the laws that governed our world, you shouldn’t have even been born at all. And yet…” Seren places one hoof below Ceridwen’s beak, steering his eyes to look into her own, brimming with tears. “You were anyways. And because of that, I didn’t have to be alone. And yet despite that, I tried to leave you alone. So please… stop blaming yourself for the fallout of my actions. You’re the only reason any of us are here at all. You’re… the reason I am who I am.”


She’d always believed in romance, never giving it a second thought nor doubt until the events of the promenade. But it wasn’t Rosewine that had made her second guess herself, or set her on this path; She’d always known there were those who would seek to take advantage of her. One stallion deceiving and taking advantage of her did not damn them all.

No, rather her current trajectory of thought was something that had been brewing underneath the surface for almost as long from a different source; her feelings for her brother, Starhawk.

Because she knew that it was wrong to have such attractions to her own flesh and blood. She knew it with a conviction which she had rarely felt for anything else in all of her life. She knew without a shadow of a doubt that those feelings were contradictory, blasphemous when put together. But if that was the case, which half was wrong?

If romance truly is the epitome of love, the highest ideal of attachment that she’d always believed it was, then how could it be that once it touched her family it became flawed? That connection with him struck her as so special. To know that they’d been together since before they were born, that the same blood swam in both their veins. That the same things that made her also made him, like they were two pieces that were only complete when together. How could love felt for the one she shared such a special connection with, the one she’d spent so much time with, the one she adored above all else, be so twisted?

There was only one explanation that could reconcile that dissonance for her. That the feeling she’d started to feel for him, which had poisoned the purity of their bond, was not love at all. How could it be? How could something which had driven her away out of terror that she would defile the perfection of their attachment, be the same thing as the affection she held in her heart for him?

No. That was not love, and never had been.

Seren blinks back tears, an overwhelming feeling of both remorse and joy filling her heart. Remorse at all the feelings she’d felt up to that point, all the things she’d done to keep them apart. And joy because, despite it all, despite what both of them had felt, despite years of silent distance and cruel yearning… They were both still here.

Ceridwen was looking at her unsurely, eyes wide with shock at the sight of her wings. Did he even realize what he’d become yet? It didn’t matter. Seren starts walking, then breaking into a trot, then a canter, and then a full on gallop, unfamiliar limbs spread wide for balance as she collides with him, throwing both forelimbs around his shoulders, embracing him more firmly than she had dared to in years.

“I swear, I must be the luckiest pony in the world.” Seren mutters, closing her eyes tightly. Because, despite everything, he was still her brother, her very flesh and blood. And to her, nothing could ever be more special than that. “Ceridwen Starhawk Llewelydd… I love you more than I thought a pony could ever love anything.”
 

DaelyxLenAuphydas

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 8, 2024
Messages
94
Points
48
Huh. Ya know, I really thought I wouldnt be the only one. But it seems like a lot of people clicked on the thread and absolutely no-one shared their own. That feels... Weird. Sharing on my own just feels awkward...

Well. Whoops, I guess. A classic miscalculation on my part.
 

LeilaniOtter

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 29, 2025
Messages
1,186
Points
113
You're talking about "orphaned" prose, essentially. I really don't have any I can share, or want to. Usually if something isn't working, into the trash it goes. *^^*
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,594
Points
158
Eh, I considered some of mine, sort of. But don't have time to set it up properly.
 

DaelyxLenAuphydas

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 8, 2024
Messages
94
Points
48
Hm. Its honestly surprising to me that more people don't have this kind of thing. I always have an 'inspiration' doc for every single story full of this kinda thing. I wouldnt say its... 'orphaned' exactly, as its usually fulfilling its intended purpose exactly; giving me a chance to visualize what the story might progress into and write down scenes that I have play in my head, even knowing that the version that I end up getting into the story will likely be different. To me this is often one of the first things I start writing in a story.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,594
Points
158
Well, this is one of those things that if I were still able to do two versions of the story (sadly that is verboten) would exist HERE with song lyrics included, but on PocketFM, for legal reasons, without (but I haven't done the version with lyrics, since ... well, there's no point at present).
This is about eight to ten chapters from the current one (and writing it kind of slowed me down with the official version).
“I guess we won,” Audrey said, weakly, and collapsed.
“Audrey!” Malcolm cried, rushing to her side. “Carol! Liz! Do something!”
Both of the women hurried over as her hand fell away, revealing the large hole in Audrey’s side.
Liz looked away, a tear in her eye. “This is beyond my skill, at least without a full hospital and staff to back me.
Carol hung her head down. “I might be able to do something, but I’m too weak after healing Sandra and Dave. I… might be able to ease her pain, but anything more would end my life and probably not help her.”
“Wait,” Liz said, suddenly realizing something, “the stories have several tales of minstrels healing people - even one who raised a recently dead person, and you are, essentially, a minstrel,” she said, turning to Malcolm.
“But… what kind of song? How?”
“Mal,” David said, a little weakly, clearly close to collapse from exhaustion, “what was that one song I saw you two dance to? The only time it happened, I think, that Winter Semi-Formal? Where we all thought you two would be a couple for the ages…”
Malcolm’s eyes narrowed as the memory came to him. “David, if this works, you are a genius and the best friend ever. If it doesn’t, you are more dead than she is, and that’s a promise.” He immediately knew the song, knew the feelings it brought, and knew it was probably the closest to perfect he would ever find… As he pulled out the Lute and began to play, he whispered: “Hold on, dear heart, this has to work…”
Slowly the melody to Journey’s “Open Arms” swelled up, filling the room as the backing instruments joined in, and then Malcolm’s voice opened with the lyrics. At first, it was weak, like he was fighting back tears, but then he used that emotion, poured it into the words of the song.
As his voice grew stronger, he felt power flowing into and through him, more power than he had ever felt in his life. As the song hit a crescendo in the final verse, he felt as if he would burst, and channelled everything he could through the final refrain and into his lover.
And then it was over, and he felt mentally, emotionally and physically drained. His eyes were closed and he was barely conscious until he felt a pair of arms wrap around him and pull him close for a kiss.
He opened his eyes and met Audrey’s brilliant green ones. As their lips parted, he said: “Don’t ever do that to me again.”
“What, die? I have no…”
“Not THAT… Never make me play freaking JOURNEY again…”
She laughed and crushed herself against him.
“Why not? That was amazing - I’ve never really liked your singing before,” Liz said, “you’re not bad, pretty good really, but just don’t have a voice I really like but that - that was perfect. You were meant to sing Journey…”
“Don’t you start…” Malcolm said, half smiling.
“No, she’s right - a bit obnoxious in how she said it,” David added, “but right - that was the best I’ve ever heard you do, and I’ve heard you do some great stuff before.”
“Yeah, Mal - and remember - Don’t Stop Believing…” Carol added, barely able to keep from laughing at her own comment.
“If I weren’t so happy right now, I’d kill you all…” Malcolm replied with a grin.
“You are an idiot, lover,” Audrey chimed in.
“But I’m your idiot,” he replied.
“Yes, Malcolm Samuel Eisenstein, you are my idiot. Care to make it now and forever?”
“Where did you learn my middle name? I don’t think David…”
“I’m a freaking cop, you numbskull. I looked it up when you were a Person of Interest in a case!”
“Oh. Uh… wait… did you… uh… Audrey, did…”
“Yes - since you seem to need a road map for everything today, I asked you to marry me.”
“One question - a Jewish ceremony for my mom or an Irish Catholic one for your family?”
She laughed. “Whichever one you’ll say ‘yes’ to,” she replied, and kissed him again.
Carol stepped closer to them: “It’s a bit too soon, as we still have to deal with D’Gar and his pet Grand Mage yet, but why not a triple ceremony here, with whatever people do, and then we each have little separate ones for friends and family who aren’t here?”
David and Thellissandra exchanged surprised glances, and each nodded. Malcolm looked at Carol, then at Liz, and finally at the other two. “I kind of like that idea, what do you think Audrey?”
“If that’s your way of saying ‘yes’ then I agree, one hundred percent,” she said.
“Then it’s a ‘yes,’” Malcolm replied with a smile, and they kissed again.
“One warning, Mal,” she said when she let him come up for air, “You will sing that song at our wedding…”
“No… wait… why?”
She kissed him again before answering. “Before that night, it was one of my favorite songs and suddenly, what felt like out of the blue, you asked me to dance with you to it, It became even more special. In all the years after, no matter what happened,” she kissed him one more time before continuing, “every time I hear that song, I find myself thinking of you and smiling… No matter where I was or what I was doing. And then I hear you sing it like THAT, with all your heart and soul in it, and … Malcolm, it’s OUR song and you sing it so … masterfully.”
He tried to hide the tear in his eye as Malcolm replied: “After that speech, I’d sing ‘Oh Sherry” at our wedding - and like it.”
“Aww! But, no, dear heart, ‘Open Arms’ will be enough.”
 
Top